|
17th October 1942, Page: 85, Column: 1 Physical Condition Of Mine AirSouth Wales Committee ReportsThird Report on Atmospheric Conditions In Mines: A Study of the Physical Condition of Mine Air. The General Research Committee of the Monmouthshire and South Wales Coal Owners' Association have issued an interim report on the subject of atmospheric conditions in mines. Mr. D. A. Hann is the chairman, and Dr. T. David Jones is the director of research, whilst Mr. F. B. Hinsley, M.Sc, is the investigator. In the preface it is pointed out that effective temperature does not give a very clear picture of the state of the ventilation of a mine ; nevertheless it appears to be a reliable measure of warmth. It is also observed that work on the wet-kata shows this well-tried index to be quite sound in all ordinary temperatures met with underground ; in high underground temperatures it is not quite so satisfactory as a measure of warmth, and the effective temperature index appears to be better. It is further noted "that in the majority of South Wales collieries good ventilating conditions prevail because of the necessity to maintain the ventilation standards of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, from the firedamp standpoint. In this connection firedamp has served as a useful handmaid to the colliery managers, since experience has shown that in general the bad environmental conditions exist in collieries where firedamp does not present a problem. There can be no doubt that good environmental conditions are not only desirable to promote the health and safety of the miner, but they are conducive to satisfactory economic conditions from the standpoint of production." It is gathered from introductory remarks that the report is not concerned with the chemical purity of the ventilating air but rather with its physical condition and the effect of this on the human body. The physical condition of the air in any space depends on its temperature, velocity and humidity, and it is the combination of these factors which produces the feeling of warmth or coolness as experienced by the individual. Mines are becoming deeper and as a result hotter; the viewpoint is gradually gaining favour that oppressively hot atmospheric working conditions are not only uncomfortable and irritating, but are also uneconomic. Hence the provision of pleasant and stimulating atmospheric conditions is becoming of increasing importance. Body Heat. Dealing with heat production and heat loss the report informs that the life processes in the human body are accompanied by considerable energy changes which have their origin in the combustion of the food eaten. The human body is continually giving off heat, so that if the temperature of the body is to remain sensibly constant, there must be a continual generation of heat internally to make up the loss. It has long been recognised that one of the main conditions of a healthy life in man is the maintenance of a constant body temperature. The average mouth temperature maintained by man is about 98.4°F. and the deep tissue temperature is about 99°F. The internal temperature is the result of a delicate balance between the rate at which heat is generated and the speed with which it is rejected. To aid the explanation of the thermal processes of the human body an analogy with a steam power station is employed, and as a result it is obvious that the state of the surface of the body, as to whether dry or wet, is of great importance in promoting heat loss from the body. The surface of the skin may be entirely dry, entirely wet or partly dry and partly wet. With a dry skin cooling takes place by radiation and convection if the air temperature is well below body temperature. If the dry-bulb temperature of the air is above that of the body, heat will flow from the air to the body and a rise of body temperature and heat stroke will result. The higher the air velocity the faster will the body gain heat. With the skin entirely wet with sweat, conditions are totally different. Cooling of the body now takes place by evaporation and the cooling of a wet body has been shown to be dependent almost entirely on the wet-bulb temperature and rate of air movement. The rate of heat loss from the wet body is not affected to any great extent by rise of dry-bulb temperature even above body temperature if the wet-bulb temperature remains constant as the relative humidity is decreased and the rate of evaporation increased. If the wet-bulb temperature is below body temperature, then there is the possibility of obtaining sufficient cooling by increase of air motion. The surface of the skin may be partly wet and partly dry. The cooling of the dry parts will depend on the dry-bulb temperature and the cooling of the wet portions will depend on the wet-bulb temperature. If the dry-bulb temperature is above body temperature and the wet-bulb temperature is below, then the dry parts will, be warmed and the wet parts cooled. The entire surface of the skin is seldom dry because of insensible sweating. With sweating of this kind there is no visible sign of moisture on the skin. Under normal temperatures in this country evaporation of moisture goes on at the surface of the skin and the individual is quite unconscious of the process. Visible sweating is helpful in heat rejection from the body so long as it evaporates on the surface ; any sweat which runs off is lost as far as body cooling is concerned. It has been noted that where men sweat in an atmosphere low in evaporative capacity there is a tendency to develop a skin rash and boils. Dr. S. W. Fisher has found that this is noticeable when the wet-bulb temperature exceeds 75°F. Measurement of Separate Factors. The separate physical factors which affect the transfer of heat from the human body are the temperature of the atmosphere, the humidity, the rate of air movement, and the temperature of the surroundings. It is usual in mine ventilation work to observe dry-bulb temperatures on a whirling hygrometer, and the rapid movement of the instrument reduces the radiation error to negligible proportions. The dry-bulb temperature is so-called because it is measured by a thermometer with a moisture-free bulb which is not affected by the water-vapour in the air. The wet-bulb temperature is useful in the study of atmospheric humidity ; it is obtained from a thermometer whose bulb is encased in a cotton wick and moistened with distilled water. Positive motion of the air must be induced over the wet-bulb, otherwise the temperature registered will be inaccurate. This is accomplished by the employment of a whirling hygrometer. The method of making an observation on a whirling hygrometer is as follows : The instrument is rotated rapidly in the air being investigated, and the readings of both thermometers taken when the wet-bulb temperature is a minimum. If the air is unsaturated, the wet-bulb temperature will be lower than the dry-bulb temperature, due to the evaporation of moisture at the wetted thermometer bulb. When air is saturated, its dry- and wet-bulb temperatures are identical and its relative humidity is 100 per cent. The position of the wet-bulb temperature in unsaturated air is between the dew point and the dry-bulb temperatures. With saturated air, the dew point, dry- and wet-bulb temperatures are the same. If no moisture is added or taken away from the air the temperature of the dew point remains constant. In work on comfort conditions air movement is not always unidirectional and it is an advantage to use methods which take eddying currents into account. The kata thermometer is a useful instrument to employ in such conditions as it is reliable at low air speeds and records the effects of eddying currents. It measures the air movement which is effective for cooling and should not be used for quantatitive work in mine ventilation except where the flow is unidirectional. Air speeds as low as 10 feet per minute can be measured with considerable accuracy. For the measurement of air speeds in high air temperatures a special high-temperature kata has been devised. The employment of this instrument cuts down the cooling times and allows air speed measurements to be made more correctly at air temperatures above about 85°F. The temperature of the surroundings, say the rock surfaces underground, affect the heat gain or loss by the body due to radiation. . . Mr. B. R. Lawton has done some work on the relation between the surface temperature of exposed strata and the air temperature in working places. Observations were made in nine seams at depths varying from 1,900 to 3,900 feet. He came to the conclusion that the effect of radiation underground is negligible as, generally speaking, the difference of temperature between the exposed strata and the air was small; the cooling effect of the air-current upon the strata being rapid. American workers have approached the subject of the warmth conditions by attempting to give a thermal value to the effect of air movement and humidity on the human senses. Effective temperature is a measure of the air conditions which affect the human feelings, and gives in one figure the resultant of the dry-bulb temperature, the humidity and the velocity of the air-combinations of temperature; humidity and air velocity which induce the same feeling of warmth are called thermo-equivalent conditions, which are claimed to indicate both the sensation of warmth and the physiological effects on the body induced by heat and cold. Effective temperatures cannot be measured on a thermometer, but are obtained from tables or specially drawn charts. The numerical value of the scale was fixed for convenience at the value where the wet- and dry-bulb temperatures agree, that is, at saturation. Thus, any air condition has an effective temperature of 70°, for instance, when it induces a sensation of warmth like that experienced in calm air at 70° saturated with moisture. Summaries are given in the report of tests and investigations, and it is then pointed out that acclimitisation is a factor of extreme importance in the working of hot and deep mines. A miner working in a hot part of a mine becomes accustomed to warm air and atmospheric conditions which would cause acute discomfort to the average individual not used to those conditions. Dr. J. S. Haldane was of the opinion that hot and moist conditions, up to a certain point, had no effect or the health of the miner. The limit above which it was not advisable to go was when the body temperature continued to rise. Dr. S. W. Fisher states that in some mines acclimitisation is brought about in a methodical manner ; for example, at a certain mine new men take a day off after a day or two at work until they have become used to the conditions ; working in fast ends had the effect of making most of the men listless and fagged out at this mine ; this was alleviated by the men taking turns in the fast end. There was no evidence that working in high temperatures was prejudicial to health, although Dr. Fisher had noticed that only strong men can do it. Results of Investigation. The investigation undertaken by the General Research Committee is an extension of an inquiry into the comfort of atmospheric conditions which was carried out by Professor T. David Jones in 1939 in connection with the causes of silicosis in mines. It was desired (a) to make a general survey of the atmospheric conditions in South Wales mines, and (b) to compare the two measures of warmth, viz., wet-kata cooling power and effective temperature. In the report details are given of six surveys illustrating the variety of conditions met with. In each case the traverse started at the bottom of the downcast shaft and travelled downstream along the intake airways, through the coal face and return airways and back to the bottom of the Upcast shaft. The appended summary and conclusions are given in the report. The investigation shows that unpleasant atmospheric working conditions can exist where air temperatures are relatively low, if air movement is lacking. Suitable air velocity is the most important factor in the production of proper underground atmospheric conditions. This is fortunate as it is the one factor under the control of the mine manager. In average air temperatures the anemometer provides a useful indication of the suitability of the air conditions. Where velocities of over 150 feet per minute are maintained, working conditions are usually quite pleasant. High velocities, however, may produce too rapid cooling and the men will have the feeling of being in a draught. Dust also becomes a nuisance in high velocities. The best conditions would appear to exist when air velocities are between 150 and 450 feet per minute. These values are recommended for air having dry-bulb temperatures less than 75°F. Above 75°F. a higher range of air velocities is required in order to produce the necessary cooling effect. Air movement seems to stimulate the worker whereas stagnant air appears to have the opposite effect. This quality of "freshness" apparently cannot be evaluated in terms of temperature. Effective temperature is incomplete as a measure of the suitability of working atmospheres because any maximum value which may be fixed can be obtained without recourse to air movement. It is only when the stagnant temperature conditions reach the upper limit of effective temperature which has been fixed, that air movement becomes necessary. Actually, for the best conditions some degree of air movement is essential at all temperatures. As a measure of warmth of hot underground atmospheric conditions, effective temperature was found to be greatly superior to wet-kata cooling power. The wet-kata thermometer is useful as an indicator of the fitness of ventilation conditions because air movement has a much greater cooling effect on it than on the human body. It is more sensitive as an anemometer than the human feelings, with the result that the effect of air movement is exaggerated as a means of cooling the body. The wet-kata cooling power also takes temperature and humidity into account but gives greatest prominence to air movement. From the mining point of view this is advantageous as low velocities are likely to give low wet-kata cooling powers, thus indicating poor conditions. This over-estimation of the effect of air movement, however, causes the wet-kata cooling power to be inaccurate as a measure of warmth. Wet-kata cooling power gives a measure of the "freshness" of the atmospheric conditions. The following figures are put forward as a rough guide as to what wet-kata cooling powers are likely to indicate good conditions. For wet-bulb temperatures less than about 70°F., good conditions are given by wet-kata cooling powers between 15 and 25. For wet-bulb temperatures above 70°F., this good conditions band should be raised to between 20 and 30. These figures are not suggested as standards to be enforced, but simply as representing good conditions, the production of which should be the aim of the colliery manager. It is necessary to increase the wet-kata cooling power with increase in wet-bulb temperature as the cooling effect of air movement decreases with increase of wet-bulb temperature. Neither wet-kata cooling power nor effective temperature gives a complete impression of the warmth comfort of a given underground atmosphere. Both together they give a clearer idea of the conditions than either does singly. The clearness of the impression is further enhanced if the dry-bulb and wet-bulb temperatures and the air velocity are specified. Effective temperature and Wet-kata cooling power are not antagonistic, but to some extent are complementary, both giving restricted but different aspects of the more complete impression of the warmth comfort of a given set of conditions as perceived by the working individual. Thus the colliery manager desirous of testing the suitability of his underground conditions should obtain the dry-bulb temperature, wet-bulb temperature, air speed, wet-kata cooling power and effective temperature. These data combined with a little experience will supply a fairly complete picture of the atmospheric conditions. The results of the present investigation are in agreement with those of other workers in this field in showing the relationship between the wet-kata cooling power and effective temperature to be extremely complex. Any single value of one index corresponds to a range of the other and vice versa. Hence fixing a value of one index as a minimum does not mean that some corresponding value of the other index has simultaneously been fixed. The investigation also shows that dry-kata cooling power can be employed as a measure of ventilation efficiency in a restricted range of relatively low air temperatures. It is a useful measure in air temperatures up to about 75°F. dry-bulb. With higher temperatures its cooling time may be inconveniently long. The dry-kata cooling power is not reliable when air temperatures are in the region of its cooling range, say above 85°F. When the air temperature exceeds 97.5°F., dry-kata cooling power becomes negative or is a warming power. The present work has also shown that high temperature kata cooling power as employed for velocity determinations, can be used as a ventilation standard. In the range of conditions dealt with, a high temperature kata cooling power of 15 will ensure a minimum wet-kata cooling power of about 15 and a maximum effective temperature of about 80°.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||