8th August 1942, Page: 25, Column: 1
Conveyor Dust Problem
Report on Water Sprays
Extracts from the 2nd report on Coal Dust Research issued by the Midland
Counties Colliery Owners' Association, dealing with the Use of Sprays to
Suppress Dust on Underground Conveyors.
The recently issued report of the Midland Counties Colliery Owners' Association
describes tests carried out with water sprays at conveyor loading and transfer
points for settling coal dust clouds. As explained in the foreword the
apparatus dealt with is simple and inexpensive, but good results can be
obtained provided the sprays are correctly positioned. Installation is not
difficult, little maintenance is required, and if suitable sprays are used
there is no danger of damaging conveyor belts or causing floor creep. It is
stated that mists formed with the aid of compressed air are more effective than
water sprays, but good results can be obtained with the latter.
The Committee record their appreciation of the work of Mr. J. T. Barclay,
B.Sc, the investigator, and of valuable assistance given by
colliery managements and officials. Extracts from the report are appended.
Spraying with water was probably the first method of dust suppression to be
adopted in coal mines, and sprays have been in use on haulage roads for many
years in some parts of the country. The simplicity of a system of spraying
compared with the more complicated methods of dust collection has much to
recommend it, especially under the difficult war-time conditions at present
prevailing, and advantage can be taken of the fact that water is now often
available throughout a mine from the mains laid down in connection with
fire-fighting requirements.
Conveyor Loading and Transfer Points.
Although sprays have been used at one time or another to deal with coal dust at
nearly every point where it may be produced, it is at conveyor loading or
transfer points that they have been most commonly employed. In general the
methods that have been adopted for dealing with this problem may be grouped
under the following headings :—
(1) Suppression of the dust by sprays or mists.
(2) Collection by apparatus employing for treatment of the dust-laden air (i)
Internal water sprays ; (ii) Filtration by (a) fabric filters, (b) metal wood
filters ; (iii) Cyclone separators ; (iv) Passing through water.
(3) Removal of dusty air to a dead end where the dust can be deposited.
(4) Treatment of the coal before it reaches the loading or transfer point.
Some of the methods of collection referred to under Group 2 above are very
efficient, but their use has not become general; many collieries prefer to use
a simple spray system even though its efficiency may not be so high. The
reasons for this preference would appear to be that most of the collectors
occupy considerable space and are rather costly ; they usually require the
enclosure of the loading point by a hood or canopy (which some managements
consider interferes with loading operations), and in particular they appear to
require a considerable amount of skilled attention to maintain them in
efficient running order. A spray system may not have such a high efficiency,
but it is extremely simple and requires very little attention — it can be
kept in order by the loaders or belt attendants. Naturally these factors are of
particular importance under present war-time conditions when skilled labour is
scarce and materials difficult to obtain.
It should be noted, however, that shrouding or enclosing the loading point is
also a big advantage when using sprays. It has the effect of concentrating the
dust under the sprays and preventing the air-current from blowing it away
before it can be damped.
It should also be clearly understood that much of the dust from gate conveyors
comes not from the loading or transfer points but is thrown off by the movement
of the belt itself; this is best treated by removal and collection by one of
the simple forms of belt cleaners.
Types of Jets and Sprays.
Fine coal dust is notoriously difficult to wet with water and a spray to be
effective must be very fine in character, though not so fine that the water
evaporates before it can wet the dust. The action of a good spray is to damp
the dust and cause it to settle quickly at or near the point of production.
Sprays designed to work with water alone under pressure may be classified
according to the means by which the water is atomised in the jet. The types now
obtainable commercially may be divided into three groups : (1) In which the
water is given a rotary or swirling action before passing through the outer
orifice ; (2) In which the water is passed through an annular jet fitting over
a cone ; (3) In which the water impinges against a pointed or cone-shaped
revolving target. Jets of the second group produce a rather coarse spray. Most
sprays now in use fall in the first group.
Two types of the latter class are in common use. In one the swirling motion is
obtained by passing the water through grooves cut spirally through the threads
of a screw which fits inside the nozzle ; the water is then ejected through a
small hole situated at the centre. This is similar to the ordinary white-wash
spray. In the other the swirling motion is obtained by passing the water
through two diaphragms with a small space between them ; the inner one has
holes drilled tangentially and the outer one a small hole at the centre. This
latter type, of which the "Royle" is a good example, has been found
to be by far the most satisfactory. Two sprays of the former type fixed over a
chute at a loading point (without covering) produced a reduction in the
quantity of dust dispersed into the air of 34.5 per cent., whereas two sprays
of the latter type (gun metal jets' with two diaphragms and a filter) gave 45
per cent. reduction.
Of the sprays produced by compressed air and water, though of limited
application in the Notts and Derbyshire coalfield, there are several types
available. Probably the best type is that in which there are inner and outer
concentric nozzles, each connected to one of two reservoirs or compartments at
the rear. In one form the inner nozzle is connected to the compressed air and
the outer to the water ; in another form the arrangement is vice-versa. This
type of spray produces a very fine mist and, provided the pressure of the
compressed air and of the water is correctly adjusted, is very satisfactory.
These jets are usually arranged in groups or "batteries" of five or
seven, either in a circular form or in line from a pipe or rectangular
compartment, according to the form of spray desired, but they can, of course,
be used singly.
Water under pressure is required for the above type, but there is a form of jet
somewhat similar which will use static water, e.g., from a barrel or tank. In
this form the compressed air jet inside a cone-shaped nozzle draws the water
from the reservoir by forming a partial vacuum behind the orifice.
In another form of compressed air operated jet, the water under pressure is
projected from a nozzle immediately in front of the compressed air nozzle, with
or without a baffle plate.
The "Hay" Mist Projector is another form of compressed air operated
apparatus which is well-known and extensively used in headings ; in this
apparatus about five gallons of water to which 4 oz. of powdered washing soda
has been added is expelled (from a drum) in the form of a mist by means of
compressed air.
The water (and air) consumption of all the above types varies greatly according
to the pressure. It will be sufficient to mention that the "Royle"
type of water spray consumes from 3 to 10 gallons per hour at 20 lb. per square
inch water pressure, up to 20 gallons per hour at 100 lb. per square inch
pressure or more. The first type of compressed air operated spray mentioned,
with inner and outer concentric nozzles, consumes from 2 to 7 gallons of water
per hour per jet according to pressure and the compressed air consumption from
3 to 10 cubic feet of free air per minute per jet, according to pressure.
A form of mist projector that has been under consideration, during the
investigation is used for humidifying the air in textile factories, and employs
an entirely different method of atomisation from the other forms of sprays
previously mentioned. A jet of water is projected on to a cone-shaped disc
which is directly coupled to a small electric motor and revolves at speeds up
to 2,000 r.p.m. The water is thrown off at the periphery by centrifugal force
at a very high velocity and strikes a series of fixed blades or baffles
arranged concentrically. It is thus split up into the form of a very fine mist
which is projected forward by the draught from a propeller fitted at the back
of the electric motor. This mist is extremely fine and the possibility of
adapting the device for use in dealing with dust suppression underground is
being considered. Certain alterations to ensure the apparatus being flameproof
will, of course, be required.
Sprays at Inbye Points on Conveyors.
The majority of the spray systems so far installed have been at the main
loading points of gate belt conveyors where the coal is delivered into the
tubs. This means that the dust is being dealt with after most of it has already
been formed, and it appears probable that a better method is to damp the coal
dust as near to the face as possible so that it will not be dispersed when it
reaches the main loading point.
An arrangement of sprays at the point where coal is fed on to a gate or trunk
conveyor not only improves the conditions around that point but at the main
loading point also. This is shown by the results of some tests in the Silkstone
Seam at a colliery in Derbyshire. A single "Royle" type spray was
fixed at each of the two inbye points where the coal was fed on to a trunk belt
conveyor — one point was 220 yards inbye from the main loading point, the
other 360 yards. The fine dust (passing through 60 mesh B.S.S. sieve) deposited
within 50 yards of the main loading point was immediately reduced by 30 per
cent. on one side of the road and 42 per cent. on the other (a difference in
the effect on the two sides of a road is often noticed due to the position of
the conveyor, etc.). The addition of two sprays at the chute on the main
loading point increased the reduction in deposition of the dust to 55 per cent.
on both sides, The chutes and transfer points were not covered in any way ; the
air was travelling inbye.
An even more interesting result was obtained at another colliery working the
Blackshale Seam. In this case the conveyor road lay between the intake and the
return, and four doors were fixed on one side for travelling where the belt
itself passed through an air lock consisting of a brick tunnel with numerous
rubber sheets hung within. There is always a lot of trouble with dust at such
places due to the high velocity of the air leaking through the sheets blowing
coal dust off the belt. Seven compressed-air type water jets were fixed in a
pipe extending across the gate belt at the point where the face conveyors
delivered on to it. The coal was thus sprayed as it came on to the gate belt
and the dust being damp when it reached the air lock a big improvement was
observed.
The results clearly indicate that spraying should not be confined to the main
loading point but should commence at the first opportunity after the coal
leaves the face. This involves in most cases extending the pipe line regularly
as the face advances, but if the loading point is to be moved up and the road
used for haulage it only means that the fire-fighting mains are laid down
somewhat earlier than would otherwise be the case.
It has not been found that this arrangement has the effect of wetting the belt,
provided the sprays are correctly adjusted to give a fine spray or mist and
that they are turned off when the flow of coal ceases. As there is commonly a
man or boy in attendance at transfer or inbye loading points this should
present no difficulty. In the case of compressed air operated sprays near the
face, the supply of air can be taken off the pipe line to the face conveyor
engines so that when the face conveyors stop the sprays stop also.
Position of Sprays.
Whatever type of spray is used the whole question of success or failure depends
on the position and manner in which the sprays are fixed. The manner of setting
must therefore be carefully studied.
The first point proved by the tests is that sprays are more effective directed
against the air-current than with it.
The advantage gained by directing the spraying against, i.e., in opposite
direction to the movement of the dust cloud, is presumably the introduction of
a time lag which increases the possibility of a collision between the particles
of water and the particles of dust.
The majority of loading points are equipped with chutes of various types and
sprays are often employed in these. If this is done, however, a spray should
always be fixed to deal with the dust underneath or at the back of the chute
rising out of the tub, otherwise little improvement may be effected. In general
a single spray is insufficient at any large loading point; at least two or
three are required, and spraying must take place above and beneath the chute.
Where compressed air operated sprays are used groups of up to seven jets have
been employed at one point with success ; this type by producing a finer mist
is less likely to cause trouble by surplus water.
At several loading points inspected where sprays produced by water alone were
in use, the arrangement was to have two sprays above the chute and one
underneath. Where the chute has high sides it is a decided advantage to set the
sprays, from a T-piece or by other means, as so to form a barrage of mist right
across the full width of the chute and thus prevent dust blowing away and
escaping around the edges of the spray.
In the tests so far carried out, the sprays have had no appreciable effect on
the humidity of the general body of the air in the districts as determined by
hygrometric readings, but this is a point that would have to be watched in the
case of a deep and hot mine.
Conclusions.
The results are given of tests in typical seams, and conclusions arrived at are
stated in brief thus :—
1. Water or mist sprays, while they do not give such good results as can be
obtained by the use of dust collectors, can be made to effect very big
improvements in the dust conditions at conveyor loading or transfer points when
the use of the other forms of apparatus is not considered desirable. They
require much less attention to keep in efficient working order.
2. Compressed air operated water sprays are superior to sprays operated by
water pressure alone because of the greater degree of atomisation, but their
use is rather limited in the Notts. and Derbyshire coalfield. Hence further
investigation to improve the performance of sprays which do not require
compressed air, is desirable.
3. Big improvements in the dust conditions can be obtained by spraying at the
inbye or face ends of gate conveyors ; spraying should not be limited to the
main loading points where it only affects a limited area. Spraying at inbye
points improves the conditions throughout the road.
4. To obtain the best results care must be taken in the setting of the sprays.
As far as is convenient sprays should always be directed against the
air-current, not with it. They should never be set in such a position or such a
pressure employed that they stir up the dust in the tub.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Barclay, J. T. | | Investigator | |