Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th June 1942, Page: 348, Column: 1

Recruitment And Training Of Labour And Officials

Extracts from paper on "The Recruitment and Training of Labour and Officials: with Special Reference to the Lancashire Coalfield," read at the May meeting of the Manchester Geological and Mining Society.

By E. H. Browne, B.A.

Lack of Attraction of Industry.

Until recent times there was a stock of mining folk of whom generations had gone to the collieries and boasted of it. A man would say : "My father, and his father before him, worked down the pit; my boy will come with me." Now he says : "I'll find my lad a better job than his father had — and it's not going to be in the pit" ; and he will place his son in any other industry. Doubtless this is partly due to wider choice of employment, but I am satisfied that it is not the whole cause.

Significant, too, is the parents' attitude. It is not mainly that the boys themselves do not want to go to the pit; home influence deters them. Labour Exchange managers can tell of frequent cases where they have arranged for a boy to start at a local colliery, but one of the parents has visited the Exchange later and asked for some other employment instead. Yet physical conditions underground, and terms of employment, have all been greatly enhanced. Nor can it be agreed that money is the paramount influence in the question. There are other factors to be considered and these include :—

(1) The Attitude of Education Authorities in Certain Cases. — Many schoolmasters have totally erroneous ideas about underground conditions. Anxious to do the best for the boys they have brought up, they sow the seeds of dislike of mining in the minds of their boys. Nor are they free of the widespread misconception that the mining industry exploits youth. This can be emphatically denied. Boys are in themselves of limited value in the pit; it is their future manhood that is required.

(2) The Slump and Unemployment. — The miner has a long memory, and he does not have to look many years back to depression and unemployment. Despite the improvement in recent years, the miner remains sceptical and is not yet impressed by hope of security in the industry.

(3) The Tendency of the Country as a whole to prefer Clerical to Manual Work. — This is too deep seated a question for discussion here, but it may be suggested that education authorities are partly to blame. Many schoolmasters are entirely out of touch with modern life and industry, and the milieu in which their charges will have to live and work. Usually they encourage their most intelligent boys to take up office jobs. They are not merely opposed to colliery work but to manual work as a whole, as compared with black-coated jobs.

(4) Disputes and Labour Difficulties. — These deter the peaceful minded.

(5) Backshift Work. — Special stress should be laid on this, and consideration given as to whether work by night or afternoon is not becoming anachronistic. It must also be realised that the proportion of night and afternoon work has been greatly increased by the introduction of machine mining, and that the unpopularity of these shifts is reflected in absenteeism. It will, I know, be loudly disputed that the backshift work is demanded by present methods of mining, and that it is both safer and more efficient to maintain the 24-hour cycle. This may, or may not, be so, purely from the mining point of view, but the benefits may well be outweighed by consideration due to labour. Better, surely, in the face of danger of labour shortage, to see to what extent machine mining methods can be adapted to a reduced proportion of work in the backshifts.

(6) The Loss of the Simple Method of Recruitment (and of Training) Inherent in Hand Getting Methods. — Here is a main cause of present difficulty. In the days of hand-getting the family business of a stall worked well and was a great advantage. After a year or two on the haulage, a boy would be employed by his father, who would teach and train him his craft. This system has gone, and nothing specific has replaced it apart from haphazard methods. Let me interpolate that this Paper is not intended to compare machine mining with hand-getting practice, neither to welcome, nor certainly to decry, the change ; but where new problems have been introduced these must be examined in their effect upon recruitment and training. The lack of adequate training schemes is very deplorable. Although such things can only develop slowly, it is unfortunate that to-day very little training is given and men are expected to learn by observation only.

(7) The Loss of Craftsmanship. — Here again changed conditions have had their effect. The old collier was a craftsman ; his present day counterpart is to a greater extent a labourer. There has been greater specialisation and some jobs are more skilled, but this is by no means the same as all-round craftsmanship. Craft implies pleasure in training and leads naturally towards it. Its loss decreases interest.

(8) Lack of Discipline. — No one will deny that discipline is weaker than heretofore. It may be that harsh treatment of men has been lessened thereby, but a fair and reasonable discipline is undoubtedly beneficial to the general weal. A pit gets a good name thereby and happiness is engendered. The converse is equally true.

(9) Communal work in larger sets of men as frequently demanded by machine mining methods is less attractive than work in the more personal and smaller set. Miners are great individualists in their way.

(10) Organisation. — Times and methods have changed and underground organisation has not kept up with them. Perhaps this is due to problems of training ; the rigidity of statutory requirements has also greatly militated against experiment and progress.

(11) Large Companies. — The loss of personal touch and, in some cases, family interest, owing to the formation of large companies, has in many instances been associated with a decline in popularity of the concerns accordingly. It is true to say that most big firms are less well spoken of by employees, especially junior officials, than smaller undertakings, although the grounds for this may be unfair.

There is evidently a tendency for the larger unit to be subject to greater suspicion. With small companies benefit was derived from a competitive spirit amongst workmen. Loyalties existed in some cases ; these might appear only under provocation, but gave the individual a personal interest. The large company tends, unless special steps are taken to mitigate this danger, to appear the more a machine. This may well be another deterrent to new entrants to the industry.

Shortage of Officials: Suggested Remedies.

Despite all the well-known objections, the mining profession has many attractions which are not generally recognised. It provides variety and interest, and in contrast to the average industrial factory the circumstances and nature of work change constantly ; the basic nature of the commodity produced lends a purpose to the work ; it is a man's job ; it produces comradeship and mutual respect comparable only with the sea ; above all, it has a unique consuming interest for those who become fascinated by it.

In general, to obtain the boys necessary to rejuvenate and maintain the life of the industry, and to recruit the officials required to run it, the coalfield must make employment more attractive in appearance and in fact. The following remedies are suggested :—

(1) Recruitment should be aided by sound propaganda. Education Authorities should be given a true picture and a fair conception of conditions underground. Such propaganda should be mainly directed towards parents as well as boys themselves. Unreasonable attitude of Press, particularly in the event of a disaster, should be tackled.

(2) Mining men should take a greater interest in education and the schools, and exert themselves with the authorities. Much doubt could be dispelled and error corrected if schoolmasters were invited underground from time to time. There are the Education Boards and Committees where representation of the industry would not be resisted if approached via the usual channels. Liaison is also desirable with the Secondary Schools, and to a limited extent with Public Schools.

(3) Great efforts should be made to reduce the proportion of backshift work.

(4) Craft training schemes for workmen should be introduced, and craftsmanship and pride in it stimulated. Some consideration might be given to a reversion to non-specialisation.

(5) Training of officials, starting with selection on proved merit, should be provided. This should embrace better opportunities for promotion, and a reasonable scale of remuneration during training for senior positions.

(6) Every effort should be made to build up a reasonable and fair discipline in the pit.

(7) The layout of faces requiring large sets of men working together should be modified where friction is created amongst men. Alternatively, small sets of men working on yardage rates within the faces may be organised successfully.

(8) Underground organisation should catch up (as it will) with mechanisation.

(9) Large companies should examine the special problems they have created for workmen and officials.

(10) The delegation of responsibility and work to each grade of official should be carefully studied, and the administration should see that each grade has scope for interest.

(11) Remuneration of officials should be related on a proper basis to that of workmen.

(12) Officials should be encouraged to regard themselves as belonging to a corporate body sharing the responsibilities carried by the staff of a colliery as a whole.

(13) Officials' Insurance and Pension Schemes should be universally adopted.

If by these or other remedies, satisfactory recruitment of men and officials can be obtained, then interest may be turned to methods of training.

Training Methods.

In considering ways and means of training, the following basic principles should be used for guidance.

(1) Although some of the initiative must come from the individual, the time has arrived when the industry must go out itself to provide itself with trained officials.

(2) All training schemes must categorise to a certain extent the status for which each section will endeavour to equip trainees, but there must be complete flexibility between these sections. There must be every opportunity for the best types in any sphere to move on to the next; under no circumstances must the goal be predetermined. In the suggested outline, and in schemes which may be adopted at collieries, it will be found convenient to set out a training policy in sub-divisions arbitrarily headed by the grade for which the scheme mainly provides and to which most participants will reach. But this will not imply that individuals will not pass through, nor, I fear, that all will reach the grade in question. There is much difficulty in selection, particularly amongst younger people, and there are bound to be mistakes and disappointments, but against these will be set the cases where men develop far better than anticipated. It is impossible in the early stages to tell what status a man may eventually realise.

(3) There must be no rigidity in limitation to the making of appointments from men who have been through the courses. There must be scope for the man who rises otherwise and who can equip himself by other means. It would be a great disservice to the industry to stereotype the lives of those destined for official status. Uniformity and systematisation would kill rather than cure.

(4) The peculiar combination of qualities required by those who are to be successful administrative officials is very selective.

It is no stigma for a man to be found unsuitable for a position in the direct line of management. In some cases it may be, paradoxically, the best of men who are so rejected. Fortunately the growing demands of specialism will be met by such individuals who will be led towards it. Many sub-divisions of the training will therefore provide for specialist positions of corresponding status in the staff of the colliery company.

(5) The training schemes should be provided mainly for employees at the pits to develop their capabilities, but recruitment from the Universities of a proportion of young men is also desirable. Fresh blood improves the stock and, particularly in a large company, the mixture of two elements provides a lively and mentally energetic staff.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Browne, E. H.      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print