Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

16th May 1942, Page: 309, Column: 1

Mechanisation And Falls Of Ground Accidents

Extracts from paper read at the April meeting of the Manchester Geological and Mining Society. Continued from page 304.

By A. Winstanley, M.B.E., D.Sc, H.M. Inspector of Mines.

Systems of Support.

The various systems of support in operation at mechanised faces can be divided according to the support provided to the roof of the cutter track, as this largely affects both the liability to falls and the coincident presence of persons.

(1) Cutter Track Unsupported. — There seems to be no doubt that lack of support to the roof of the cutter track is a serious omission, because it results in too much time spent under newly exposed unsecured roof.

(2) Systems Providing Support to the Cutter Track. — Undoubtedly, there are great benefits to be obtained from setting a row of props close to the coal immediately after cutting, and it should not involve consumption of a greater number of props, because the props so set are recovered by the strippers.

(3) Roof Over Cutter Track Partly Supported. — In some systems, some support is provided by using straps either needled into the coal or only partly overhanging the cutter track from the front row of props. A little support is thus provided to the roof due to the strength of the overhanging part of the strap, but deficiency in support to the roof after removal of the holing sprags still exists and little protection is given to the strippers ahead of the permanent propping system.

Support at Roadheads and Gate Ends.

At roadheads and gate ends there is a marked concentration of falls of ground accidents. For the purpose of analysis of support three areas can be considered separately : (a) The road itself up to the ripping face ; (b) The ripping face and sides ; (c) From the ripping face to the coal face. The aim is adequate and stable support with the minimum of time spent within range of falls from unsecured or insufficiently secured roof or sides.

(a) The Road Itself to the Ripping Face. — Where the presence of machinery prevents setting permanent supports close in to the ripping, a system of temporary supplementary support is needed. For this purpose, props and lids, props and bars, stretchers from the last road support to the ripping face, and supported on props or on needled cross bars, extension girders fitted in brackets on the last two or three permanent supports, and extended forward to the ripping face, have all been adopted with varying degrees of success. Those types of support which can be set soonest after the ripping has been taken down have the advantage of providing support while the dirt from the ripping is being cleaned up. Where the overhang amounts to several feet an obvious precaution, and a desirable precaution in any case, is to sprag or stell the road supports so that they cannot be overturned by the weight of roof on the extension supports.

The position immediately after the ripping has been blasted or otherwise taken down is very important. The procedure should be arranged so that temporary support is applied immediately, and the permanent supports advanced as soon as possible afterwards. The practice of leaving the erection of the supports until the debris has been cleared away is very bad, and to postpone the setting of the permanent supports until the next day as sometimes is the case is even worse. The proper course is to have the supports set so that the minimum of time is spent under the unsecured roof.

(b) The Ripping Face. — Especially where ripping is by shots, the ripping face itself, and the sides also, may have been shattered. Main roof breaks and inherent weaknesses, whether visible or not, should be presumed to exist, and it should be remembered that both lateral and vertical movements are always going on.

Temporary sprags can usually be set to the ripping face from the debris, but these are rarely secure enough and they may be disturbed as the debris is being cleared away. Various telescopic-stretchers have been devised for setting across ripping faces, with the ends let into needle holes in the sides. These can be set as soon as the face has been dressed, and it is usual to fit backing pieces of wood behind them. Planks are also used as stretchers in the same way, and after removal of debris at suitable places sprags are got from the floor to these planks. In some cases, where the sides are too soft to hold the stretchers, brackets are fitted on the last two road supports, and extension girders are fitted in them. These girders are pushed forward so that their ends are tight against the ripping face, and then cross stretchers are supported on the extension girders; or they are fitted in shoes on the ends of the girders. These ripping face supports have been found quite effective, but the overhang of the extension girders should be kept as short as possible by keeping the road supports, which carry them, advanced close to the ripping face.

(c) Between the Ripping Face and the Coal Face. — Besides the ordinary systematic setting of props and lids or props and bars at the coal face, the presence of machinery, and the obvious need for extra support, to the roof extending back to the ripping lip, has resulted in fairly widespread use of supplementary long wood bars, corrugated steel straps, or channels or girders, set either parallel with or at right angles to the face, beneath the ordinary supports. These supplementary supports need to be arranged so that they can be withdrawn at the ripping face with the minimum of disturbance, and always leaving adequate support immediately under the ripping lip. Sometimes under the ripping lip one or more built-up steel, or wood chocks, are used in addition to the long bars, to give additional stability to the supports near the ripping lip. It is very important to make provision for the inevitable height loss between roof -and floor to be taken by all props and chocks set between the coal face and the ripping face.

The benefits obtained from supplementary support under ripping lips, with proper provision for ensuring stability, by provision for height loss and by spragging or tying the lip support to prevent it from swinging out laterally, are obvious, and their xise at all roadheads is strongly recommended.

Combined Scaffold and Support Frame for Roadheads.

A very good arrangement, being used to an increasing extent at roadheads, consists of a steel girder work frame three or four feet less in width than the width of the road, a few inches lower than the height from the floor to the ripping lip, and about 8 feet long. It may be built up and maintained at the ripping face as a complete unit on skids, and hauled forward as required by Sylvesters, or the side frame may be separated and joined up as required by pivoted cross ties extending between them. The latter arrangement may be the best for thin seams. The top girders are provided with shoes on which props can be set to the roof back from the ripping face, and other shoes from which stells can be set to the ripping face. Brackets are provided near the top of the side frames for stretcher girders which can be pushed forward under the ripping lip.

At the start of the ripping shift the front end of the scaffold is close in to the ripping face which is stelled from it, and on top of the frame at least two props are set to the roof back from the ripping with lids, to provide for height loss. There is a layer of planks on the frame to catch any material falling from the roof or the ripping face. A pair of back stays are set from the frame to the floor at the rear, and the extension girders are forward under the ripping lip. In this position the frame has provided protection from the previous ripping time.

After the shotholes have been bored, using the frame as a scaffold — this can be done on other shifts if desired — the whole frame is advanced until its fore end is under the inner strap which will become the lip strap after ripping ; this strap may be blocked from the frame. The supports under the part to be ripped are then withdrawn, some protection being provided by the frame against falls while the Sylvester chain is being attached to those supports. As the frame is now open at the top, the planks having been taken off, the shots may be fired with the frame in position, or if, owing to the strong nature of the ripping, it is considered that the frame may be damaged, it can be drawn back to the ripping face. Where the ripping is done by hand or pneumatic picks, the frame is used in the forward position, and in some cases it is used as a shovelling platform.

If the stage is in the forward position after the ripping has been got down by blasting or otherwise, the roof above it is supported off the frame sides immediately, and the new ripping face spragged off the frame and the back stays put in. The extension girders are pushed forward under the ripping lip and propped. When sufficient debris has been cleared at the sides of the frame the permanent road supports are set. The stage remains in this position until the next ripping.

If the stage has been drawn back for blasting it is advanced as soon as a path has been cleared for it, and meantime the extension girders, blocked up off the debris, are used to carry supports for the roof and the ripping face.

These scaffolds are by no means complicated in structure nor in use, and the facilities they provide for erection of supports, and as working scaffolds, seem more than to justify any time involved in manipulation. Their more extensive use, especially at the big loading roadheads at mechanised faces, would not only give greater safety, but also enable some of the preparatory work for actual ripping to go on independently of coal loading, an obvious advantage when delays in completing stripping are so liable to upset the main road ripping programme.

Withdrawal and Recovery of Supports.

As height loss between the roof and floor at working faces is going on continually, but at the greatest rate during coal cutting, the controversial question as to whether drawing off should precede or succeed cutting at the face depends largely on the amount of provision remaining for height loss when the supports are at the waste edge. If the additional height loss during cutting will overload these supports, then they should be withdrawn and the new waste edge supports supplemented, before cutting. On the other hand, if there still remains ample provision for height loss, the supports can beneficially remain until they have contributed their resistance to the strata movements caused by the new cutting operation. When these extra movements have subsided, and not while they are going on. withdrawal can proceed.

Before withdrawal of supports from the waste is started, any supports which have failed in the rows between the coal face and the waste edge, as it will be aftor the operation, should be renewed. Where necessary for the safety of the persons during the withdrawal operation, temporary supports should be set. The use of a special anchor prop, quite independent of any support props, for the Sylvester, and two withdrawal chains so that one can be attached to the next prop before the preceding one is withdrawn, reduce the chances of accidents during withdrawal operations.

When advancing chocks, additional security is provided if a chock is first built and tightened to the roof before the one it is to replace is withdrawn.

Direction of withdrawal is perhaps a controversial matter, because ease of withdrawal is effected by the general direction in which the props have swung as a result of relative movements of the roof and floor, but there is no doubt that the operators should, as far as possible, work opposite the part of the waste not already drawn off.

Standardisation of Methods of Support.

There are advantages in standard methods of support for special places such as roadheads, coal cutter turning points, and at conveyor engines, and mechanisation has made standardisation of methods of support at working faces possible. The idea of a standard method does not necessarily imply perfection. It simply means the best that can be devised at the time the standard is drawn up. Improvements on the standard are wanted and adopted whenever they are found. There is nothing in standardisation to preclude innovation, but before a proposed change in a standard is put into operation it must be scrutinised as carefully as the original.

There will no doubt be some who say that no standard method or device can ever supplant the need for and usefulness of experienced men. But even the judgment of experienced men cannot be depended upon to prevent falls accidents, and therefore presentation of the best method must be of value to all, whether experienced or otherwise. Leaving the initiative to the worker by no means ensures that he will take the initiative, and the same is true of the mine officials. Before progress on these lines can he made a different outlook may be needed. Instead of emphasising differences in conditions, it is more important to establish likenesses. There is undoubtedly a great deal of uniformity in the practice of mechanised mining.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Winstanley, Arthur    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
02 May 1942  Mechanisation And Falls Of Ground Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 May 1942  Mechanisation And Falls Of Ground Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print