|
4th April 1942, Page: 276, Column: 1 Steel As Timber SubstituteExtracts from paper on "Mining Timber: Possible Economies and Substitutes," submitted at the February general meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. By L. C. Maitland. Advantages to be Obtained. Coming to the substitution of steel props and straps for wood props and crowntrees (or planks) — it is with these that the greatest economies in the use of timber can be effected. Steel has been in use as a substitute for wood on the coal face for many years and in many instances has been most successful. Progress in the use of steel was slow at first, largely due to the heavy first cost, but in recent years there has been a considerable extension in its use — it is realised now that steel is a very sound investment provided its use is properly organised. Steel props are of uniform strength, greatly in excess of that of wood props of similar size. For instance, a 4-inch prop of Scandinavian timber, 4 feet in length, will fail under a load of from 15 to 20 tons, whilst a 4-inch external diameter steel tube, wood filled, or a 4 by 4-inch steel joist prop of the same length, will sustain a load of over 60 tons. Comparatively few steel props are broken in service, damage is more often due to withdrawal under unfavourable conditions, also many are lost. The chief advantages to be obtained from the use of steel are as follows :— (1) It is the most handy and satisfactory substitute for timber for the support of roads and faces. (2) The life of the steel prop may average three or four months compared with three or four days with timber, but so much depends on the organisation — losses per annum vary from 10 per cent. to 300 per cent., but the high losses are not generally due to damage in service. (3) In case of fire, there is nothing to lose. (4) Increased life of the props means a considerable reduction of transport compared with wood. (5) Increased confidence on the face, due to the rigidity of the prop. (6) An indirect advantage in roof control lies in the necessity for more attention to the systematic withdrawal of props from the goaf. (7) Steel should be looked upon as the most suitable material for the support of working faces, and not as a substitute for wood. There are two types of steel props : (a) Yielding props and (b) rigid props ; the former are better on slow moving faces, the latter on rapidly advancing faces, on which the props remain set for only a short period. Of the rigid props, the composite tubular and the "H" section girder are more generally used. Other conditions being equal, a tubular prop is better on a coalcutter face, because it is much less liable to be dislodged by the machine. Where "H" section girder props are used on coalcutter faces, the flanges of the prop should be parallel to the face, and when being driven into their final position the hammer should strike the flange and not the web. Both composite tubular and "H" section girder props are better with a slightly convex head, as it offers relatively little resistance when being driven under a wood lid or bar, and in the case of steel bars, provided it does not make contact with the steel, there is no liability to spring out. The use of steel straps as substitutes for timber crowntrees is even more popular than the use of steel props. The number of steel straps in use is making rapid progress every year, and up to the present their application is much more general than that of the steel prop. They are certainly easier to introduce into the mines in many instances than the steel prop. As with steel props, so with steel straps, the system of supervision and withdrawal must be efficient to obtain satisfactory results. When steel props and steel straps are used a good lid should always be used between the props and the strap. The lid should be at least as large as the prop head, and thick enough to provide cushioning ; their effectiveness is increased if used with the grain of the wood at right angles to the corrugations of the strap. Slightly tapered hardwood lids are recommended — the taper assists in the setting and withdrawal. In the paper, "Mine Supports During War Time," by A. M. Bryan, M. A. Hogan, and J. A. S. Ritson, they state : "Since the tonnage of steel used on roadways is far greater than that required on the working face, economies in the use of steel on roadways ought eventually to release a sufficient tonnage of steel to make a substantial contribution towards the provision of additional steel for use at the working face. Attention to the following matters would go a long way towards providing that contribution :— (1) Immediate withdrawal of steel arches from disused roadways. (2) Efficient lagging or strutting of arches to increase resistance, minimise distortion, and possibly increase also the spacing of arches. (3) Use of efficient yielding devices to prevent or minimise distortion of arches in the moving zone. (4) Improvement of packing system to reduce convergence, including consideration of the double packing system. (5) Close study of conditions with a view to reducing the tonnage of steel required by setting arches on top of roadside packs, or by the use of cambered or straight girders. (6) Provision of reconditioning plant at each colliery and immediate reconditioning of distorted arches for re-use as arches or for cutting into props, chock pieces, sprags, sleepers, etc., the material for which no further use can be found at the pits, to be returned immediately as scrap. , (7) Use of, or replacement of steel by, other forms of support, such as brickwork, masonry or reinforced concrete in roadways in more or less settled ground." Results prove definitely that considerable economies can be effected in the use of timber and by the substitution of steel for timber ; also economies can be effected in the use of steel by the "double-packing" method of support of roadways, by the checking system on the coal face, and by the use of face packs. The use of concrete props on travelling roads and airways is extending ; in settled ground they are very satisfactory and will last indefinitely. With a few exceptions, they have not been a success on longwall faces; investigations and experiments are being carried out in an endeavour to find a reinforced concrete prop that will withstand the severe conditions experienced on longwall faces. Points to Consider. In conclusion, what can be done to decrease the use of timber and to increase the use of substitutes ? The following suggestions may be useful in this respect:— (a) More expert and intense supervision by officials who have been educated in the correct method of using timber, and where and what substitutes can be used. (b) A study of the general principles of roof control, more particularly applying to the local conditions. The correct method of roof control in bord and pillar "whole" and "broken" workings and in longwall workings has a considerable influence on the consumption and maintenance of the support used — timber or steel. (c) The correct use of packs on the face, the best system of supporting the main roads. (d) The correct cycle of operations. Whenever possible, the back supports should be drawn and moved forward, the conveyors moved forward, and the packs built as close to the face as possible, all before the face is machine cut. (e) As soon as a support has done what it was set for, it should be withdrawn. No supports should be left in the waste. The valuable research work of the investigators should be continued now, instead of being left in abeyance until the war is over. Surely this work is more important now than ever, when increased production and economies in every direction are so essential. Assume that investigators and their work cost the industry £10,000 per annum, that sum is nothing to what they would save. One valuable suggestion might very easily save that sum of money at one colliery in less than one year. Attractive lectures to workers and officials on these subjects would produce good results eventually, it might not come all at once. A company owning a group of collieries might appoint a lecturer on these subjects and an investigator of their own. Much valuable work could be done in this way. The appointments should be good ones in order to attract the right men. The information gained and the results obtained might be "pooled" for the benefit of the industry as a whole. Finally, the writer wishes to emphasise the point that no suggestions made in this paper are intended to minimise, in any way, the question of safety, which should always be the first consideration.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||