21st February 1942, Page: 244, Column: 1
Notes On Dust Suppression And Collection
By J. Smellie, Ph.D., A.R.T.C.
Extracts from paper presented at the February meeting of the Manchester
Geological and Mining Society.
Treatment of Coal Dust on Roadways.
On the question of dust deposits, it is common knowledge that the treatment of
coal dust on roadways by water on anything but a very small scale is
ineffective and generally does more harm than good. After its adoption in the
early days it was very soon abandoned "as a remedy worse than the
disease."
The use of special binding and wetting solutions has been successful on a small
scale, but at prohibitive cost for general use. Where this treatment has been
applied the problem of fresh coal dust deposits has not been satisfactorily
solved.
Incombustible dust is, unfortunately, the main line of defence at the moment
for dealing with deposited coal dust. It is well to reflect that any further
changes in the standards will, in all likelihood, call for further increase in
those quantities. The present position, in my view, is that expressed in the
Report of the Royal Commission on Safety in Mines which states " . . . .
reliance on the efficacy of stone-dusting as a means of neutralising the
explosive quality of coal dust has had the effect of encouraging some mine
managements to take too complacent an attitude towards the accumulation of
dust."
There is undoubtedly a great measure of truth in that statement and we have, I
am afraid, become accessories to the system. Considering the explosions that
have occurred in which the action of the stone dust was questionable and the
fact that it is so often and so easily overlain by coal dust, the stone dust
remedy cannot be accepted as the solution of the coal dust problem of to-day.
It should be regarded as a last resort when all other methods of dust reduction
and collection have proved ineffective or insufficient.
Dust Suppression and Collection.
Apart from the question of dust collection at specific points with special
apparatus, there is the question of air dustiness on the coal face itself,
arising from coal-getting operations. With ever-increasing concentration of
production this is becoming an acute problem in many instances. I am of the
opinion that on a very dusty coal face many mining problems are magnified, and
that if the dust were reduced appreciably the effect might be seen in improved
accident and absenteeism rates. Dusty conditions arise from the dust produced
in the operations of coal-cutting and shot-firing very largely, the bulk of the
dust being liberated during filling out. Reduction in the amount of dust made
in the first place and the suppression of the remainder are the only possible
solutions at the moment. Any improvement at the source, however, will become
apparent at all points where coal dust is normally dispersed into the air.
The problem of wetting the scuftings is now being studied and experiments are
in progress with sprays on coal-cutting machines. Wetting of the broken coal
and scuftings as they lie on the face has always been very lightly dismissed,
and yet it would provide an improvement with far reaching effects. It is
generally argued that water adversely affects the strata and increases the
humidity. The humidity factor is a real one in some of the deep and hot mines,
but I am not certain that the increase in humidity would be so great or persist
for any length of time in each cycle. We have also very little evidence to show
that the amount of water which would be required to damp the coal surfaces and
cause the dust to adhere would greatly effect the floor of the average seam.
The wetting agent need not be water alone ; it is possible that other
solutions, oils or light foams may yet be found for this work of
"fixing" the dust.
Coal dust is not easily wet by water as we are all aware, but the obvious dust
reduction when a coal face becomes naturally damp is surely sufficient reason
for making further efforts towards dust suppression and dust fixing on the coal
face.
Dust Suppression at Loading Points.
Since no really effective method of "fixing" the dust at its point of
origin is yet in use, we are obliged to collect it at the points where it is
dispersed. Loading stations are generally the worst points, and it is at these
places that the majority of dust collectors have been applied in coal mines. In
surface installations a similar problem would provide a fairly straightforward
task for an air-conditioning engineer, the use of ample power and space
ensuring the required efficiency of collection and cleaning. Underground,
however, with the same problem the questions of space, adaptability and
mobility have to be considered in conjunction with collecting efficiency.
The essential features of a successful dust collector for underground use, in
my opinion, are as follows :—
(1) Simplicity and reliability. Like all mining machinery the maximum
simplicity and minimum attention are required.
(2) Small space occupied consistent with the air quantity being handled.
(3) Interchangeability. Should be suitable for use at both fixed and moving
loading points.
(4) High air-cleaning efficiency at all dust concentrations.
(5) Collection of the dust to be absolute and require no further treatment.
Devices which have been used in practice with varying success are briefly : (1)
Simple sprays on the loading chutes or on the loaded belt near the loading
point. (2) Suction devices operating with a finely atomised water spray. The
suction provided by fan or induced by compressed air jets. (3) Filters,
woodwool, metalwool and fabric bags. (4) Cyclone separators.
These devices utilise the principles of wetting, filtering and centrifuging,
and in some cases a combination of several principles. Gravitational settlement
and electrostatic precipitation can be considered impracticable for the moment.
Cyclone Separators.
There is nothing new about the cyclone separator ; it is probably one of the
oldest dust collectors and has been used for many years in surface
installations. In its simplest form the cyclone consists of an outer
cylindrical chamber, with tangential inlet, terminating in the conical portion
with dust exit at the bottom. The air travels downwards in a vertex to the
bottom of the cone, returns in the inner vertex and exits at the thimble at the
top in the form of a rotating ring. The separation efficiency depends on the
effect of centrifugal force and the radial acceleration of the dust particles
in the high-velocity air streams whirling around in the apparatus. It is
evident that the separating velocity of the particles are dependent directly on
the square of the velocity of the air stream and inversely on the radius of the
separator. For efficient separation, the smallest particle which it is desired
to separate must reach the sides of the cyclone within the time of passage of
the air throughout the unit.
The results obtained in experimental tests indicate that the small cyclone
compares favourably with other types of dust collectors, but its full
possibilities in mines have not been explored. It possesses the great
advantages that the dust is collected dry and ready for disposal and all water
difficulties are eliminated. A further investigation into the possibilities of
using still smaller sizes would be worth while as there appears to be scope for
a battery of very small cyclones in movable units such as tubs. Cyclones down
to 4 inches in diameter, claimed to be capable of removing particles down to
the 3-micron size, are now in use in metallurgical processes in preference to
larger units. Although more costly, the efficiency is greater, and as the
cyclone size does not appreciably affect the pressure drop the use of the small
high-efficiency types is warranted.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Smellie, J. | | | |