24th January 1942, Page: 219, Column: 1
Air Conditioning In Mines
Physical Qualities Affecting Health, Etc.
The principal physical qualities of mine air that affect the health, safety,
and efficiency of the miner are temperature, humidity, motion, and barometric
pressure. Additional hazards to health and safety may result from compressed
air and fogginess, especially in tunnels.
Reviewing the literature on conditioning air for the advancement of health and
safety, the authors (D. Harrington and Sara J. Davenport) of U.S.
Bureau of Mines Information Circular 7175 deal With the physiological aspects
of the principal physical qualities of mine air, and express the foregoing view
in their introductory remarks. They say that acclimatisation (man's ability to
adapt himself to changes in air conditions) and psychology (an intangible
matter of habit and suggestion) are important influences that cannot be ignored
in air conditioning. Although the human organism can adapt itself to a wide
range of atmospheric conditions without apparent discomfort or injury to
health, acclimatisation to extreme conditions probably involves strain on the
heat-regulating system and interferes with the normal physiologic functions of
the human body.
Exposure of workers to a hot, moist atmosphere has an effect on their
efficiency and working capacity more or less similar to that of living in a
hot, moist climate. Human energy is derived from the combustion of foodstuffs.
Exposure to high temperature and humidity in the working environment in north
temperate climates probably would be more likely to cause acute effects in the
worker than in the climates where he is exposed to high temperatures all the
time. Haldane considered the wet-bulb temperature to be the measure of
atmospheric conditions suitable for efficiency of workers. He set the limit for
men resting and lightly clad at 88°F. wet bulb or 93°F. in the air
moving at 170 feet a minute. He believed that the limit for active work was
78°F. wet bulb in still air and 85°F. in air moving 135 feet a minute ;
that at 80° wet bulb the work of a miner decreased ; that at 85° hard
work was virtually impossible ; and that beyond about 88°F. it was
impracticable for unacclimatised persons to stay in such air for long periods.
In addition to the great reduction in efficiency of the human machine owing to
the difficulty of keeping down the body temperature during work in high
wet-bulb temperature, Briggs suggested as a possible cause the
impairment by the hot, damp air of the passage of oxygen from the air in the
lungs into the blood. He mentioned the following experience as indicating this
: A rescue brigade was exercising with breathing apparatus in a road in the
Niddrie Colliery. A steam pipe ran along the road ; some steam was escaping,
bringing the air to saturation point at a temperature of 85°F. After more
than an hour's light work a halt was called, and the Instructor (Mr. D. Davidson)
advised the men to take out their mouthpieces and rest. They did
so, but very soon slipped them back again, one by one, They preferred to
breathe air from the apparatus — which by that time would also be
saturated and of at least as high a temperature as the outer atmosphere —
rather than fresh air from the road. The air of the apparatus would contain 70
or 80 per cent. of oxygen ; it would, therefore, be more comfortable to inhale
than normal saturated air at this high temperature if there were any difficulty
in getting a proper oxygen supply from the latter. This seems to be a point
calling for investigation.
Regarding the effect of temperature on accidents the authors say that a study
of all accidents that entailed absences from work of more than three days among
18,000 underground workers in British coal mines revealed that temperature had
a distinct bearing on the liability to accidents. Those employed in seams where
the temperature was 80°F. or more had 30 to 77 per cent. more accidents
than those working at temperatures below 70°F. Accident severity, measured
in terms of number of days lost per 1,000 hours worked, was greatest in the
hottest mines, but the increase in accident severity was less than the increase
in accident frequency. Temperature had no appreciable influence on the
frequency of severe accidents causing prolonged disability. Minor accidents
entailing disability of less than ten days, however, were three times as
numerous at the higher temperatures as at the lower ones. The relation between
age and accident frequency also was influenced by the temperatures at which the
men worked.
Conclusions.
As applied to mines and those who work in and around them, some conclusions are
offered based largely upon data contained in the Circular but including also
some observations from investigations as well as experience of the authors.
1. In hot, humid, stagnant air men are likely to be affected by dizziness or
inability to think clearly or quickly, or they may faint at an inopportune time
and be killed ; also, there have been numerous instances of men dropping dead
from heart failure in hot places in mines.
2. Rock temperature generally increases with depth, the rate of increase
ranging from 1°F. or more per 100 feet of depth in certain districts of the
western part of the United States to but ½° or 1/3°F. per 100 feet
of depth in other regions, both in the United States and in foreign countries.
In Montana, rock temperature in copper sulphide veins is about 108°F. 3,800
feet below the surface, the rate of increase being about 1° per 100 feet of
depth. In a lead sulphide vein in the Coeur d'Alenes in Idaho rock temperature
2,000 feet below the surface was but 50°F. In a Michigan copper mine with
native copper ore rock temperature was about 82°F. 5,000 feet below the
surface. In a gold-bearing quartz vein in Arizona the rock temperature was
90°F. 600 feet below the surface, while in a quartz deposit bearing copper
sulphide in another Arizona district rock temperature 600 feet below the
surface was but 70°. Temperature of coal in place in coal mines in the
United States is rarely above 70°F. and is generally much lower. Magazine
articles give the rock temperature of the Kolar gold field in India at
118°F. 6,100 feet below surface and 98°F. at the 4,000-foot level of
the St. John Del Rey mine in Brazil, whilst it is calculated that at the
8,000-foot level of the City Deep mine in South Africa the rock temperature
will be but about 97°F.
3. With dry-bulb temperatures below 75°F., mine working places may be
comparatively comfortable, irrespective of air movement or relative humidity,
if the air is not deficient in oxygen or impregnated with toxic or noxious
gases.
4. With temperatures between 75° and 95°F., especially if the relative
humidity is high, still air is likely to cause excessive perspiration in the
performance of even light manual work, possibly headache and nausea, frequently
mental dullness, and usually a rise in body temperature.
5. With temperatures of 80° to 95°, stagnant air is oppressive even if
pure and the relative humidity low.
6. With temperatures of 90° to 95°F., stagnant air, at low humidity, is
bearable if it is given a velocity of 500 linear feet per minute.
7. When air temperatures rise above blood heat (98°F.) virtually the only
means to prevent discomfort or lowered efficiently is rapid circulation of the
air. In heat experiments conducted, by the Bureau of Mines and the United
States Public Health Service, a man whose body temperature had risen to
100.2°F., after remaining 45 minutes at rest in still air at
97½°F. and 90 per cent. relative humidity, walked 200 feet along a
level and carried a short ladder back to his resting place ; this slight effort
in the hot, humid, stagnant atmosphere forced his body temperature to
102.6°F., indicating the probable effect on body temperature of trying to
do hard work in temperatures higher than 100°F.
8. Until dry-bulb temperature approaches 75°F., a relative humidity
virtually up to saturation causes little or no discomfort, even though the air
is still, unless the air is depleted, of oxygen or is charged with
comparatively large quantities of CO, CO2, or other noxious gases.
When such air is given a velocity of 25 linear feet or more, work can be done
normally.
9. With the relative humidity 85 per cent. or more and the temperature. 75°
to 85°F., stagnant air, even when pure, is oppressive, and its
oppressiveness is greatly intensified with even a small decrease in oxygen
supply, or increase of CO2. However, when comparatively pure air of
this sort is given a velocity of 100 linear feet a minute a miner feels no
appreciable discomfort when working fairly hard.
10. Stagnant air, regardless of purity and humidity, is oppressive at 90°
to 95°F., and the oppressiveness increases as the air
approaches saturation. With a velocity of 400 linear feet or more per minute,
such air is not particularly oppressive, and with a velocity of 1,000 or more
linear feet per minute the effect is pleasant, particularly if the relative
humidity is not more than 95 per cent.
11. When temperatures reach 100°F. or higher, and the relative humidity is
close to 100 per cent., even a comparatively high velocity gives little relief.
On the other hand, air with a temperature as high as 110°F. but with a
relative humidity of 85 per cent. or less, although distinctly oppressive when
still, is readily endurable when it has a velocity of 1,000 linear feet or more
per minute. Hence, if adequate movement is supplied, the relative humidity is
not a deciding factor until the temperature exceeds 100°F. and humidity
approaches 100 per cent.
12. Although the effects of underground air are greatly influenced by
temperature, humidity, and gases, velocity of air probably has greater
importance than all other agencies combined, With the possible exception of the
removal of poisonous gases. In general, workers can be comfortable, healthy,
and efficient if the air in which they work is circulating, even though that
air is comparatively hot, humid, and to a considerable extent vitiated. The
effect of even slight air movement was noticed by the senior author of the
Circular in a western mine where the workers in a stope with stagnant air at
79°F. and a relative humidity of 86 per cent. were accustomed several times
daily to climb to the level above to "cool off" in air which,
although actually 3° hotter and with 5 per cent. greater relative humidity
than the air in the stope, moved at a rate of 150 linear feet a minute.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Briggs, — | | | |
| Davenport, Sara J. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Davidson, D. | | | |
| Haldane, — | | | |
| Harrington, D. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |