|
27th December 1941, Page: 192, Column: 2 Recent Criticism Of ExaminationsIn a paper on "Recruitment and Training of Mining Engineers, with Special Reference to Colliery Management," Mr. A. M. Bryan at a meeting of the Institute of Scotland drew attention to the following six points regarding the examinations for certificates of competency upon which recent criticism has been based. (1) The standard of the examinations has gradually risen above the capacity or opportunities of the working miner, and consequently the door has been closed to many good practical men. (2) The questions are often of a type which would stump acting managers of wide experience. (3) Some of the questions call for detail that can only be crammed. (4) A knowledge of certain subjects greater than is required for mine management is called for. (5) The oral examination carries a too high proportion of the total marks, and the examination can be unequal. (6) It Should be possible to take the examination in stages, subject by subject. A two-day examination is very exhausting, quite apart from the energy expended in the immense preparation for it. Having dealt with these grounds of recent criticism Mr. Bryan remarked that it can generally be agreed that the examinations for certificates of competency are something handed down from the "bad old days." At the present time they demand a book-wormness and application difficult to find in youths and young men in these days of mass entertainment. It is evident that, if anything is done in the recruitment and attraction of men to mine management, the examinations for certificates of competency must not be forgotten.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||