29th November 1941, Page: 169, Column: 1
Minor Constituents In Coal
A comprehensive survey of the minor constituents in South African high grade
export coals has been carried out, and the ascertained results are given by
G. Armstrong Smith, of the Fuel Research Institute of South Africa, in
the Journal of the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of S.A. Part 1 of
the contribution emphasises the significance of the constituents. Extracts are
appended.
Sulphur.
Sulphur, in different forms, is invariably found in coal and its presence is
always undesirable. Coals having in their raw state a sulphur content of less
than 0.5 per cent, are very rare and are unknown in South Africa. The sulphur
in coal is essentially of three types — organic, sulphide and sulphate.
The organic sulphur is of vegetable origin, being derived from proteid remains.
There appear to be two forms : resinic sulphur and humus sulphur (it is more
profitable to consider the organic sulphur as a whole).
While workers are generally agreed on the origin of organic sulphur, the source
of the pyrite is still under dispute. The point in contention is chiefly the
origin of the sulphur in the FeS2. One school of thought assumes the
pyrite owes its formation to the original sulphur in the coal substance. On the
other hand the investigation of a brown coal bed led Donath and
Vykypiel to conclude that the pyrite evolved from infiltrated ferrous
(or ferric) sulphate solution which was reduced by organic coal material.
The sulphate content of coals is universally small, except where air has had
access to the coal. Under such circumstances iron pyrites may be oxidised to
form iron sulphate. This oxidation may be seen in outcrops and old Workings
where a surface layer of sulphate covering unaltered pyrites is often
observable. The sulphate content, then, is an indication of the degree of
weathering the coal has undergone. Another source of sulphate in coal is
gypsum, a residuent from percolating water. It is found as thin, whitish flakes
in cracks and crevices in the coal. It is usually present in negligible
quantities.
Organic sulphur is an inherent constituent of the coal, whereas the inorganic
sulphur is mixed mechanically with it. This fact is of fundamental importance
when considering the reduction of the sulphur content of coal, which ranks next
to ash reduction in importance and is linked together with it in washing
problems. Only the elimination of mineral sulphur can be expected in cleaning,
and a specific gravity separation on a commercial scale is further limited in
its application to the massive forms of pyrite. As coal will tend to fracture
along pyrite bands and partings, this form of sulphur may frequently render the
coal more friable and cause a natural concentration of the pyrites in the
smalls. For this reason partial cleaning may be effected by screening, as in
the case of some Witbank coals.
In general it may be stated that no high sulphur coal is suited for use in any
process which involves the contact of the treated product with the fuel or its
combustion products. As an example may be quoted the ceramic industry in which
sulphur causes objectionable gases in the waste heat driers, destruction of
colours in glazes, blistering and the troublesome "kiln white" or
scum on the product.
In considering the actual firing of coal there is considerable evidence to show
that high sulphur coals are likely to have a low ash fusion temperature,
although the converse by no means follows.
Much discussion and inconclusive work has been published on the role of pyrites
in the spontaneous combustion of coal. In the past sulphur was thought to be a
primary cause. Later this theory was discredited and at present the consensus
of opinion seems to be that, while pyrites may be an aid to spontaneous
combustion, it is a subordinate and not a fundamental factor.
Where the coal is used in the manufacture of coke for metallurgical purposes or
the production of water gas, control of sulphur content is essential. Although
it is possible to use high sulphur coke for the production of pig iron by
special furnace and slag control, this type of coke is usually extremely
variable in quality and the method may therefore prove inefficient.
Further considering the deleterious effects of sulphur in coal there is the
question of atmospheric pollution. Some idea of the potential destructive power
of sulphur in coal may be obtained from the fact that 1,000 tons of coal
containing 1.5 per cent, may discharge 45 tons of sulphuric acid into the air.
For this reason large consumers of coal, especially power stations, are now
being obliged in many instances to remove the oxides of sulphur from flue
gases, a familiar example being the Battersea Station. To accomplish this two
methods are possible : (a) The selection of the fuel and the removal of the
greater portion of the sulphur by washing prior to burning, or (b) the washing
of flue gases. The latter is favoured industrially, but the former method
remains the only practicable one for domestic and small consumers.
Nitrogen.
The nitrogen in coal has a vegetable origin, being derived from proteid
remains. These proteids are also the source of the original organic sulphur.
The nitrogenous compounds formerly provided a large proportion of the world's
ammonia supply but, owing to the development of the nitrogen fixation process,
the economic importance of this element in coal has become negligible. In
general, on carbonisation not more than 20 per cent. of the total nitrogen
content is evolved as ammonia, upwards of 40 per cent. remaining in the coke,
probably in the nitride form, while the remainder is lost as free nitrogen or
cyanogen in the gas, and in small amounts as basic bodies, such as pyridine, in
the tar.
No relationship apparently exists between the nitrogen content and rank of a
coal.
Phosphorus.
Recently considerable attention has been given to the proving of deposits of
low phosphorus coals, the value of which lies exclusively in their use for coke
production for smelting and metallurgical purposes. The deleterious effect of
phosphorus in steel causing "cold shortness" is well known. Where the
pig iron is intended for use in the acid steel process the coke burnt in its
production in the blast furnace must adhere strictly to definite specifications
as regards phosphorus content. The maximum permissible phosphorus content
usually lies between 0.01 and 0.03 per cent.
Little work on the phosphorus distribution in coal seams appears to have been
done. Cawley gives some results for the banded constituents of a low and
high phosphorus coal and concludes that the phosphorus is not concentrated in
any particular parts of the seams. The analyses of different bands showed that
in high phosphorus coals durain was higher in phosphorus than vitrain. In low
phosphorus samples, the phosphorus was evenly distributed.
It has generally been accepted that a certain concentration of phosphorus in
the fusain always occurs.
Arsenic.
In view of the high pyritic and phosphorus contents of some South African
coals, their arsenic contents were determined. References to work overseas are
extremely scanty. Attention has been drawn to its presence in coal by the
occurrence of several cases of toxic poisoning from arsenic of workmen engaged
in the handling of pitch and the manufacture of coal briquettes. Further
examples of occupational poisoning from the same cause of chimney sweeps,
boiler cleaners, and gas, coke and tar workers are discussed by Bayet
and Slosse, who suggest that many serious industrial diseases can be
traced to the burning of arseniferous coal. Flue dust has been found to contain
from 0.01 to 0.05 per cent, arsenic. Analyses of some arseniferous coals show a
range of 0.003 to 0.041 per cent. arsenic.
Chlorine.
The chlorine in coal is present in small amounts mainly as chlorides of the
alkalis and magnesium, with sodium chloride predominating. The coal seam may be
originally impregnated with these salts or, as commonly happens, they may be
introduced during the washing and preparation of the coal after mining.
The chief objection to high chlorine coals is the extensive and costly
corrosion occurring in furnace linings as a result of their use. Abnormal
corrosion of boilers has also been traced to the presence of 0.22 per cent.
chlorine in the coal used for firing. The sodium chloride acts mainly in its
volatile form, but it has been suggested that it may react with the silica in
ash and lining to form hydrochloric acid and chlorine. Corrosion has
particularly been noticed in smelting furnaces.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bayet, — | | | |
| Cawley, — | | | |
| Donath, — | | | |
| Slosse, — | | | |
| Smith, G. Armstrong | | | |
| Vykypiel, — | | | |