29th November 1941, Page: 168, Column: 2
Trials With Concrete Supports
In the review of recent work presented by Mr. J. W. Robinson at the
annual meeting of the South Staffs, and Warwickshire Institute of Mining
Engineers, it was emphasised that, in the problem of concrete props on the face
the handling, setting, withdrawing, and shotfiring, all had an important
influence on the life of the props. The essential conditions for the successful
application of reinforced concrete props on longwall faces were that provision
must be made for the minimum of height reduction between the face and the edge
of the waste during the period the props were set and for withdrawal without
damage. At several of the pits where the face conditions might reasonably be
expected to give satisfactory results, the question of considering a trial of
concrete props had been discussed with the management. Points raised had
reference to the weight and difficulty in handling, liability to damage during
setting and withdrawal, and the liability to recondition when damaged.
Two trials with concrete supports were described as follows :—
(1) The seam was 4 feet 6 inches thick, with a good shale roof and medium to
soft fireclay floor. The reinforced concrete props were 4 inches square and set
with lids 2 feet by 4½ inches by 2#189; inches, at distances of 4 feet
apart. The seam was undercut to a depth of 4#189; feet. After breaking into the
back of the cut at the roadhead, a tub road was carried forward as the coal was
filled off. Although the face Was only advancing some 12 feet per Week, the
roof conditions were good and the convergence low. Little trouble was
experienced in withdrawing the props by means of a Sylvester and few showed
signs of damage. The results of the test suggested that concrete props could be
more or less successful in conditions in which the floor was relatively weak.
This might be the case even where the roof was of such a nature that it
collapsed as soon as the props were withdrawn, so long as sufficient wooden
props were used as safeguards to cover the withdrawal of the props. Probably
about one-third of the props previously consumed would be used for this
particular purpose. Moreover, due to the fact that such props needed only to be
set for a few hours, it was unlikely that many of them would be broken or lost.
It was, nevertheless, a count against concrete props from the economic
standpoint.
(2) Reinforced concrete props were introduced in a seam 2 feet 9 inches thick,
having a fairly strong roof and hard floor. The face was equipped with conveyor
units of 80 and 25 yards respectively, and was undercut to a depth of 4 feet.
The trial was undertaken on the shorter length of face. Prior to the
installation the roof was supported by wooden props and lids. At the time the
roof conditions were not too good, and in consequence the convergence Was
abnormal. When discussing this case with the management, it was emphasised that
the provision of some form of release for accommodating the convergence would
be absolutely necessary to ensure any degree of success. The result of the
trial proved a failure. The concrete props in many cases collapsed and the
remainder were more or less fractured. In view of the management's previous
experience with wooden props it was surprising that they had not taken the
obvious precaution of making additional provision for accommodating the
abnormal convergence other than by capping the props with a 3-inch thick lid.
The investigations established that reinforced concrete chocks had
possibilities on properly controlled working faces as a substitute for wood or
steel chocks, providing that a good withdrawal device was used and attention
given to the careful bedding of the chock.
Laboratory investigations and tests carried out into the design of concrete
chocks, Mr. Robinson was able to reveal, have shown that the
"dumb-bell" type with proper reinforcement gave good results. One
chock was withdrawn forty times when carrying loads from 10 to 100 tons without
serious damage. With regard to the materials forming the "mix" to be
cast into props and chock pieces, research work has shown, for instance, that a
70 per cent. increase in the quantity of cement would increase the strength of
the prop or chock piece 4 times and a 50 per cent. decrease in the water
content would increase the crushing strength 4 times. Such factors as the
cleanliness of the aggregate and the water used were important as well as the
thoroughness of the mixing, the type of reinforcement and its position in the
cross-section.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Robinson, J. W. | | | |