|
15th November 1941, Page: 147, Column: 1 Ventilation SurveyingMon. and South Wales Coal Owners' ReportGauge and Tube Method. The General Research Committee of the Monmouthshire and South Wales Coal Owners' Association has issued its Second Report, on Ventilation Surveying : with special reference to the Inclined Gauge and Tube Method of Pressure Surveying. The Chairman of the Committee is Mr. D. A. Hann, the Director of Research being Dr. T. David Jones and the Investigator Mr. F. B. Hinsley, M.Sc. The report stresses the utility of ventilation surveying, and the results of several surveys are included and discussed. Actually surveys were carried out at nine collieries and eighteen separate splits were surveyed. In view of the complexity of mine ventilation it is suggested that rigorous standards cannot be formulated, the safest method being to treat each set of circumstances separately. Pressure Surveying. This 38-page report with its 11 illustrations has been issued in order to bring the gauge and tube method to the notice of colliery managements. Extracts are appended. It is a well-known fact in mine ventilation that, as the air proceeds downstream round the ventilating circuit, there is a continual loss of ventilating pressure. This loss of pressure is not generally uniform with distance travelled by the air but depends upon the cross-sectional area, shape, alignment, and degree of roughness of the lining of the airways. There are two methods of measuring pressure losses. These are (a) the barometer method and (b) the gauge and tube method. The barometer method employs sensitive aneroid barometers Which require a high degree of skill in their manipulation. In the reduction of the results of barometer surveys many and varied corrections have to be made, some of which may be larger than the pressure drops Which are to be determined. Conditions of steady surface barometric pressure are essential during the progress of a barometer survey. The main field for the barometer survey is the extensive survey carried out quickly, the results giving the main outlines of the ventilating pressure distribution. For detailed and more accurate work the gauge and tube method is recommended. This method as generally adopted consists of connecting a gauge directly by tubes to the ends of the portion of airway over which the pressure drop is required. The pressure drop is then shown directly on the gauge. Thus an open roadway can be treated in exactly the same way as a cross-cut containing doors. When dealing with an entire ventilation circuit extending from the bottom of the downcast to the bottom of the upcast, the full pressure drop is obtained by measuring short lengths of roadway in turn until the whole circuit has been traversed. The sum of these individual pressure drops gives the full pressure drop. For very accurate work it is better to mount a pitot-static tube at each of the measuring stations and then either total or static pressure differences can be observed by simply changing the connections from the total to the static tubes. This also has the advantage that the measuring head remains fixed until all the observations have been completed at that measuring station. In level workings the sum of the total pressure drops round a circuit from the bottom of the downcast to the bottom of the upcast at any instant, should be equal to the pit-bottom water-gauge. In steep workings natural pressures may be generated, and in order to effect a balance the natural pressure must be added to, or subtracted from, the pit-bottom water-gauge, depending upon whether it is working with or against the fan. It is of the utmost importance when making a ventilation survey to make a large number of quantity observations and not just a few spot readings here and there. At all splits sufficient quantities should be measured to show that the air flowing to the junction is equal to that flowing away. Hence at least three determinations are required. No quantities should be found by measuring two flows and getting the third by difference, all should be measured in order to provide checks. This procedure should be carried out at all leakage points, and the leakage current measured by means of a dust test. A similar procedure should be adopted at the points where the air streams reassemble. Where there is a long length of roadway without splits, several determinations at intervals should be made. In this way leakage through packs and strata can be detected. If there is no leakage the mean of these readings gives a very reliable quantity value due to the large number of observations taken. Procedure to be Adopted. When making measurements of pressure loss, the portions of airway dealt with at each setting of the gauge should be carefully chosen, so that in effect, the circuit is divided up into a number of airway lengths or sections, such that each carries almost constant quantity for the whole of its length. The circuit then becomes a number of airways connected in series. This can be arranged by making all splits and points of leakage into measuring stations. For each of these constant quantity portions of roadway, at least one quantity measurement should be made. It is much better to make three or four quantity determinations in each separate section depending on the length of the section. The survey should begin at one of the pit bottoms, either the downcast or upcast, and proceed either with or against the air stream, depending on where a start is made, round to the other pit bottom. The tube should be laid out with one end in the pit bottom and the gauge should be set up at the first inbye station in such a position that it need not be moved even when the tube is advanced into the next section. The tubes are then connected up, the ends held facing the wind and the pressure drop read and recorded. The tube is then disconnected and dragged forward into the next bay where a similar process is carried out. In the third bay the gauge is again moved to the inbye station and the process repeated. Meanwhile quantity measurements are being made in these lengths of airways and the whole survey moves along at almost the same rate. This procedure is followed until the face, or the separation doors, leading to the return are reached, through which the survey is to pass on its Way to the other pit bottom. Besides measuring pressure drops along the airway, advantage should be taken at all separation doors along the circuit, to measure the pressure across the intake and return. These figures can be used as checks in suitable circumstances. A point worthy of attention in steep mines is that in inclined airways the true pressure drop will not be recorded on the gauge if the tubes are not full of air at the same temperature as that in the airway, hence in passing from intake to return, sufficient time should be allowed for the cold air to run out of the tube and be replaced by warm return air. It can be stated that the resistance in Atkinsons per 1,000 feet of airway gives a figure for each airway which allows a ready comparison to be made of the flow properties possessed by each, irrespective of any pressure drop and quantity differences which may have existed in the airways when the observations were made. The power required to circulate a given quantity of air is proportional to the resistance of the circuit. Now the most economical ventilation system, provided the standard of ventilation is adequate of course, will be the one giving the lowest cost for power and construction and maintenance of airways. Hence there is a limit set by power costs above which it will be uneconomic to let airway resistance rise. The airways in which the power requirements are likely to be high are those which carry large quantities, such as the main and trunk airways. District airways, due to the reduced quantities, are rarely large power users. Hence inbye airways may be of relatively high resistance and yet not absorb large amounts of power. Such airways may be suitable for transmitting small quantities of air but are uneconomical for large quantities. The power requirements of an airway, therefore, give some measure of its suitability for the particular task allotted to it. In reporting the results of ventilation surveys an attempt should be made to render defects as obvious as possible. To this end graphical methods should be applied as these allow a true picture of the conditions to be made rapidly and easily. The first and perhaps the most generally used method of mapping the results is to write the pressure drops, quantities and other relevant matter on a plan of the workings. In this way the ventilating pressure and quantity distribution can be shown in its true relation to the workings and airways. Main Defects Encountered. Following discussion of results obtained in typical cases, the report indicates that several common defects were noted, as follows :— Perhaps the most common defect was the provision of inadequate return airways, especially the portions near the bottom of the upcast shaft. These airways often have to transmit the joint flows from several splits and are therefore heavily loaded. In many cases, the roads provided were of too high resistance for their important position in the circuit and large pressure and energy losses were experienced. A similar kind of defect was sometimes found in the main intakes, heavy losses being caused in the vicinity of the downcast shaft and further inbye if splitting was delayed until the main current had travelled hundreds of yards. In a few cases both returns and intakes showed abnormal pressure and energy losses. Connected with the above difficulties is the lack of sufficient main roads. In some cases all the output was concentrated from one side of the mine, with the result that the ventilation system which might have been adequate for an all-round hand-got layout, was inadequate for concentrated machine working on one side only. Splits should take place as near the bottom of the downcast as possible, and reassemble as near to, or in the upcast shaft. If this is done, overloading is reduced to the minimum. The practice adopted by some collieries of taking the return air direct into the upcast shaft by means of cross-measure drifts has much to recommend it. The number of air-crossings is reduced, as is also the leakage and the quantity flowing in the trunk returns. When it is known that workings Will be extensive in any direction, more main roads should be packed out and ripped. Where faces have to travel only relatively short distances two roads will suffice, but the longer the distance to be travelled by development faces the larger should be the sectional area and number of roads packed out and constructed. Another common defect, where two or three seams were being worked, was the construction of cross-measure drifts or "roof ups" of high resistance. These "roof ups" are generally put through at a high angle and in several cases have been thirled and left with severe constrictions at the entrance and exit. In the majority of cases met with in this work the resistance of "roof ups" has been many times that of an equal length of adjoining airway. If the drift is to be a permanent part of the ventilation system, even though it be in the return, it should be made of a cross-sectional area comparable with the rest of the system and the entrance and exit should be faired or eased to reduce resistance. Also, in choosing the gradient, all the factors involved should be carefully weighed, because if the drift is designed to form a permanent part of the system it may become necessary to clean it out at intervals and tubs may be needed for this. Leakage, the main bugbear in ventilation practice, was rather high in some cases, and roads carrying leakage should where possible, be tightly stowed. Doors on the whole appeared to be fairly well maintained, except those on haulage roads. One or two cases were met where a large percentage of the air was leaking through doors badly sawn by haulage ropes. In stall work leakage near the face was very high, and more attention could profitably be paid to brattice sheets and doors inside the districts. Size and Design of Airways. The design and layout of a ventilation system will be governed by such factors as : strength of the strata in relation to the ease or difficulty of making and maintaining roads, firedamp yield of seams, output, distance to be travelled, depth of seams; temperature conditions, faulting, liability to spontaneous combustion, and many others may have to be taken into account. No general standard of size and design of roadways can be laid down. With the knowledge placed at his disposal by ventilation surveying and his specialised knowledge of the above conditions, the mining engineer can set his own airway standards for a particular mine or seam. His standards should be set so as to allow some margin of safety so that he has a little in hand for an emergency. If ventilation surveying is practised several standards are open to him. For example, in one case the standard mentioned was to maintain trunk roads of such a size as to give a maximum pressure drop of one-tenth of an inch of water per 1,000 feet of roadway. In another case 0.3 inch of water was considered satisfactory. Another was to keep all main roads at a resistance less than 1 Atkinson per 1,000 feet. In other words the roads must be maintained either by area or by smoothing at a resistance less than that offered by a steel-arched roadway 11 feet diameter and 9 feet high. A very simple and easily applied standard for use in the control of ventilation is that of velocity, and this is closely allied to the pressure drop standard. From the information at his disposal the mining engineer can fix the maximum velocity above which it is not wise to go. Air-horse-power. Air-horse-power losses for trunk airways where relatively largo quantities are flowing have an average of about 5 per 1,000 feet. This figure is rarely reached in the low resistance circuits where it would be considered excessive. In other more highly resistant circuits, much higher figures may be found and may still be economical depending on the factors involved. Lower values than 5 a.h.p. per 1,000 feet are, in most cases, desirable and a suggested round figure, which should not be exceeded, is 3 a.h.p. per 1,000 feet. Pressure Losses. An average for pressure losses is in the region of 0.4 inch of water per 1,000 feet for main roads. This again might be considered excessive in some circumstances, but quite permissible in others. For the average large mine this figure is on the high side and should be brought down to 0.3 inch or less. These suggested approximate maximum values of a.h.p. and pressure loss per 1,000 feet will apply to most average mines, but the setting of standards is difficult owing to the variety of conditions. These values have been fixed from the survey results obtained up to the present and further work may show them to be erroneous ; they are merely put forward as a guide.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||