|
1st November 1941, Page: 138, Column: 2 Analysing Mine DustsBy E. H. Browne, B.A.Cantab. The testing of samples is carried out, not primarily in order to establish exact figures of proportions of coal dust and inert material, but in order to ascertain whether the dust on the roadway contains above or below or is in the neighbourhood of a proportion of combustible matter which is considered to be dangerous. If in the neighbourhood of the limit, it will probably be desired to take steps for improvement whether the statutory requirement has been exceeded or not. Considering the limits of sampling accuracy, and the main purpose of testing, it has seemed to many that the cumbersome method of testing samples by combustion analysis is an unnecessary burden, commanding as it does a degree of accuracy disproportionate to the process as a whole. The desire for greater simplicity has grown with the increased number of samples which are now taken at collieries. Furthermore, economy in labour in wartime is essential, but if the results are to be of true value they should be available without delay. Alternative and simpler methods evolved have included colour tests, and methods of computation from the density of the sample. One such method has been used at a group of collieries for some months. The principle of the method is based upon estimation by empirical means of the combustible content from the density of the sample, the latter being obtained by comparison of the weight with the volume ascertained by displacement of liquid. It is of importance that a process of this kind which is to be repeated indefinitely should have simplicity and speed in operation. Direct reading of combustible content is therefore desirable. Sampling by the Volumeter Method. Preliminary tests having given satisfaction that a reasonable degree of accuracy could be obtained, the use of the method for statutory requirements was made possible by the action of H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines, through whose good offices, in May, 1941, Special Regulations were obtained. The conditions are quoted below :— ................ Mine, Lancashire. 1. These regulations shall apply to such seams as may be specified in writing by the Inspector of the Division. 2. Subject to these Regulations, the volumeter apparatus already provided and tested at the mine may be used by a person competent in its use and appointed by the manager, to estimate the percentage of incombustible matter in samples of dust collected for the purpose of ensuring that No. 3 of the Coal Mines General Regulations (Precautions against Goal Dust), 1939, is complied with. 3. The percentage of incombustible matter so estimated shall be posted at the pithead and recorded in the prescribed book with the distinguishing words "by Volumeter." 4. (a) As regards one in every ton of all samples which fall within a range of 5 per cent. from the content of incombustible matter required by the said General Regulations for the seam, and one in every fifty of all other samples, chosen haphazard, the estimate by the volumeter apparatus shall bo checked by analysis in the prescribed manner, and the analysis shall be coupled with the estimate by the volumeter apparatus and be posted and recorded in the prescribed book with the distinguishing words "by analysis." (b) If in respect of any seam the percentage of incombustible matter estimated by the volumeter apparatus differs from the percentage determined by the check analysis by more than 5 per cent. in three or more out of any twenty consecutive check analyses, notice in writing shall be sent to the Inspector of the Division and these Regulations shall continue to have effect in respect of that seam only with his consent in writing and subject to such conditions as he may prescribe. 5. Copies of all the calibration curves used for the volumeter apparatus and of the data on which they are based shall be kept in the prescribed book. Advantages. Following this approval, the whole of a group of collieries was placed on the volumetric method and a large number of results have therefore been obtained. They are strikingly good, and well within the reasonable limits of accuracy desired. Provided there is general uniformity in conditions, the empirical nature of the method will overcome difficulties due to variations in stone dust introduced. The higher the proportion of incombustible stone dust introduced, which is likely to be uniform in composition, the greater the accuracy of testing is likely to be. The check testing which is required by the Special Regulations and which is highly desirable in itself, provides a constant means for reconsidering and adjusting the graph from time to time. Using the combustion analysis, an average worker can test about 24 samples in a full day. By the volumetric method 50 are regularly tested. Thus, a 50 per cent. saving in labour can be made. The amount of apparatus is reduced, and the furnaces used only for check testing. The simplicity of the method tends to avoid inaccuracies due to human errors, and it may well be that the benefit thus obtained is equal and possibly greater than the theoretically more certain accuracy of combustion analysis. The whole basis of check testing has been on the assumption that the combustion tests were perfectly correct, but it is extremely likely that in the course of countless samples dealt with, errors creep in, owing to the many weighings which have to be made. Whilst it is recognised that it is not the best laboratory practice to weigh up to a fixed amount, the use of the fixed 25 gram sample undoubtedly has the advantage of eliminating all arithmetic. Conclusions. (1) The limits of accuracy of mine roadway sampling are recognised. The relative accuracy of combustion analysis is disproportionate and unnecessary. (2) The volumetric method gives a reasonable degree of accuracy for the purpose for which it is designed. (3) Variations in the composition of stone dusts present in the mine are liable to create errors, but can be met by regular check testing. (4) A saving of 50 per cent. labour in testing can be obtained. (5) The results are made available rapidly. Description of Method Used. — Methylated spirits is the liquid employed and is used from a 50 m.l. burette filled to the zero mark. In order to avoid surface tension about 15 m.l. is first run into a 50 m.l. flask. 25 grams of the dust sample is then added and Well mixed in order to wet thoroughly and dislodge air bubbles. Sufficient methylated spirits is then run out of the burette in order to fill up the flask to the 50 m.l. mark. Burette readings were plotted against combustible content as ascertained by combustion testing and the graph obtained subsequently used to give direct results. The specific gravity of normal clean bituminous coal is between 1.25 and 1.30. Stonedusts vary but are in the neighbourhood of twice the latter, e.g., Limestone, 2.7 ; Shale, 2.4 ; Gypsum, 3.32. * Extracts from paper on "The Volumetric Method of Analysing Mine Dusts" presented at the October meeting of the Manchester Geological and Mining Society.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||