18th October 1941, Page: 118, Column: 1
Recent Advances In Coal Cleaning
By A. D. Cummings, B.Sc. *
In most coalfields of Great Britain the better seams are being worked out and
the less good seams, which were left in earlier working, are coming into
production. Where formerly the raw coal came from a thick seam of uniformly low
ash with some accidental shale from bands, it now more often comes from a seam
of higher inherent ash containing dirt bands which may not be readily detached
from coal and making altogether a raw coal of much higher ash. The first could
be prepared for market by hand picking, the second will require careful
cleaning before it is acceptable.
The new coal cleaning processes, which are the coal industry's response to the
new conditions at the mine and the demands of the consumer, are striving after
two things — to get rid of the middlings which are getting in and raising
the ash of the clean coal and which the older processes cannot keep out, and to
lower the ash of the smallest sizes, the dirty fines produced by coal cutting.
There are two ways in which dirty fines can be dealt with. They can be screened
out and cleaned apart from the rest of the raw coal, or they can pass through
the washery with the rest of the raw coal and be re-washed separately. Many
washing plants now include arrangements for de-dusting, i.e., taking out the
dust below 1/50-inch which in any case is not cleaned and represents a handicap
in the washery. This dust is mixed back dry with the washed slack. But
something more than this is required. The cleaning of all the sizes below
1/8-inch is poor compared with sizes above this, and where it is possible it
would probably pay to remove and treat separately the 1/8—0 fraction.
Since the treatment in water of fine coal is never a very satisfactory business
(the washery water becomes fouled, large settling cones are required, probably
water clarification too and the final moisture is about 30 per cent.), there is
much to be said for dry cleaning this size, and several plants have been
developed to do this. There is only one important difficulty, the coal must be
dry; these processes are only successful if the surface moisture is below 3 per
cent. Three dry cleaning tables which have been successful in doing this are
the Coppee, the Mourner and the Static (Raw-Ridley).
Raw coal may be separated into two layers, coal and shale, by moans of upward
currents of air or water. Air separation has been successfully applied to
cleaning coal from about 2 inches diameter to 1/8-inch. In several plants the
air-currents are applied to sized coal and the coal is lifted above the shale ;
in another a rapidly pulsating air-current is applied to a thick bed of unsized
coal, and under these conditions shale sinks to the bottom as in a heavy
liquid. It is this second principle that seems to be operating in these fine
coal cleaners. A thin bed of coal of 1/8—0 size is subjected to a steady
or pulsating air-current on a jigging or reciprocating surface and shale
separates out below the coal. The conditions of separation are rather delicate,
but once established they can be maintained. The separation of the layers
involves some difficulty, but has been solved ; shale is led off below, leaving
the stratified bed undisturbed, and clean coal is sliced off from the upper
layers. This is repeated a number of times and the bed narrowed to compensate
for the loss of thickness. Several plants are working and reducing 1/8—0
coal from 25 per cent. ash to about 8 or 9 per cent., a very good result on
such material. It is notable that it is found worth while to dry the coal by
heat in at least two cases.
Another method of cleaning fine coal, either raw coal screened out of larger
sizes or the slurry separated from washery water, is by froth flotation, a
principle extensively applied in ore dressing. It is somewhat expensive and has
so far not been used much for coal cleaning.
The process depends on differential "wettability." The extent to
which a solid is wetted by a liquid depends on their relative attraction for
each other, e.g., a clean surface of glass is wetted by water, but not if the
surface be greasy. The appearance of a liquid drop on a solid surface, whether
it forms a flat disc or a round bead, depends on a balance of three
attractions, that of the liquid for the solid, of the liquid for air, and of
the solid for air. When the attraction between liquid and solid is strong, air
can be displaced from the surface of the solid and the liquid wets it; when the
attraction is weak, air is not displaced and the liquid remains in a distinct
drop. It follows that if the solid is immersed in water, air bubbles can attach
themselves to the solid surface by displacing the water, if the attraction for
water is weak, but not if the attraction is strong.
It happens that water wets shale more easily than coal. It is, therefore, easy
for an air bubble to displace water from a coal surface, but not from a shale
surface. The surface of the coal can be made less wettable by water by coating
it with a suitable oil which does not easily wet shale ; this will at the same
time strengthen the attachment of an air bubble to the coal surface, and a
large bubble can lift small pieces of coal (up to about 1/8-inch) to the
surface.
The process is as follows: the raw coal is mixed with about four times as much
water and reagents (such as creosote oil and heavy paraffin) are added in small
quantities. This ensures that, when the coal and Water pulp are agitated,
bubbles will be formed in large quantities and will attach themselves to
oil-coated coal particles, but not to water-coated shale particles, and a
coal-bearing froth will form on the surface, leaving the shale at the bottom.
This froth can be removed by a scraper, collected and drained or filtered.
Instead of agitating to produce bubbles, suction can be applied when air coming
out of solution in the water will form bubbles on the coal surfaces rather than
on shale surfaces and carry the coal to the top. The advantages of this
process, the Elmore Vacuum Flotation Process, are that the pulp in the vaccum
vessel is quiescent and air bubbles are not detached by violent agitation, and
that the vacuum-produced froth is easily broken down and the separated coal
drains better.
The new development for large coal is Gravity Separation, i.e., the partition
of raw coal into clean coal and shale at a fixed specific gravity in a heavy
liquid as in a laboratory separation in carbon tetrachloride. The chief
advantage of this is that the products are 100 per cent. correct at the
specific gravity chosen, everything floating is clean coal, everything sinking
is shale, and there are no "errors of classification" as in jig and
trough washing. The yield of clean coal is larger, its ash is absolutely
uniform and the shale contains no wasted coal. Other advantages are ability to
handle variations in load and amount of dirt, the possibility of washing a wide
range of sizes in one plant and finally the ability to separate at low
densities, thus eliminating the carbonaceous shales which usually appear in the
clean coal when a jig washer, operating at about 1.6 S.G., is the means of
separation.
All the processes now operating use a suspension of insoluble material in water
to make the heavy liquid; this material is swilled off the products and
recovered by settling. The Chance process uses sand held in suspension by water
currents, other processes, using finer materials without agitation currents,
are the Tromp (magnetite), the Barvoys (barytes and clay) and the Dutch State
Mines (very fine sandy material called loess). The processes are on the whole
very similar to each other. The separating vessel is usually cone shaped ; raw
coal is fed into the bath of liquid from a shaker feeder and clean coal floats
immediately to the surface, to be removed by a plate-scraper skimming the
surface of the liquid and drawing the coal up a drainage screen. Shale sinks
down through the liquid and on reaching the bottom is collected by a bucket
elevator. Usually, arrangements are made for removing from the shale particles
of density intermediate between the floating coal and heavy shale, otherwise
these would accumulate in the separating bath. The processes thus make three
products, clean coal, middlings and shale. The middlings are usually crushed to
free attached coal and re-washed along with the raw coal.
So far the processes have not treated coal below ¼-inch and separate plant
must be provided for cleaning this size. Otherwise the method can be said to
offer means of washing run-of-mine coal entirely in one operation.
Handling equipment and consequently power consumption is similar to that in
older processes and the additional cost for reagent does not exceed ½d.
per ton.
Coal cleaning practice has in the past borrowed many ideas from ore dressing,
and in the future it seems likely that it will continue to do so. Up to now,
coal producers have usually installed one type of washer to deal with all the
coal requiring cleaning, usually a jig or trough washer treating 2-inch to 0.
Recently several plants have been built involving different types of plant for
different sizes of coal. This is a line likely to be followed up ; as in ore
dressing, the coal will be divided into sizes and each treated in the best type
of plant to secure the results desired in that size. There will never be so
many stages as in ore treatment, but separate treatment of large coal, slack
size and fines seems likely.
Another direction in which development in coal preparation is following mineral
dressing is in the complete recovery of all combustible material, with the
double object of collecting everything saleable and making the waste heap safe
from fire. The collection, crushing and re-treatment of middlings has been
mentioned, a feature of all the gravity processes. The collection, of fine coal
from the washery water in a condition suitable for boiler firing by means of
flocculation, and filtering instead of settling in ponds or running to waste,
as formerly, is another instance. After all, the risks and cost of bringing raw
coal to the surface are considerable, and it seems only fair that an effort
should be made to get the last ounce of value out of it before deciding that
the remainder is refuse. This has always been the ore-miner's practice, because
of the much higher value of his product, and new processes have yielded good
recoveries from the waste heaps of past generations. This is not a way open to
the coal miner; coal that has gone to the waste heap cannot be recovered later,
Nature (and the unemployed) have seen to that.
* Extracts from Notts. Mining Students' Association Magazine, Vol. 18.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cummings, A. D. | | | |