18th October 1941, Page: 115, Column: 2
Steam Raising At Collieries
Before the Lothians branch of the Association of Mining Electrical Engineers
Mr. H. E. Partridge, consulting engineer, read a paper on "Steam
Raising at Collieries." He described it as remarkable that the early work
and development of steam raising and steam power plants have been largely
concerned with collieries and yet, speaking generally, it is at the collieries
where one finds the least serious regard for the steam raising plant. There are
many industries in which the boiler plant is regarded as the heart of
production and this in many cases where the overhead charges relative to the
other manufacturing charges are much less than is the case with collieries.
This position has probably arisen as a result of the pioneer being left with
his initial pioneering plant, whereas those who have followed have been able to
learn by the pioneer's mistakes. Furthermore, the last thirty or forty years
have passed by with a heavy burden on the financial side of the whole of the
coal industry, and it is only during this last three or four years that sense
and sensibility appear to have become prominent in the commercial side of the
coal trade as a whole. The unfortunate engineer at the colliery has frequently
had to take up a legacy which he could not afford to ignore, but which, at the
same time, was quite inadequate to meet the call upon it and the poor relations
round about have given little or no opportunity for improvement.
Mr. Partridge's paper has been reproduced in the Transactions (The
Mining Electrical Engineer) of the Association and the closing notes are
extracted as follows :—
One of the best means of illustrating the requirements of mechanical equipment
for dealing with colliery fuels is to be found by a use of the blacksmith's
hearth. The author has made many tests by this means and, whilst they are
purely tests of observation, they do definitely give the lead as to the
fundamentals required for dealing with low grade fuel. The average boiler
plant, where
washed selected fuels are used, will deal with a fire say 5 inches thick with a
suction in the combustion chamber of 0.2 and without the use of forced draught.
If the same condition is attempted with unwashed waste fuels, it will be found
that little more than 1½ inches of fire can be carried. The result,
however, is still worse than this because the thin fire is carrying a fuel
having a low B.Th.U. value and a high ash content, with the result that the
total number of B.Th.U.'s generated is not only less as being available but
much lower in generation owing to the difficulty of excluding excess air
through the thin fuel bed.
Here are readings recently taken by the author on plant where washed singles
were being fired 3½ inches thick : The evaporation was of the order of
32,000 lb. of steam per hour. The fuel was changed to low grade waste, with the
result that the fires had to be thinned to allow air to get through the fuel
bed. The CO2 dropped to between 5 per cent. and 6 per cent., the
combustion chamber temperature Was considerably reduced and the evaporation
dropped to less than 20,000 lb., with pressure dropping also by about 20 lb.
Blending Plant.
Such an instance is not unusual in connection with colliery plant and many a
fireman will have had this experience, but if attention is paid to the whole of
the fuel, no matter what grade, and it is blended and mixed, there is no excuse
for faulty fires and low evaporation. The author is interested at the moment in
a plant which deals with an output of approximately 1½ million tons of
material drawn per annum. Of this amount, 2.33 per cent. is regarded as
inferior coal, some of which can be disposed of more or less locally; the
remainder, together with the waste products from the washery plant, give a
total equal to 1.77 per cent. of the material drawn and this constitutes the
boiler fuel. A short time ago the boiler plant received eight different
qualities of fuel in as many hours, and during one month 27 all named varieties
were sent down to the boilers for disposal, with the result that it was
well-nigh impossible to meet the steaming demand. Surely this calls for pity
for the poor firemen. Experiments have been made and observations taken when
burning the several wastes separately, and it has repeatedly been found to be
almost impossible to maintain anything like reasonable steaming conditions.
A small experimental blending plant has been tried out, with the result that
when all the wastes are mixed and maintained under more or less constant
conditions, then the firing results are excellent, good fires being easily
obtained and just as easily maintained. A complete blending plant is now to be
installed which will not only deal with the raw wastes but also with the wastes
produced from coke ovens. The only risk is that the mixed product will be so
satisfactory that the sales side will be wishful of marketing it! The practical
problem which arises is obviously relative to the large quantity of ash, but
this is quite a minor matter when the steam pressure can be maintained under
all load conditions.
Engineers are never more interested than when solving a problem, and when the
collieries come to encourage the same amount of attention, being given to their
waste products as they do to their saleable products, then the engineers will
find means whereby the waste can be economically dealt with. Combustion
equipment has been designed for dealing with fuel at rates as high as 70 lb.
per square foot of grate area, and collieries should never regard any existing
equipment as the limit of what is possible. Conversely, and quite frankly, it
is beyond the wit and ability of any man to maintain steaming conditions where
fuel variations take place almost hour by hour. It is not uncommon to find coal
bunkers carrying different strata of coal which would defy the cleverest
physicist to burn efficiently and satisfactorily. The wastefulness which has
been in evidence for many years in connection with steam raising has been
prodigal, and so long as the engineer is able to develop plant along truly
scientific lines and coincident with the research of coal values, only then
shall we begin to appreciate how wasteful we have been in the past. The author
might even venture to go further and say that in his opinion, but without
wishing to predict, it would seem that the day is not far off when it will be
considered a crime to burn raw coal. In the meantime, however, make it a rule
never to regard any fuel as waste. The Chicago packers made fortunes from
everything down to the squeal of the pig, and it is not too much to say that
even the CO2 from the gases should be collected and utilised.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Partridge, H. E. | | Consulting Engineer | |