20th September 1941, Page: 90, Column: 1
Surveying In Indian Coal Mines
By James Lomax.
Very often small collieries cannot afford the necessary expensive equipment or
even the services of a full-time surveyor, which probably would not be
justified. Their surveys are made by a part-time surveyor, attending on perhaps
one day per week ; the latter, because of the conditions of his employment, has
only a passing interest. In the British Isles, the surveying of such small
collieries would probably be done by a private firm of Consulting Mining
Engineers and Surveyors, having at their disposal a well-trained staff and the
best of instruments ; in India, however, this is not the case.
In view of the large number of small properties being worked and consequently
the numerous barriers which have to be left, it is essential that there should
be accuracy in surveying if safe working is to be achieved. This accuracy can
only be achieved by constant supervision and by insisting that only
fundamentally sound methods be employed.
I once remarked to a colliery manager that the methods of surveying employed in
Indian mines left a lot to be desired ; he replied that as far as he was
concerned his plans were amongst the neatest he had seen and was confident he
could leave the surveying entirely to his surveyor. I thought that a plan's
neatness was no criterion of its accuracy, and I venture to suggest that if
that manager chose to enquire rather more deeply into the methods employed by
his surveyor, he would have some very disturbing moments.
Standard of Surveying.
I am of the opinion that many of the present evils are due to the lack of
supervision in the plan office, and lack of attention to detail. As a
consequence and since the human element cannot be eliminated, very often the
easy way has been adopted and invariably the easy way is wrong in principle.
Typical examples of the easy way I give below :%mdash;
(a) Use of linen tapes for the measurement of survey lines.
(b) Infrequent checking of measuring chains against a standard steel band.
(c) Continued use of instruments, both of great age and in such a bad state of
repair, as to be impossible to make an accurate survey with them.
(d) Commencing surveys from marks, which are not recognised survey marks and
which are not marked on the plan.
(e) Commencing each survey with an independent bearing without reference to the
base line of the plan.
(f) Use of single tripod instruments for fast needle traversing.
(g) If survey is based on the magnetic meridian, failure to take frequent check
bearings during the course of the survey.
(h) Failure to check the survey by making a complete circuit or closing on to
recognised survey stations.
(i) Omitting to take the direction of galleries at a dead end, depending on
measurement only.
(j) Plotting the survey without the use of a pricker and by a six-inch brass
protractor.
(k) Neglect to make correction for dip when plotting.
(l) Neglect to make correction for change in declination since the time the
plan was first made.
(m) Plotting surveys based on magnetic north on a plan based on true north.
(n) Plotting the survey, together with some old workings on a piece of tracing
paper, superimposing this on the plan, then pricking the survey through.
(o) Inking in the plan with an ordinary pen, and even in some cases with
ordinary ink.
No one can make a survey unless the instruments available are serviceable, and
if a reasonable degree of accuracy is to be attained it is essential that the
instruments be of reasonably modern design, of a good make and maintained in a
good state of repair. If such instruments are available they should be placed
at the disposal, not only of the surveyors, but also of the apprentices. No
matter how well a survey office may be equipped, its equipment is of little
value if the trained personnel is not^there to use it.
Some Simple Methods.
Owing to the changing methods of mining and because of the possibility of
serious error, the loose needle method of surveying has now fallen into
disfavour and fast needle traversing is generally adopted. A fast needle
traverse may be made by one of three methods : (a) By continuous azimuths, (b)
By vernier angles, (c) By deflection angles.
No matter what method is adopted, it is necessary that each station be occupied
by the instrument. It is, therefore, to be desired that the three-tripod system
be adopted as this admits of greater rapidity than if one tripod is used, and
obviates any error which may accrue from centring. Generally speaking, the
continuous azimuth method is preferred and very often the magnetic meridian is
used as a base for the survey, when possible the magnetic azimuth of the first
line is measured. If there is accurate foresighting and backsighting the N. and
S. graduations of the base plate of the dial lie along the magnetic meridian at
each station. Thus the accuracy of angling can be checked by frequent checking
of the needle.
The incidence of magnetic storms causing unusual fluctuations in the magnetic
needle, during the course of an underground survey, may pass undetected, but if
such records were available any unusual variation would be immediately
apparent.
The colliery surveyor must measure his own change in declination, and this can
be done by setting up a base line on the surface and observing its magnetic
bearing at six-monthly intervals, preferably immediately before the half-yearly
surveys. It is essential that such observation be made with a reliable
telescopic instrument and, since the trough needle of the theodolite is
notoriously unreliable, a good telescope dial is ideal for this work. Variation
in bearing of this line is a good indication of the change in declination and,
incidentally, takes into account any change which may occur in the
characteristic reading of the instrument. Thus, correction can be applied for
change in declination since the time the plan was made, or if it is required to
plot an old survey on a new plan, the necessary correction can be found by
reference to past readings of this base line. Similarly, should it be desired
to plot the surveys of two or more instruments on the same plan, the difference
in the characteristic readings of the various instruments should be noted by
observing the bearing of the base line by each instrument in turn.
Very often a plan is based on a line, arrived at through the correlation of
surface and underground surveys, and might be termed the Shaft Base Line
method. In this case, the survey is commenced by observing a line between two
fixed survey stations, the plan bearing of which has been previously noted. The
vernier of the instrument is set to this bearing after the instrument has been
set up under the second of the stations. An observation is then taken of the
first station and the survey proceeds in the normal manner, using any of the
three methods previously mentioned. Since the accuracy of the survey depends
entirely on angular measurement, a theodolite should be used, and by adopting
the vernier angle method it becomes unnecessary to transit the telescope and so
eliminates errors due to adjustment of collimation. This method has the
disadvantage that recourse cannot be made to the magnetic needle, at intervals
during the survey, to check any error of manipulation. Whatever method is
adopted, it is necessary that a complete circuit be made to check the survey
and on plotting, should the final line fail to tie in to the starting point, it
is evident that some error has taken place. If this error is small, it may be
due directly to plotting, thus the only true check is to calculate the
co-ordinates of the stations.
At the time bearings of lines in a dip direction are observed the inclination
reading should be observed also, in order that the plan length may be
calculated at the time the survey is plotted. This method is to be preferred to
measuring the line in horizontal steps, as this may not be carried out in the
absence of a senior surveyor.
Permanent Marks, Setting Out and Plotting.
In making underground surveys, which will subsequently be extended, it is
necessary that marks be left at the furthest convenient points inbye, from
which to start the later surveys. If this practice has been carried out since
the mine first started, permanent marks will be available right from the shaft
bottom or from the mouth of the incline.
Proposed work should be marked on the main plan in order that the surveyor may
find the position of the proposed line in relation to his nearest permanent
mark. The bearing of that line can be taken directly from the plan and after
the line has been set out underground a short traverse should be made from the
line to the nearest permanent station. This traverse can then be plotted on the
plan and the actual position of the line, in relation to the proposed line,
noted. Similarly, should it be desired to join a gallery between two points, it
would not be necessary to make a special survey since the only information
required is its bearing and position in relation to the permanent marks.
In the plotting of general mine surveys, based on the magnetic meridian, the
draughtsman on receiving the field book should first apply a correction for
inclination to those lines measured in a dip direction. Secondly, he should
apply a correction for variation in the declination and the characteristic
reading of the instrument ; this correction is found by reference to the
records of the surface base line bearings. (It is convenient to mention here,
that in the notes of the various surveys the instrument with which the survey
was made should be stated.) The corrected measurement should be written in
neatly, against the original measurement, preferably in coloured ink.
The two most popular methods of plotting are by protractor and co-ordinates.
The co-ordinate method is the more accurate because the position of each
station is plotted without being affected by any errors which may have been
committed in plotting the previous stations. The protractor method of plotting
is the more convenient method and can be carried out expeditiously. It will
give a degree of accuracy sufficient for the plotting of general mine surveys
if a large protractor is used. A suitable form of protractor is constructed of
cardboard. This is engine-divided, and can be obtained in different sizes, the
most convenient of which is about twenty-two inches square with a circle 16
inches in diameter, graduated to 10 minutes. The central portion of about 15
inches in diameter is cut away, thereby allowing the plotting to be done on the
paper inside the circle, without removing the protractor. This protractor
should be used in conjunction with a roller parallel ruler having a length of
at least 24 inches.
It will be found convenient to plot the main survey stations of the surface
survey by co-ordinates, and having fixed those points, the small internal
surveys of the surface features may be plotted by protractor from those
stations. Similarly, in plotting the underground surveys the main permanent
stations, usually in main roads, may be plotted by co-ordinates and the
subsequent general mine surveys by protractor based on the main permanent
marks. A distinction is made here between main permanent marks in main roads
and permanent marks in other roads.
Correlation of Surface and Underground Surveys.
To determine the relative positions of the surface and underground surveys is
one of the most important jobs of the colliery surveyor, and there are several
methods which can be adopted to bring about this correlation. Some of these
methods are simple and some are very elaborate ; usually the elaborate methods
have a high degree of accuracy, but invariably require a considerable amount of
time, and a fairly large staff to carry them out. In choosing the method,
consideration should be given as to the purpose of the correlation, staff
available and inconvenience which may be caused due to stoppages.
In India, where shafts are usually working 24 hours per day and sometimes 7
days per week, it is often inconvenient to install plumb-lines in the shaft and
a common practice is to accept one of the winding ropes or guide ropes as being
truly vertical. In the case of well-constructed shafts, this method is well
within the limits of accuracy of magnetic traverses, but if this method is
adopted it should be realised that it is a source of error and as such cannot
be recommended. The method adopted depends also on the way entrance is effected
into the mine. If, through inclines, a traverse can be made underground which
is a continuation of the surface survey ; if the surface survey was a
triangulation, the underground traverse can be based on the surface base line.
Supposing, however, that the entrance to the mine is effected by vertical
shafts, the correlation may be made through the medium of plumb-lines in two
shafts, or, if one shaft only is available, by suspending two plumb-lines in
one shaft.
Mine Plans.
There is little I have to say about mine plans except that if they are to be of
service in 20 years' time it is necessary that they should be made neatly in
the first place and care should be taken in handling them. I think it is
essential that the surface features should be shown on the plan of the workings
irrespective of whether a surface plan is maintained, and in referring to plans
I am not referring to tracings. Further, the surface features should be clear
and distinctive, such that no mistake can be made between surface and
underground. I remember an instance when an old plan was referred to when
choosing the site of a fire dam in an old road. After the site had been chosen
an inspection was made underground but the old road could not be found. On
further examination of the old plan it was found that what Was thought to be an
old road was, in fact, a surface drain. Mine plans, in addition to showing the
delineation of the mine workings, should also give details of the geological
features met with during the working of the mine. In this respect, the manager
can give the surveyor every help by insisting that the position of a fault or
dyke be proved in each gallery approaching it; very often the position of the
fault is only proved at points wide apart and the intermediate galleries are
stopped short. It is desirable that the surveyor, when making his survey,
should read off the head and foot of the fault and note the throw, in order
that this may be shown clearly on the plan. Subsequently, this information may
be of major importance in tracing the occurrence of faults and dykes, when
planning the proposed working of lower seams. In this connection also
systematic levelling, at intervals of 200 feet along main roads, should be
encouraged and should be shown on the plan. To have levels of the original mine
floor in large goaf areas is very valuable information and helps considerably
in tracing the probable course of water after inundations, in readily
calculating heads of water, and in the ready determination of the depth of
cover.
Discussion of Points Raised.
Following the reading of the paper by Mr. Lomax members engaged in an
interesting discussion, which is given in extenso in Part 2 Volume 36 of the
Transactions of the Institute. Appended are extracts from the contribution by
Mr. K. B. Swamy
Regarding the standard of survey, the author mentions that many of the present
evils are due to lack of supervision in the plan office. The ultimate aim of
surveying in most cases is to prepare an accurate plan and this takes place in
three stages, namely : (a) actual surveying in the mine with instruments
involving measurements of distances and angles, (b) computation and (c)
plotting. In the plan office, as only computation and plotting can at best be
supervised or checked, I think checking the field work now and then in the mine
is also equally important.
Under the heading Some Simple Methods of Surveying, the author says that
"generally speaking, the continuous azimuth method is preferred and very
often the magnetic meridian is used as a base for the survey." But I would
suggest the general use of inward angle method (i.e., double foresight method)
for the following reasons. The continuous azimuth method should only be adopted
for very short and independent traverses and also only when the surveyor is
well experienced and skilled. For, with this method, as the bearing of a line
is measured only once, there is no check on angular measurements in an open
traverse, and in a closed traverse, if an error is disclosed at the final
measurement, the whole operation is to be repeated as the mistake in measuring
an individual angle cannot be detected at the time of measuring it. Further, in
this method, an error in reading or recording is not disclosed until the
co-ordinates are calculated ; while with the inward angle method, the angle at
each station is measured at least twice by the Repeat-addition method, one
measurement acting as check over the other. Thereby there is very little chance
of making a mistake. The only minor disadvantage with this method is that it
takes a little extra time in measuring each angle twice and also in calculating
the bearings from the vernier angles. Thus the inward angle method should
invariably be preferred whenever the area is large and connected to other
circuits.
In regard to the magnetic meridian being used as a base for the survey : here
again I am of opinion that, where the surveyor is not experienced to lay a true
north line from astronomical observations, an arbitrary meridian, fixed at a
convenient place on the mine surface by means of permanent stations, should be
preferred as a base line. The actual surveying of the surface and underground
will be more accurate if based on such an arbitrary base line as meridian
rather than when based on the magnetic meridian which is ever changing. Of
course, the magnetic bearing of this arbitrary base line should be determined
only for the purpose of showing the magnetic north on the mine plan. The amount
of magnetic declination and the date of measurement should also be noted on the
mine plan for future reference.
In regard to the Permanent Marks, I may suggest that it will be advantageous to
maintain a register of boundary, surface and underground permanent stations, in
which data in a tabular form may be written regarding station numbers, their
location with proper references, co-ordinates, date of survey, number and page
of field book in which field notes are entered, number and page of computation
book in which co-ordinates are calculated, reduced level, its distance from any
particular boundary line, etc. Such a register should be found helpful not only
to the surveyor but also to the mine manager.
Method of Correlation.
For the purpose of correlation of surface and underground surveys, it is
advisable to use invariably a good theodolite instead of a dial. Generally
speaking, most of the dials in the coal mines in India cannot be relied upon
for very accurate survey Work and much less because most of them are of the
sight vane type. A theodolite, because of its superiority in design and
workmanship, because of its compound axis which makes for accurate
concentricity of the revolving portion, and because of its superior mechanism
for centring, levelling and intersection, is essentially an instrument of much
greater precision than the dial which has nothing corresponding to the above in
its construction. Hence, the use of the theodolite should be insisted upon not
only in correlation work but also in all important surveys such as boundary
surveys, holing-through surveys, triangulation surveys and astronomical
observations in azimuth determinations.
In regard to the method of correlation by two plumb lines in one shaft using a
theodolite, there is yet another more convenient and simple method of aligning
the wires with the azimuth axis, and it is being practised along with the
Weisbach method by our students with great success in the annual survey camps.
This method is as follows :—
1. First fix the instrument so that the azimuth axis is approximately in line
With the two wires. As the instrument is generally fixed at about 10 feet from
the near wire, it is possible to achieve an approximation by means of the naked
eye, well within half an inch.
2. Intersect farther wire.
3. Focus near wire.
4. Shift opposite direction by means of centring device (if image of near wire
appears to the right of the azimuth line of diaphragm, i.e., shift instrument
to the left by the centring device).
5. Intersect near wire.
6. Focus farther wire.
7. Shift same direction by means of centring device (if the image of farther
wire appears to the right, i.e., shift instrument to the right).
As the correctness of final alignment is to be judged by focusing on both wires
to see that the near wire covers the farther one at the intersection of
cross-wires and not by any measurement, we have found this method very easy and
at the same time quick. The theory of this method is easy to understand if only
a diagram is drawn showing how the images of wires appear at each stage of the
above operation.
* Extracts from paper on "Some Aspects of Surveying in Indian Coal
Mines" read before the Mining, Geological and Metallurgical Institute of
India.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Lomax, James | | | |
| Swamy, K. B. | | | |