|
17th September 1941, Page: 3, Column: 1 Coroner Comments On Pit VentilationFrom Our Own Correspondent Wakefield, Tuesday The West Riding Coroner (Mr. C. J. Haworth) to-day concluded the inquest on the 22 men who were killed in the explosion at Crigglestone Colliery on July 29, and recorded a verdict of, "Death by misadventure." The hearing had lasted six days. The Coroner recommended that the statutory requirements as to the supply of lamps or other detectors should be rigidly compiled with, especially where workings are electrified and intensively worked, and that every man employed in a pit whether a deputy or otherwise, should carry out the requirements of reporting any impurities in the air. The balance of evidence showed, said Mr. Haworth, that split ventilation was the better system. At Crigglestone there ought to have been some tightening up of ventilation by additional doors, or other precautions in the road, especially as the conveyor ran through the separation door. There were two faces in the district intensively worked and fully mechanised, and normal risks were thereby increased, requiring, he thought, extra precautions because of the intensive working. Evidence or reports of gas in the pit made it clear that from July 17 small traces of gas were reported on a good many occasions. They had been told of steps taken to remove the gas before shots were fired, but H.M. Inspectors were against the firing of shots at all under circumstances such as the evidence disclosed to be existing. As to the cause of ignition in the explosion, there were three possible or plausible reasons, and if it were true that an outburst of gas was closely followed by ignition, then he questioned whether any system of ventilation, however perfect, would have prevented the explosion. Packing methods should be carefully considered. Earlier, Mr. J. Hawley, Junior H.M. Inspector of Mines, had said he formed the opinion that the explosion originated at or near the South loader gate face ripping lip. In his opinion the firedamp came from roof breaks in the South loader and timber gates. A shot at the South loader gate ripping Up might have ignited firedamp which might have continued to burn until an explosive mixture was formed, or until it reached an explosive mixture. Cross-examined by Mr. J. A. Hall (president, Yorkshire Mineworkers' Association), he said he did not believe in the policy of clearing gas to fire shots by raising the hurdle, as had been done in this case. Mr. Hall: Are you convinced that the speed of working in the mines now is responsible for the large number of explosions? — No. Are you alarmed at the number of explosions taking place? — Yes. Can they be prevented? — Yes, to a certain extent, but I do not think we can prevent them altogether. Questioned by Mr. A. S. Furniss, representing the colliery owners, the Inspector agreed it was most likely that whatever amount of air was put through the district, the gas in the break would have remained. Charles Edward Henshaw, Senior H.M. Inspector of Mines, of Roundhay, Leeds, gave it as his opinion that the explosion was probably caused by the delayed action of a shot fired. He did not think that brattice sheets should have to be adjusted to clear gas. Major H. J. Humphrys (H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines): You know shot-firing is on the increase in Yorkshire, and, in view of that fact, do you think that an efficient break detector is a most important thing? — Yes. James Herbert Davies, who had been at Crigglestone only 13 days as undermanager before the explosion, said he did not agree with the theory that a delayed action shot caused ignition.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||