6th September 1941, Page: 75, Column: 1
Results Of Shot-Firing Experiments
One of the papers prepared for the 5th International Conference of Directors of
Mine Safety Research was "An Experimental Study of the Ignition of
Firedamp-Air Mixtures by Explosives." It was handed in by Etienne Audibert,
Director of the Station d'Essais, Comite Central des Houilleres,
Senlis, Prance. Conditions led to the postponement of the Conference, but in
view of the general interest in the subject the U.S. Bureau of Mines has
published the paper as Report of Investigations 3518. The author says that no
satisfactory theory has yet been advanced to explain what takes place when an
explosive is fired in a mixture of firedamp and air. The only means of
measuring the danger is to fire the explosive into the gas mixture and note the
effect, but the conditions of firing must be chosen carefully.
Experiments designed to show the effect of the principal factors involved in
the conditions of firing are discussed by M. Audibert, the diameter of
the cartridge being 30 mm. and that of the shot-hole 35 mm., these being the
sizes generally used in France. The results of firing stemmed shots when direct
initiation was substituted for inverse initiation were examined.
The conclusions drawn from the experimental results are reproduced from the
Circular as under :—
(1) It has been accepted up to the present time that, all other things being
equal, the use of stemming always decreases the risk of inflammation of gaseous
mixtures by explosives. This was true in the author's experiments only for
explosives whose speed of decomposition was high. When the speed is not so high
(as when the explosives in the tests contained less than 20 per cent. of
nitro-glycerine), a stemmed shot may be more dangerous than an unstemmed one.
(2) Moreover, it has been accepted generally that the risk of inflammation of
gaseous mixtures by explosives is an increasing function of the weight of the
charge. It has even been thought possible to characterise the danger of an
explosive by its "charge limit," that is, by the weight of the
strongest charge that can be fired, under given conditions, without causing
inflammation. The present researches show that the exact significance of the
studies from which this idea was obtained has not been realised. If the risk of
ignition increases with the charge when the mortar is of constant length, it is
because, under these conditions, cooling of the gaseous products of detonation
by the mortar decreases when the charge increases . . . . The idea of a
"charge limit" has no experimental support.
(3) It is often stated that in practice direct initiation presents less risk of
inflammation than inverse initiation; as a matter of fact this is not true.
Where the stemming has slowed expansion far enough for the explosive to
decompose completely (and it is only when this condition is realised that an
explosive is used to its best effect), there is no difference in the effect on
gaseous mixtures of firing shots with direct or inverse initiation.
(4) To determine the danger from an explosive fired into gaseous mixtures it is
necessary to fire small charges of the explosive in mortars of the same length
as the charge and with inverse initiation. With explosives whose speed of
decomposition is high it is adequate to fire these shots without stemming.
Explosives with average or slow speeds of decomposition, such as many
ammonium-nitrate explosives, should be fired in mortars closed by devices that
slow the speed of expansion of the gaseous products of detonation.
(5) Application of this method to balanced mixtures of gelatinised
nitro-glycerine, ammonium nitrate, wood pulp, and inert salt (NaCl + KCl) has
brought about the discovery of explosives which, when fired in a shothole, have
no effect on gaseous mixtures and are still strong enough to be practical. For
example, the following table shows the characteristics of explosives that
contain 14, 20, or 25 per cent. of gelatinised nitro-glycerine and the exact
proportion of inert salt necessary to insure their safety in practice :—
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Audibert, Etienne | | Director | |