|
21st August 1941, Page: 6, Column: 1 Witness On StretcherMore Evidence Of Yorkshire Pit ExplosionFrom Our Own Correspondent Wakefield, Wednesday Further evidence was heard to-day at Wakefield by Mr. C. J. Haworth (West Riding coroner) at the resumed inquest on the 22 men who lost their lives in the Crigglestone Colliery explosion on July 29. Those present included: Major H. J. Humphrys, H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines; Mr. A. S. Furniss, solicitor, Rotherham, representing the owners of the colliery (Benzol and By-Products, Ltd.); Mr. J. A. Hall (president) and Mr. T. Oakey (financial secretary), for the Yorkshire Mineworkers' Association; Mr. C. Baxendale, Crigglestone Branch, Y.M.A.; and Mr. J. Howard, Yorkshire Deputies' Association. Ernest Broadhead, of Burton Road, Crigglestone, a coal-cutting machine man, was brought into court on a stretcher, being still a patient in Clayton Hospital. He stated that he had smelt gas at the ripping edge on about three occasions in the week before the explosion. He admitted that he did not stop work after having smelt gas up in the top at the ripping edge in the South loader gate, and that neither he nor the other machine man tested for gas. He left his oil lamp in the main gate, and the testing for gas, he thought, was a matter for the deputy and the shot firer. "Frightened of Losing Job" Asked why he did not stop cutting after he had smelt gas, Broadhead said: "We were frightened of losing our job." Mr. Hall: Do you know that cutting when gas is in close proximity is dangerous? — Yes. What made you think you would lose your job if you stopped cutting? — That was my own idea. In reply to further questions, Broadhead said he had never followed the practice of placing his oil lamp in advance of the cutting machine. Mr. Hall We shall have to see to it, after to-day, that that method is carried out. Broadhead went on to say that men in the district had complained about headaches from time to time, and Bob White, one of the men killed, had not been well during the latter part of the shift, and had remarked that he was not going to work there any more. Questioned by Mr. Furniss, Broadhead said he had never learned to test for gas. Referring to Broadhead's statement that they were frightened that, if they had stopped cutting, they would have lost their jobs, Mr. Furniss said: "That seems to me a most serious suggestion to make." Broadhead thereupon said he would withdraw it. Mr. Furniss: I think it would have been better if you had not said it. Had you at any time discussed with your mates this idea that you might lose your job? — No. Why did you say it? — I think if I had come out that day I should have been sacked. A protest at what he termed "an inquisition" was made by Mr. Hall, who said he thought Broadhead had a psychological trait which was responsible for his idea. "He has probably got the idea that men have been victimised in the mine for petty things." Mr. Furniss: I think Mr. Hall is probably right. Mr. Hall: This court would not hold the number of persons who could give the same evidence based on the same theory. The Coroner said that if such an idea was about. It was an exceedingly dangerous one from every point of view. Mr. Furniss: Have you any idea how the explosion could have been caused? Broadhead: By a spark from a pick in the ripping. Have you ever seen a spark from a pick? — Yes, in the face. Did you not think it dangerous in the last fortnight when you had found gas? — No, sir. Remembers Nothing Clarence Frederick Kennett, who had sufficiently recovered from his injuries to be discharged from hospital, was called, but told the Coroner that he could not remember anything that had happened in the pit on the day of the explosion. "I do not remember what I did that day," he said; "I have do idea at all." Mr. Hall suggested that this witness should be released until his memory returned, and this was done, the Coroner remarking that probably Kennett would find that his memory of happenings on the shift in question would come back to him in course of time. Rawson Robertshaw, deputy, said the small traces of gas he had found in the three weeks previous to the explosion had caused him no anxiety. He had never seen sufficient gas to cause him to contemplate stopping the machinery or calling the men out. Until he detected 1¼ per cent, of gas he would not advise the stopping of the machinery. He could not suggest how there could have been so great an accumulation of gas as to cause an explosion of the violence of that which did occur. Wilfred Schofield, deputy, said he had only found slight traces of gas during the fortnight before the explosion — nothing to suggest any danger. He had no idea how gas could have accumulated to do the damage which was done.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||