26th July 1941, Page: 27, Column: 2
Producer Gas — Main Disadvantages
In a paper on "Producer Gas for Internal Combustion Engines" before
the South African Institution of Engineers Dr. F. J. Trump, acting
director of the Fuel Research Institute of South Africa, said that low
temperature coke, which is extensively used in Great Britain, is generally
prepared on a fairly large scale, requiring a modicum of technical knowledge,
with the result that a standard and reliable product can be obtained. Referring
to cokes from six selected South African coals, he said the minimum ash content
of the cokes experimented with was 12.2 per cent. In Great Britain a maximum
ash content of 5 per cent. is specified.
The paper by Dr. Trump had special reference to South African
conditions, and he observed that the following are some of the main
disadvantages of the use of producer gas in motor vehicles :—
(a) Extra weight of apparatus to be carried, approximately 500 lb.
(b) Space taken up on vehicle by producer and cleaners.
(c) Requires refuelling approximately every 50-100 miles.
(d) Large volume occupied by additional fuel, if carried on vehicle. To run 100
miles approximately two bags of charcoal are required.
(e) Scrubbers require frequent cleaning.
(f) Grate requires cleaning at least once a day, and in many cases more often.
(g) Refuelling, and cleaning of scrubbers and grate necessarily involves the
handling of much dirt.
(h) Difficulty in obtaining fuel of uniform quality. Friable charcoal will
choke the producer. Charcoal which has not been properly burnt will give off
tar, which will give engine trouble.
(i) Imperfections in the producers and scrubbers resulting in breakdowns of
producer plant or engine troubles.
All these disadvantages must necessarily be faced if emergency conditions
enforce the use of producer gas vehicles. For stationary plant many of the
disadvantages disappear and others are minimised, but even here, some of the
people who have been using producer gas in stationary units in the Union for
ten and more years, have recently gone in for Diesel and other types of power
units in order to avoid the trouble associated with the use of producers.
Owing to demand and competition, power units using liquid fuel have reached a
very high state of perfection. The same cannot be said generally of producer
gas units. In order that producer gas may survive under normal conditions
careful research and prolonged tests carried out under practical conditions are
necessary.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Trump, F. J., Dr. | | Acting Director, Fuel Research Institute | |