12th July 1941, Page: 7, Column: 1
Fracturing Of Quartzites Under Pressure*
By Oscar Weiss.
It is well known to all students of the earth's crust that there are still wide
gaps in the observations of physical phenomena in the rocks that form the upper
10,000 feet of our globe. Thus, while magnificent theories fill volumes about
the nature of the crust down to its very core, we find that very few facts are
known even about its skin. A great mining field like the Witwatersrand offers
unique opportunities for learning about rocks down to nearly 9,000 feet in
depth.
Faulting, cleavage and jointing are special cases of fracturing; they all
involve an increase in rock volume. The volume increase and the friction on the
surface of fractures are the important factors. The nature of the host rock,
competent or incompetent has, to some extent, secondary role at great depths,
i.e., under high stresses, as the volume increase and friction can be greatly
influenced by the suitable distribution of stresses, such as by high confining
pressures.
We know that fracturing is a relief from stresses, but the conditions of
rupture remain unknown to us in spite of the various stress, strain and shear
theories of failure. It is well worth realising this fact before applying
theories to mining and geological problems. Such a high authority as
Bridgman concludes after a lifetime's work that "For myself, I am
exceedingly sceptical as to whether there is any such thing as a genuine
criterion of rupture." He further states "These considerations as
well as the experimental facts indicate therefore that we should attempt to
establish criteria of rupture only as a matter of practical convenience, as for
engineering purposes, and that we should expect any such criteria to be valid
only in a narrow range of conditions, both of stress and material."
In dealing with crushing tests, the following few points are worth
recapitulation :—
Crushing tests are usually made on cubes or on cylinders the heights of which
are equal to their diameter. These specimens are subjected to uniform direct
pressure on two faces, while the rest of the surfaces are only under the
atmospheric pressure. It should be understood that while there are uniform
pressures on the two faces, the material itself resolves these into
non-homogeneous internal stresses, both direct stresses and shears. This
difference between external and internal stresses should be kept in mind. If in
crushing tests on isotropic materials uniformly distributed stresses would be
required, then the cylindrical specimens should not be compressed between
plates, but between two cones. Through the suitable selection of the angles of
the cone it is possible to achieve that the resultant stress within the test
piece is everywhere a pure axial compression.
The significance of the crushing strength of rocks in mining it limited to
small pillars and supports. Larger pillars and remnants behave like thin plates
and follow their own particular laws.
In dealing with rocks in the earth's crust the usefulness of crushing strength
data is even more restricted. Where can we find rocks in the crust which are
only stressed on two opposing planes, and are otherwise under atmospheric
pressure ?
It is well known that the strength of rocks in crushing tests is a combination
of the resistance of the material against shearing and of the resistance
against motion due to friction. The great importance of friction can be
realised through the fact that the ratio of crushing strength to resistance
against pure shearing is about 14 : 1 in most rocks. This means that if the
crushing strength of Witwatersrand quartzites is 20,000-30,000 lb./sq. inch,
then its strength against pure shear is roughly only 1,430-2,140 lb./sq. inch.
It is suggested that the two sets of conjugate shear planes found in the
Witwatersrand quartzites are remnants of the effects of differential pressures
to which these rocks were once subjected. If this be true, then by crushing
oriented rock samples of a given locality, the direction of the shear planes
should show a constant tendency. And vice versa, if this tendency has once been
established from the direction of the shear planes, the orientation of rock
pieces should be possible through simple crushing tests. It is, therefore,
possible that a new method of orientation of rock samples, and the study of
structural forces, may be achieved in regions of past or active differential
pressures.
It is important to realise that these shears do not occur simultaneously. In
solid and fairly homogeneous rocks the time intervals between the development
of the shears are extremely short, but the reverberating sound that accompanies
the failing of rocks proves that we are dealing with rapidly repeated failures.
The time interval measurement may be a very interesting new a line of research.
When the specimens contained incipient or visible shears before the tests, it
has been observed by the writer that the shears occurred under compression at
longer intervals. In one specimen a visible shear plane existed in the rock.
Under compression the first shear occurred at the load of 5.04 tons, When a
vertical slab broke off, and at the same time the indicator showed a sudden
fall in the pressure. Continuing the experiment without interruption, the load
increased again to eight tons when a second shear system occurred, and again
the pressure dropped temporarily. Following this, the remaining parts of the
specimen resisted a further higher load, and final collapse took place at the
load of 10.38 tons. The above experience throws new light on the often
discussed observations in our mines, namely, that bursts may occur in the same
pillar repeatedly.
* Excerpts from paper on "Experiments on the Fracturing of Witwatersrand
Quartzites under Direct Pressure," presented at March meeting of the
Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of South Africa.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bridgman, — | | | |
| Weiss, Oscar | | | |