12th July 1941, Page: 4, Column: 1
Extinguishing Waste-Bank Fire
Officials of the Philadelphia and Reading Coal and Iron Co. have permitted
publication of certain experiences in connection with the extinguishing of an
extensive waste-bank fire at the St. Nicholas Colliery in the Western Middle
anthracite field near Mahanoy City, Pa. Particulars are given by Mr. R. D. Leitch,
chemical engineer of the U.S. Bureau of Mines safety division, in
Information Circular 7104 of the Bureau under the caption "Some
Information on Extinguishing an Anthracite Refuse-bank Fire near Mahanoy City,
Pa." Some of the notes are reproduced from the Circular.
By R. D. Leitch.
The well-known methods for preventing spontaneous firing of coal are underwater
storage, maintenance of storage piles at a maximum height, below which the heat
generated by oxidation can be dissipated, sizing and either packing the piles
to cut off air or keeping them loose and well ventilated by cribbing or other
means, and close observation to detect abnormal heating under the three
last-named methods. To these may be added the effective but less practicable
measure of separating and burning, under controlled conditions, the combustible
material in the waste.
Quenching with water or smothering with incombustible material has often been
effective in extinguishing relatively small fires in stored coal, but usually
it is advisable, if not necessary, to dig out the hot or burning coal. The same
method may be effective with waste-pile fires, but are less likely to be
employed, as the lower value of the waste does not justify the costs incident
to the greater areas and volumes involved and the presence of more difficult
physical handicaps.
Data are not available on the total losses caused by burning bank fires or on
the cost when it has been necessary to extinguish them. These losses and costs,
however, must now aggregate several million dollars, to which many millions of
dollars certainly will be added in the future unless more effective and less
costly methods of handling these troublesome fires are discovered.
Story of the Fire.
The first evidence of fire in the St. Nicholas waste pile was noted on 13th
November, 1937, when carbon monoxide was found in No. 1 rock hole to the Holmes
vein off No. 15 tunnel, No. 7 plane level, at Maple Hill Colliery. Four days
later it was decided to fight the fire by excavating and trucking the burning
material to an area east of the fire, where it could be isolated from other
banks or coal outcrops and cooled by spraying with water pumped from a nearby
creek. While getting equipment to the site and installing pumping facilities it
also was decided to attempt other control measures. Churn-drill holes were made
to determine the extent of the fire. After the holes had served their purpose
they were flooded with a suspension of one bag (80 pounds) of rock dust in
about ten gallons of water and abandoned. During excavations later it was
observed that the rock dust had penetrated radially into the surrounding
material for a distance of 6 to 8 feet.
An interesting feature at the time the rock-dust solution was applied through
the churn-drill holes was the presence of a faint ammonia odour in the vicinity
of the holes. The ammonia probably was liberated by the chemical action of free
lime on ammoniacal compounds, the free lime being formed by the action of heat
on the limestone rock dust applied, while the ammoniacal compounds resulted
from semi-distillation of carbonaceous matter in the refuse bank.
Temperature readings were taken at the various depths as the drilling
progressed. It was necessary to case all holes to full depth. Those not
exceeding 120 feet in depth were cased with 10-inch pipe, but it was necessary
in deeper holes to use 8-inch diameter liner pipe as an inner casing to prevent
buckling, and this was the procedure on all holes exceeding 120 feet in depth.
The method of applying limestone rock-dust solution through holes made in the
bank has been used successfully to control refuse-bank fires at other
locations. Owing to difficult drilling conditions on the St. Nicholas
refuse-bank, this method of application of rock dust was limited to locations
where the churn drilling would not interfere with the excavation of the fire
and the completed test holes could be flooded with rock-dust solution. While
churn drilling was in progress, an attempt was made to smother the fire by
rock-dusting the surface. The rock dust was spread by chutes extending from the
top of the bank down to the fire area. The chutes were moved laterally along
the bank until the surface was covered as desired. A total of 700 tons of rock
dust was used to cover an area of 7,500 square feet to a depth of 2 to 3 feet.
The procedure appeared to be ineffective as a fire-control measure.
Excavation and Transport.
Following the decision to excavate the burning material, it was necessary to
construct a truck road to the vicinity of the fire. This required the
construction of about 1,200 feet of road along the slope of the old Maple Hill
refuse-bank. Water lines and pumps were installed to quench the burning
material.
During the construction of the truck road, several operators on the excavating
equipment were overcome by fumes from the fire, and it was decided to install
forced ventilation. Accordingly, two centrifugal blower fans were placed in
fresh air on the Maple Hill refuse-bank and delivered air through a 20-inch
ventube to the excavating equipment and trucks in the pit. As the area of the
pit increased during excavation, natural ventilation increased and the
artificial ventilation system was unnecessary after about three months of work.
The general plan for extinguishing the fire was to isolate the burning
material, load it on trucks, and quench at a selected site east of the fire. In
somewhat more detail, the plan was first to isolate the Maple Hill bank by
excavating with small dragline shovels a trench to natural surface between the
two banks to prevent spread of the fire into that bank ; then, as much as
possible of the material overlying the fire in the St. Nicholas bank was to be
removed by a large dragline shovel and cast back on top of the refuse pile ;
and finally, the remaining material, including that actually on fire, was to be
transported by trucks as first-mentioned.
The equipment for this work was all Diesel-powered except the gasoline-driven
43-B shovel. The transportation equipment consisted of 20 gasoline-driven Mack
dump trucks of 9-cubic-yard capacity. After the trench had been excavated along
the Maple Hill bank, similar trenches were excavated roughly at right angles
southward along the east and west limits of the fire, and finally isolation was
completed by trenching along the south limit of the fire. Thus, an island of
burning material was left remaining in the pit except for the main truck road,
a necessary connecting link. However, this part of the road was a clay fill, so
that the fire remained completely isolated to the end of the work. When the
fire was completely isolated from the adjoining banks it was a matter of
excavating the burning material and hauling it to the dump area, where it was
cooled with water.
Considerable difficulty was experienced in excavating the northern portion of
the "island," where the coarser rock of the Maple Hill bank was fused
to form a massive clinker that extended from the east to the west limits of the
fire. This clinker had to be drilled and shot, which was accomplished by first
cooling with water the area to be drilled. Even then it was impossible to drill
holes deeper than 4½ feet, as heat of the clinker below this depth caused
flattening of the drill bit. Holes were 3 inches in diameter, spaced 6 feet
apart. The charge for each hole consisted of two 2- by 12-inch sticks of 40 per
cent. dynamite wrapped in sheet asbestos.
Disposal of Burning Material.
Excavation of the burning material was completed 28th May, 1938. It is
estimated that a total of 1,685,300 cubic yards of material was moved, of which
786,400 cubic yards was moved by the 10-W Monighan dragline located on top of
the St. Nicholas bank and 898,900 cubic yards was moved by the smaller
machines. Of the total quantity of material handled by the smaller machines,
798,900 cubic yards was loaded into trucks and hauled to the disposal area. The
burning material was dumped in individual piles until the dump area was
covered, then the whole area was cooled with streams of water from a number of
hose lines. After the piles had cooled sufficiently they were levelled with a
bulldozer and another layer of hot material was added after due precautions had
been taken to make certain that the previous layer was completely cooled.
Attention to Health Standard.
Although 87 persons engaged in the work suffered some sort of injury, the
health and accident record is remarkably favourable when it is considered that
during a total of more than 28,000 man-days in hazardous work (for much of the
time in winter), no fatalities occurred and the injuries were mostly of a minor
nature. Of the 87 injuries 55 required no lost time ; thirty of the total were
due to operation of trucks.
Early in the work the smoke, fumes, and dust seemed to have a definite
psychological effect. The situation was improved speedily and later eliminated
by providing gas masks for shovel operators and dust respirators for others ;
and providing the general foreman with a carbon monoxide detector, which he
used frequently in the presence of other employees with repeated assurance that
no dangerous atmospheres existed. His almost constant presence at suspected
points of danger is believed to have allayed most of the fear experienced
early. Gas masks seldom were used after short trials, although they were always
readily available, because the men preferred the discomfort without respiratory
protection to that experienced in wearing masks. Forced ventilation was
provided during the early and worst stages of the work, and a well-equipped
first-aid station was maintained on the ground.
The man-days worked numbered 28,218, and the job cost 532,000 dollars.
In some general observations it is pointed out that an interesting feature was
the method by which the fire advanced in the St. Nicholas bank. It was noted
that the fire proceeded in small finger like areas following vents or
concentrations of coarser material. As is common on all high banks, most of the
coarser material is concentrated at the bottom of the bank or at the junction
of two banks or sections of the same bank. As in this instance, concentrations
of coarser material usually are found in lines parallel to the slope of the
bank. Thus, a grate and multiple chimney effect is produced by which air is
drawn through the fire area making it difficult or even impossible to control
by blanketing with limestone dust, earth, sand, clay, or other similar
material. In digging out such fires, the finger like spread may allow the
drilling of exploratory holes to indicate the actual limits of the fire.
It appears that if a barrier to the extension of a fire in waste banks of
similar material is to be made by introducing a suspension of rock dust in
water, the drill holes should not be more than ten to twelve feet apart, as the
spread of the rock dust here did not exceed six to eight feet radially from the
holes. The distance would vary, of course, with the nature of the refuse,
temperatures due to the fire, and possibly other conditions.
Frequent inspections of surface waste piles and recording of sub-surface
temperatures with analyses of the gases occurring a few feet beneath the
surface are of value in preventing firing and certainly in discovering a fire
or tendency to fire in the incipient stages. These data can and should be
obtained by drilling holes a few feet in depth wherever evidence of heating is
noted, as for example the presence of steam or smoke or the melting of snow in
the winter.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Leitch, R. D. | | Chemical Engineer, U.S. Bureau of Mines | |