12th July 1941, Page: 2, Column: 1
Coal Preparation And Washing
Members of the South African Institution of Engineers and the Chemical,
Metallurgical and Mining Society of South Africa, following the reading by
Mr. T. Coulter, at the March joint meeting, of his paper on "Some
Recent Problems in Coal Preparation and Washing on the Lewis and Marks Group of
Collieries" (see pp. 401-2, No. 26, Vol. 51), dealt with a number of
points in an interesting discussion. Extracts from the journals of the
societies are appended.
Factors to be Considered.
Mr. M. Turner said that mining men are naturally inclined to weigh up
the benefits to be derived from the preparation of coal by washing entirely
from the economic point of view, and it may be possible to cite cases where the
increase of price received for the washed product would not cover the extra
cost involved.
The increased cost of washing the coal compared with dry screening is not the
whole difference, for consideration must be given to other factors, such as
:—
1. Increased capital cost of the plant compared with a dry screening plant.
2. Extra power cost resulting from probable higher maximum K.V.A. demand.
3. Increase in working cost per ton sold, arising from the higher percentage of
discard that would result from washing necessitating the mining of a larger
tonnage for the same sales output.
4. Round coal must be broken to suitable size for washing, resulting in the
production of more small coal which is sold at a lower price. The Duff coal
produced by the breaker may even have to be discarded through lack of sale for
such a product.
By adopting a washing process for the preparation of coal, the calorific value
of the small sizes will be increased appreciably by the elimination of the low
grade coal, dirt and pyritic matter.
The average ash content of the coal will be considerably lowered and will show
little variation from day to day, so that the benefits to the consumer will be
much greater than the increase in calorific value would indicate.
Main Objects in View.
Dr. P. N. Lategan recalled that coal washing is undertaken with two main
objects in view — firstly to reduce the ash content and thereby improve
the calorific value, and secondly to separate different types of coal from a
heterogeneous seam for specific purposes.
Washing improves the calorific value of a coal by removing extraneous
impurities and also bone coal of high inherent ash.
By washing, coking coal or gas coal of low ash content can be separated from
steam coal of higher inherent ash.
The extent to which improvement in calorific value or separation of various
types of coal can be accomplished depends on the difference in specific
gravities of constituents to be separated.
The bigger the difference the easier the separation, e.g., the removal of
extraneous matter such as shale and pyrites presents no difficulties.
The removal, however, of bone coal with a specific gravity not very much
different from the good coal is a far more difficult matter.
South African coals contain high percentages of bone coal of high mineral
content intimately mixed with it. The removal of this bone coal or part of it
is not only a problem that presents physical difficulties, but also entails
large recovery losses. Heavy discards with comparatively small improvement in
the washed product are, of course, uneconomic. Fortunately, in South Africa
coal is mostly sold on the unit of heat basis and the enhanced price realised
by the producer compensates for the loss in discard.
Until comparatively recently small coal was a by-product of round coal which
was and still is to a greater extent cleaned by hand picking. The introduction,
however, of mechanical methods of firing increased the demand for smalls, and
the question of improving its value by the removal of extraneous matter became
necessary.
Here, obviously, hand picking is out of the question and the producer had to
apply mechanical methods of cleaning. Although at first reluctant to embark on
the capital expenditure necessary for a washing plant, the producer soon
realised that the enhanced prices obtained made mechanical cleaning of his
smalls a profitable policy.
As the consumer is often the dictator of quality the time is perhaps not far
distant when he may demand washed coal and nothing but washed coal. Even the
domestic consumer is beginning to realise the advantages of a well-graded
Washed product. For these reasons alone the producer who equips a new pit
to-day and does not install or make provision for the installation of a washer
in his layout may regret such an omission dearly in the near future.
Determination of Maximum Size.
In his contribution Mr. V. Pickles said that coal remains still our
greatest source of power, and it is the power engineer's business, or should
be, to try to utilise as much of the energy available in the coal mines as
possible.
In the early days of the Rand Power Company it was the practice to divide the
colliery product for use at its power stations into two grades, namely, nuts
and slacks. The slack was that part which passed through a 7/8-inch screen and
the nuts were of a size 1¼-inch-7/8-inch. The slack Was the more difficult
to burn and it was only when they devised what is known as the stoker screen
that the position was reversed, after which it was no longer necessary to
produce the two separate grades.
Mr. Pickles briefly recounted how this came about. In 1926 the screening
plant of tho Largo Colliery was destroyed by fire, and until it could be
repaired the only product available to the Power Company from this colliery was
a mixture of nuts and slack. Fortunately at that time a number of boilers had
been equipped with stoker screens, and it was found that with their use the
mixture of nuts and slack could be burned without loss of efficiency or output.
It was therefore obvious that separation was no longer necessary, and the
production of nuts was forthwith abandoned, both at Largo and Cornelia
Collieries. From then onwards the problem resolved itself into a determination
of the proper maximum size to be adopted, and this eventually led to the design
of crushing plant now installed at all the collieries supplying lower grade
coal to the power stations.
The speaker said that in their investigations it was found that the sizing of
the coal has a very important bearing on furnace ignition, and on ash loss, and
experience has proved conclusively that the maximum size of the product fed to
the boilers should not be more than ¾-inch. It is also necessary that the
percentage of fines below 1/16-inch should be as small as possible because,
with modern highly rated chain grate stokers, the air pressure under the fuel
bed necessary for rapid combustion is high enough to lift the very fine grade
coal off the grate, much of which is either deposited unburnt into the ashpit
or is carried away in the gas stream. He mentioned this condition because it
not only has to be considered in the design of the crushing plant but because
the present-day use of coal-cutters produces a very appreciable amount of
fines, which he believes is influenced by the "pick setting" of the
coal-cutters.
Improving Low Grade Coal.
Closing the evening's discussion Dr. J. H. Dobson emphasised that the
subject of "Coal Preparation and Washing" is one which has come more
and more to the forefront during the last ten or fifteen years, particularly in
the large industrial areas of the world wherein the successful eradication of
the smoke nuisance has been unfortunately accompanied by a steadily growing
dust nuisance from the very large super power stations in the midst of crowded
populations, particularly from such of those power stations, etc., which were
utilising pulverised coal. Intensive research into the deleterious effects and
social consequences of the oxides of sulphur liberated on the combustion of
coal in closely circumscribed areas became absolutely imperative. Economical
considerations were, of course, also intimately associated with these nuisances
and injurious effects.
South Africa's coal problems, so far as washing and preparation are concerned,
are therefore principally confined to improving low grade coal, thereby
creating markets and uses for large coal tonnages which otherwise could not be
mined on a profitable basis.
The natural corollary to this is that coal of relatively high quality, when
properly prepared and suitably washed, can also be made of still better quality
; and, furthermore, a more uniform grade can be supplied which must be of
appreciable economic importance to the consumer, and inter-linked with these
conditions is the greater use of existing coal mining areas. South Africa's
coal preparation problems are therefore principally economic and relatively
free from the difficult social responsibilities referred to.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Coulter, T. | | | |
| Dobson, J. H., Dr. | | | |
| Lategan, P. N., Dr. | | | |
| Pickles, V. | | | |
| Turner, M. | | | |