28th June 1941, Page: 416, Column: 2
Dust Sampling
At the March meeting of the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of South
Africa Mr. J. de V. Lambrechts presented a paper on "A Critical
Review of Dust Sampling Methods Employed in Witwatersrand Gold Mines." He
said that for the last 30 years dust sampling has been an important subject in
Witwatersrand mining, and the great success achieved in decreasing the
incidence of silicosis on these fields has perhaps been due in no small measure
to the use of the sugar tube and that small instrument, the Konimeter.
Only comparatively recently the sugar tube method of sampling was abandoned
presumably not because it was valueless in principle but because results were
not sufficiently discriminating.
In 1934 came the Thermal Precipitator with a technique which was foreign to
current practice on the Rand, namely, omission to acid-treat dust records.
Results yielded by the Thermal Precipitator were startlingly different from
those given by the Konimeter.
Various clouds of dust such as those created by wet drilling, dry drilling,
ore-tipping, etc., were sampled by the Thermal Precipitator and Konimeter
simultaneously and the corresponding dust determinations made. Rather contrary
to expectations, it Was found that the Konimeter was not necessarily less
efficient than the Thermal Precipitator and also, it Was not necessarily less
efficient for the flue particles than for the coarse particles. In fact, for
certain dusts, namely, those which were comparatively dry, it appeared that the
Konimeter may actually have an apparent efficiency greater than that of the
Thermal Precipitator. This, it is suggested, is due to the fact that in dry
dusts particles occur in aggregates, and that the Konimeter breaks up those
aggregates, whereas the Thermal Precipitator does not.
Concluding his paper Mr. Lambrechts expressed the hope that the
Konimeter, with certain alterations in technique, will remain an invaluable
scientific instrument to be used alongside the Thermal Precipitator. The former
will probably be used more specifically for routine work and the latter more
specifically for research work.
Contributing to the discussion following the reading of the paper Mr. J. P. Rees
said that taking a broad view of the dust problem it seemed that the
engineer's object is to maintain underground an atmosphere similar to that
prevailing on the surface on a fine morning. From this point of view the
question of which particles are harmful does not arise. The object is to remove
all particulate matter. Taking a narrow view of the problem, the engineer's
object is to remove those particles which are dangerous to health. In our
present state of knowledge, opinions vary as to which particles are harmless
and therefore need not be considered. And even if our knowledge was more
advanced than it is the broader aim of ventilation and dust prevention cannot
be lost sight of.
There are three main methods of sampling, by weight of dust, by counting
particles and by dispersion of light. The last method reflects the number of
particles present, but is affected by their size and nature. The application of
these methods is controlled and limited by practical considerations, which are
not always obvious. Of the three methods it seems to Mr. Rees that the
particle count offers the most scope.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Lambrechts, J. de V. | | | |
| Rees, J. P. | | | |