28th June 1941, Page: 401, Column: 1
South African Coal Preparation Problems
Discussion before Joint Meeting of Engineers
At the joint meeting in March of the South African Institution of Engineers and
the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of South Africa, Mr. T. Coulter*
read a paper on "Some Recent Problems in Coal Preparation and
Washing on the Lewis and Marks Group of Collieries."
The Author said the subject of "Coal Preparation" covers a wide range
of methods used in handling "Run-of-Mine" coal as it comes straight
from the colliery workings into the surface plant, and in crushing, screening,
cleaning and loading the various products into railway trucks for dispatch to
the consumer.
During the past decade some interesting changes have taken place in America,
Britain and on the Continent in the technique of preparing coal for the market,
particularly in regard to the methods employed for cleaning, in which some new
and novel systems have recently been developed on a commercial scale.
No two coal handling problems are treated in the same manner. There is a great
diversity of opinion and ideas as to how a plant should be designed and laid
out to meet any given set of conditions.
Nowadays there is such a wide range of good plant to choose from that it often
becomes a matter of extreme difficulty for the engineer to make up his mind on
the type of equipment best suited to his requirements, for in that selection
very often lies the key to layout and flow sheet details.
There is also that human tendency, which manifests itself in many subtle ways,
to stick to the narrow path of proved methods, to play safe as it were, and to
leave experimentation to other people.
Whatever course is adopted the engineer who is called upon to deal with any
given coal handling problem must decide and act according to his training,
judgment and experience, and then hope for the best.
The golden rules to be followed in getting the right kind of plant vary
according to one's experience ; the wider and harder the experience, the easier
it usually becomes to judge the merits or otherwise of proposals put forward
for meeting any given requirements.
Conditions in Five Coal Areas.
Mr. Coulter reviewed five problems covering various classes of coal and
differing substantially in plant capacity and market requirements, concluding
his paper with some general observations on the subject of crushing and
washing. The cases examined and reviewed are those which have recently been
dealt with at the following collieries : (1) The East Shaft of Springfield
Colliery in the Vereeniging District (installation, "Chance" heavy
liquid gravity type) ; (2) The West Shaft of Springfield Colliery
("Norton" improved "Baum" type) ; (3) Largo Colliery in the
Springs District (Norton type) ; (4) Schoongezicht Colliery in the Witbank
District (Chance type) ; (5) Vryheid Coronation Colliery in the Vryheid
District (Felspar Jig type washery installed specially for coking coal).
Springfield Colliery (East Shaft) is situated about four miles north of
Vereeniging township. It was opened up in the year 1935 for the primary purpose
of supplying the coal requirements of Klip Power Station, certain tonnage
demands in the domestic and general industrial market also being catered for.
Boring operations and some prior milling experience in the outcrop zones had
proved the existence of a seam of coal ranging from a few feet up to 60 feet in
thickness, generally low in grade, and containing varying amounts of
interbedded shale and lying on a highly undulating bed of water-bearing
dolomites. This unusually thick seam was made up of alternating beds of
different classes of coal, massive in structure, varying in calorific value
from about 8,000 to 11,500 B.T.U.'s and intercalated with thin bands of
carbonaceous and clay shale.
The West Shaft, about 1½ miles distant from the East Shaft, was
opened up and developed in 1937-38 for the purpose of meeting additional
demands for coal at Klip Power Station.
Compared with the East Shaft, the coal preparation problem at the West Shaft
was much simpler, as there Was no necessity for double stage washing, ample
provision having already been made for meeting the domestic trade requirements
from the East Shaft plant. However, it was considered advisable to arrange for
washing the entire Run-of-Mine output, including the -¾ inch fraction, as
the handling and transport arrangements were such as to remove much of the
moisture from the washed product before it reached the power station bunkers.
Largo Colliery is situated in the Springs District and has been
operating for about 21 years. All coal produced at Largo is crushed down to
minus 2/2½ inch mesh in the first instance, after which a certain
proportion of nuts is screened out, before crushing the balance down to minus
7/8 inch.
The coalfield contains three separate seams, low in grade and similar in
character to the Vereeniging coals. The Bottom seam is the best of the three,
from the standpoint of quality, with the Top and Middle seams ranking on a
lower and more or less equal basis. Gradual exhaustion of the bottom seam
reserves over the past few years has necessitated drawing larger proportions of
output from the other two seams, and this resulted in a marked falling off in
both the calorific value and burning qualities of the coal, giving rise to
various difficulties at the power stations.
Cleaning facilities were limited to the usual hand sorting, which at best gives
very poor results in dealing with these low grade coals. Consideration was
therefore given to the question of washing and the necessary investigations
were carried out regarding the system to be adopted. Experience with the
Springfield East and West shaft plants proved to be most helpful in dealing
with the Largo problem.
Schoongezicht Colliery is situated in the Witbank District and has been
working for over 19 years. Two seams are being mined, namely the Bottom or No.
1 seam, and the Main or No. 2 seam of the Witbank coalfield.
Both seams contain hard, tough coal, with numerous intrusions of interbedded
hard shaly sandstone (locally known as "floating bands"), while the
coal itself shows variations in calorific value over a wide range. As a result
of these conditions, the usual system of cleaning by hand on sorting belts did
not always give the desired results. Apart from this, selective methods of
mining had to be adopted underground and losses of marketable coal inevitably
took place.
Early in the year 1937 it was decided to investigate the question of erecting a
new coal handling plant, embodying washing facilities. Choice of a washing
process was governed by two important points, firstly the extreme range in the
sizes to be washed, namely 9 inches down to ¼ inch; and secondly the
necessity for accurate separation, in view of the character of the coal and the
comparatively high percentage of refuse to be discharged so as to obtain the
desired improvement in quality. The decision was finally made in favour of
another "Chance" installation equipped with a 12-foot diameter cone
for single stage washing.
Vryheid Coronation Colliery is situated in the Vryheid district of
Northern Natal and has been producing for about 18 years, Three seams are
worked, each averaging about 4 feet thick and yielding very soft, friable coal
of high coking propensity.
Expansion in coke production gave rise to certain problems in the washing of
small coal of a size -¼ inch mesh. Approximately two tons of Run-of-Mine
coal are required for the production of one ton of coke. The raw coal is washed
to remove stone, shale and bone material, some 33 per cent. being discarded in
the process. Two tons of raw coal yield, after washing, about 1.34 tons of
clean coal, which on being coked in the open burning ovens used at this
colliery, will produce roughly one ton of coke. Therefore, for the production
of 10,000 tons of coke per month, 20,000 tons of raw coal are required.
Mr. Coulter's review of the five coal preparation problems covered a
range of different layouts and methods in which an aggregate of about 16,750
tons of Run-of-Mine coal are being handled each working day. Of this total,
approximately 14,250 tons, equal to about 85 per cent., are washed each day.
Coal Specification Changes.
The paper included much material in detail of special interest to South African
students and users of plant. It may be admissible here to present excerpts from
the Author's general statement of conclusions as under :—
Apart from the large tonnage being washed, considerable quantities of crushed
coal are also required for power station consumption, and at three of the five
collieries under discussion some 10,000 tons per day of a specially graded
-¾ inch product have to be supplied.
Many years ago the Victoria Falls and Transvaal Power Company used to burn coal
crushed down to about 1¼ inches only, with a certain proportion of
oversize, but gradually that specification has been altered first to 1 inch,
then to ¾ inch, and at the present time the plants must operate so as to
produce not more than 1 or 2 per cent, oversize left on a ¾ inch mesh
screen.
An important point about the specification of coal for these stations is the
necessity for maintaining correct grading in the smaller -½ inch of which
the proportion now called for must average about 65 per cent., with
approximately 35 per cent, able to pass through a ¼ inch mesh screen.
Changes in coal specification have naturally had very marked repercussions on
plant design, and crushing is no longer a matter of pushing the coal through a
couple of toothed rolls, but a scientific business in which the product goes
through quite a lengthy process of crushing, screening and re-crushing until
the desired size and grading is obtained.
In dealing with crushing problems experience has shown the necessity for good
equipment, with ample margin in capacity to meet the heavy and unavoidable
fluctuations in both load and grading of the coal delivered to the plant.
As a matter of interest it should be noted that all coal which passes through
the plant is subject to more or less continuous sampling, from which one
composite sample representing the tonnage supplied each day is prepared for
calorific determination.
While it is true that many European collieries are actually discarding in the
process of washing greater percentages of refuse than South African collieries
are called upon to deal with, the dirt is mostly confined to the smaller sizes
under two or three inches, and is adventitious shale or sandstone not inherent
in the seam but associated with it in the roof or floor. Lump coal is usually a
high grade low ash product, requiring only a small amount of hand picking. It
is not uncommon for a colliery in England to wash out 20/30 per cent. of its
smaller sizes as refuse, but in doing so the ash content is often reduced from
20/25 per cent, to as low as 4 or 5 per cent.
Such results cannot be obtained in South Africa because the general run of coal
is quite different, especially in the Transvaal where the inherent ash content
is high with the middling fraction, in certain seams, reaching heavy
proportions.
Washing Systems.
Since the first big "Chance" plant was introduced at the Springfield
Colliery, nearly six years ago, much information and valuable experience has
been gained in dealing with these complex coals, from which both purchasers and
suppliers of washing equipment have profited.
Experience in the use of both the Baum and Chance systems during that period
has convinced the Author that each has its merit, suitability and special field
of application in dealing with South African coals.
During the past two years, further progress has been made in developing the
heavy liquid system of washing along new lines, in which separation is effected
in a more or less static liquid. A number of commercial plants are now at work
in England and high separation efficiency is being claimed at most of these
installations.
Speaking generally of Transvaal conditions, it is probably true that in many
instances the long distance benefits from a washing, policy are quite
appreciable.
Most Transvaal coals are amenable to washing, and there are very considerable
tonnage reserves of coal available in the Union, with the calorific value lying
not far below the "A" grade line, which could be easily brought up to
that line by efficient cleaning. Obviously such propositions call for washing,
and any attempt to exploit these areas without regard to the benefits Which
would accrue from good methods of coal preparation is merely asking for trouble
that could easily be avoided.
Calorific Standard.
Many collieries in the Witbank District have been obliged for a number of years
past to maintain standards of quality slightly higher than the average weight
of the field, and this has necessitated a certain amount of selective mining,
besides imposing considerable hardship in maintaining grade. These difficulties
are well known to all producers in the Witbank field, and there is no doubt
whatever that the adoption of washing greatly eases the struggle and vigilance
necessary in supplying clean, good quality coal up to the required calorific
standard.
There is a natural tendency at times to regard the present 12.8 standard
(calorific value 12.80 lb./lb.) as being too high for easy and comfortable
attainment, and suggestions are often heard that the figure should be reduced
to 12.5 and so, it is contended, rule out the necessity and expense of washing.
Reducing the standard would not, in the opinion of the Author, eliminate the
need for washing many areas of Main Seam, which at best is usually a mixed
grill of dull and bright coal of constantly varying grade.
Selective Mining.
In this connection the conflict between producer and consumer raises an
interesting point. The consumer is looking more and more for a product
containing maximum heating value, with the minimum of ash content, and in
fairness it should be said that he does not usually object to paying a little
extra on the pitsmouth price for the better grade product.
On the other hand, anxious enquiries are made from time to time on behalf of
the Government as to whether coal mining companies are not indulging in too
much selective mining for the benefit of the consumer to the detriment of
national interest and posterity.
In these difficult circumstances Mr. Coulter says it is impossible to
lay down any clear cut suggestions as to what policy should be followed in
working South African coalfields to the best advantage, beyond perhaps saying
that the producer must adopt a middle course by working his property to the
best ultimate advantage, at the same time keeping faith with the consumer.
Coal mining after all is a competitive business in which mining conditions,
working costs, quality of the product and so on all play their part in making
the Profit and Loss Account look pleasing or otherwise.
All things being equal, good quality products command attention in the market,
and relieve the producer of much worry and trouble in dealing with the
consumer.
The Author is of opinion that better methods of coal preparation, including
washing, will play an important part in the future in opening up many areas
regarded at the moment as indifferent commercial subjects, and thus greatly add
to the reserves of good quality coal available to meet the Union's
requirements.
* Consulting Engineer of the Lewis and Marks group of collieries.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Coulter, T. | | Consulting Engineer | |