14th June 1941, Page: 387, Column: 2
Smoking Dangers In Mines
More or less unconsciously and from sheer force of habit human beings do many
things they probably would not do if the possible consequences of their acts
were fully recognised and appreciated. That is the introductory statement by
Messrs. D. Harrington and D. J. Parker in the United States
Bureau of Mines Information Circular 7141 on "Explosions in Coal Mines
Caused by Smoking." They add that although a relatively harmless habit in
the proper environment, smoking has been the cause or suspected cause of many
gas explosions and black-powder ignitions and has resulted in numerous
instances of bodily injury, loss of life, and destruction of property.
Likewise, many fires, in both coal and metal mines, causing loss of life, have
been started by smoking.
The Authors give a summary of thirteen cases in which smoking was suspect, two
of them from British practice. From the body of the Circular the following
figures and general remarks are extracted :—
As far back as 1839 and up to and including 1937, at least 678 explosions,
which resulted in the death of 5,429 persons and were caused by open lights or
smoking, are known to have occurred in the coal mines of the United States.
Owing to the identical hazards involved, ignition from either cause has been
the greatest single source of explosions, having been responsible for 23.7 per
cent, of all those of which record was available up to 1938.
Temperature of Burning Tobacco.
From time to time the question has been raised whether burning tobacco in the
form of cigars and cigarettes or in pipes will ignite methane or firedamp.
Since a flame (which readily ignites methane), whether from a match or patent
lighter, is generally used by smokers, the question seems to be somewhat
pointless and irrelevant and may lead one to believe that once the tobacco is
ignited in fresh air, away from the working face, a leisurely stroll may be
taken back to the face or other possible gassy place, where a smoke may be
enjoyed with complacency, even in a possibly inflammable or explosive gas-air
mixture.
Exhaustive tests by the U.S. Departments of Commerce and Agriculture in 1916
proved that a burning cigar develops a temperature during puffs of 1,500°
to 1,700°F., and between puffs the temperature ranges from 1,100° to
1,500°F. The temperature necessary to ignite methane ranges from 1,000°
to 1,380°F. Based upon the assumption that temperatures developed by
burning cigarettes and in pipes are comparable to those produced by a burning
cigar, the conclusion is reasonable and obvious that burning tobacco,
regardless of the method of use, is likely to ignite methane, though many
"old timers" are inclined to dispute the correctness of this
conclusion.
The foregoing is a little surprising because preliminary tests in the Bureau of
Mines laboratory about 25 years ago indicated that a glowing cigarette would
not ignite methane until the methane-air mixture attained a velocity of about
1,000 linear feet per minute or more. This appears to the Authors to be beside
the issue, as commonsense and not the air velocity should determine the safest
course to pursue. However, it is well to realise that taking a lighted
cigarette, cigar, or pipe into an explosive mixture of methane and air is
extremely hazardous, and the practice is likely to cause an ignition.
Presenting their conclusions Messrs. Harrington and Parker say
that one of the worst features of surreptitious smoking in mines is that the
smoker usually tries to find some out-of-the-way place in which to smoke, such
as a partly caved pillar region or an abandoned room or other place where
usually there is an extra hazard of methane accumulations owing to difficulty
in ventilating it. Moreover, the mine smoker is no more careful than his type
in a forest or other out-of-the-way place, and very often he leaves behind him
a burned match or unextinguished cigarette, which slowly ignites the
surrounding combustibles, and the fire cannot be discovered easily because of
its hidden location.
The Authors hope that the Circular may be instrumental in helping to prevent
further needless sacrifice of life through the foolish practice of smoking in
mines ; also that it will help to bring about closer co-operation between
employers and employees with respect to this as well as other matters of
safety.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Harrington, D. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Parker, D. J. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |