17th May 1941, Page: 359, Column: 1
Prevention Of Gas-Ignition In The Overcut
Some time ago Mr. Robert D. Beilby, B.Sc. (Hons. Min.), spent two months
at Holditch Colliery in Staffordshire investigating the effect of mist sprays
as a means of clearing and diluting gas in the overcut. Sprays had been in use
on the coal-cutting machines in the Four Foot Seam for a considerable period
before he carried out the research dealt with in his paper before the North of
England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers under the title "The
Prevention of Gas-ignition in the Overcut." It will be recalled that a
serious disaster occurred at Holditch Colliery some three years ago, due to an
ignition of gas in the undercut causing an outbreak of fire and subsequent
explosions.
The Working Cycle.
In his paper before the Institute Mr. Beilby explained that the Four
Foot Seam lies at a depth of 800 yards and has a section varying from 4 feet 8
inches to 5 feet 2 inches of clean coal. The work was carried out on a longwall
conveyor face 420 yards long, having at the time one main intake airway and two
return airways, with a dumb road which was to be converted into a second intake
airway at a later date. The average quantity of air passing along the face
during normal cutting was about 30,000 cubic feet per minute at an average
velocity of 1,000 feet per minute. The face was cut by three overcutting
machines, each operating over approximately a distance of 140 yards. On one cut
two machines worked to the rise, while the third machine worked to the dip and
vice versa on the following cut. The depth of the cut was 4 feet 8 inches and
approximately 7 inches in thickness, with about 6 inches of coal left up for
roof-support purposes. The working cycle was as follows : Filling was carried
out on the day-shift, cutting and moving up of conveyors on the
afternoon-shift, while packing and stonework was done on the afternoon and
night shifts. The face was supported entirely on steel, H-section steel props
and steel straps being used with hardwood chocks set solidly to floor and roof
at intervals along the face.
The machines used were compressed-air driven telescopic overcutters developing
40-50 h.p. at a pressure of 60 lb. per square inch. The sprays were fitted to
all machines, which were also fitted with a cowl at the rear of the jib and
which assisted in reducing the amount of dust produced behind the machine.
These machines had a cutting speed of approximately 1 yard in just over 1
minute.
The sprays were attached to the machine at the back of the jib on to the
framework of the telescopic turret by means of a pin on the framework of the
sprays, which is slotted into a groove on the frame of the machine. The
atomisers were fitted in such a manner as to enable the direction of the spray
to be altered to ensure the maximum effect of the overcut. Each set of sprays
contained four atomising nozzles. The atomisers were fitted at the four corners
of a diamond, set in a cubical framework, and consisted of two concentric
nozzles, water being passed through the outer nozzle and compressed air through
the inner nozzle. The atomisers produce sprays of fine mist and these were
projected into the undercut by the compressed air.
Sampling With and Without Sprays.
A representative survey of the methane-air mixtures present in the overcut was
obtained during actual cutting. In order that samples could be taken, under
normal cutting conditions the machine cut 30 yards from the commencement of
cutting before the first group of samples were taken over a 10-yard length of
face ; when the first group of samples had been taken with either the sprays on
or off, the machine cut a further 25 yards under opposite conditions with
regard to the sprays before sampling was re-commenced. At the outset, four
groups of samples were taken forming two complete series. The first series
consisted of 30 samples, 15 with the sprays on and 15 with the sprays off, all
taken with the coal-cutter travelling in the same direction along the face as
the ventilation. The second series, also of 30 samples as above, was taken with
the coal-cutter travelling up the face against the ventilation. There is a
considerable difference in the results obtained with the sprays off, whereas
with the sprays on, except for samples taken at the back of the cut, there is a
decided similarity in the results obtained in both series.
It was felt that the cowl attached to the machine might have had some effect on
the results obtained. It was therefore decided to take two further series of
samples on two other cuts with the cowl off. The results of these samples show
that there is a similar difference in the results obtained between the samples
taken, with the sprays off, with the ventilation and against the ventilation,
although to a lesser extent than in the first groups of samples. These results
show that any effect which the cowl may have had upon the ventilation was not
responsible for the difference.
The percentages of inflammable gas in the cut are higher in those samples taken
with the cowl on than with the cowl off, but Mr. Beilby does not think
that there is sufficient evidence available to express any opinion that these
differences were wholly due to the presence of the cowl in the ventilating
system.
Combustible Gas Percentages.
In every case without the sprays operating the percentage of combustible gases
present in the atmosphere at the back of the cut was generally above the lower
limit of inflammability of methane, that is, 5.4 per cent. With the sprays in
operation these high percentages were reduced below the lower limit of
inflammability of methane, within a distance of 2½ yards from the back of
the machine, thus reducing the possibility of ignition of gas in the overcut by
heating of cutter-chain or sparks from cutter-picks. In the middle and at the
front of the cut, where in many cases without the sprays on inflammable
mixtures were present, this danger was entirely eliminated by the use of the
sprays.
The following are some examples of the effect of the sprays, taken from the
four series showing conditions which were encountered :—
It will be realised, Mr. Beilby said, that under no circumstances is it
possible to take samples under exactly the same conditions on different days,
as these may vary on each cut from day to day, but with the sprays on the
conditions are more stable and much safer than with the sprays off. One very
important factor has come to light through the experiments carried out, and
that is that there is a considerably lower percentage of methane in the cut
when cutting against the ventilation than when cutting with the ventilation ;
the most marked effect being noted in the samples taken at the back of the cut
with the sprays off, where samples taken against the ventilation are only
slightly above lower point of inflammability, while those taken with the
ventilation are considerably higher.
On the major subject as to the effect of the sprays on the clearance and
dilution of gas in the overcut, the Author says the results show that in every
case with the sprays on there is considerable improvement in the conditions
with regard to gas ignition than without the sprays. In addition to the effects
and benefits which are obtained by clearance of gas from the overcut, the spray
system added moisture to dust formed in cutting, and caused deposition of large
quantities of dust which would otherwise be carried in the ventilating system
of the mine, thus acting as a twofold safety device against any possible
ignition. Furthermore, he concluded, it is quite possible that, in the case of
an actual ignition by heating of cutter picks or sparks from them, the spray
would extinguish the ignition at its source.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Beilby, Robert D. | | | |