17th May 1941, Page: 358, Column: 1
Sodium Vapour Lamps
The First Report of the General Research Committee of the Monmouthshire and
South Wales Coal Owners' Association has been issued under the title "The
Introduction of Sodium Vapour Lamps Underground in British Collieries."
Mr. C. S. Chubb, M.Sc., was the investigator. Appended are extracts from
the Report.
Improvements in electrical and mechanical knowledge made practicable and
economical about ten years ago a type of arc lamp (namely, the electric
discharge lamp) having an enclosed arc striking within a glass tube for
non-consumable electrodes. Several of these, such as the neon tube, were not
suitable illuminants, but two have been developed as more economical and better
sources of light for many purposes than the highly developed tungsten filament
lamps. These two are the mercury and sodium electric discharge lamps.
Colour of Light.
With mercury vapour lighting, colour rendering is very limited. The spectrum of
the light from this lamp is rich in blue, green and yellow radiations in
sharply defined bands, with dark patches between. An object having anything
approaching this particular combination of colour will be seen with enhanced
intensity compared with objects which do not have them, so that the radiations
in limited bands of wave lengths help to provide greater contrasts and better
definition. This property is especially helpful in colliery work where it is
desired to differentiate between coal and the impurities associated with it,
such as shale and stone, because the impurities correspond closely with the
colour of mercury discharge lamps, so that on picking belts or at the coal face
the power to see the difference between coal and dirt is greatly enhanced.
Sodium vapour lamps emit light effectively only at the one band of wave lengths
about 5,890A°. This colour is a pleasant yellow and it has no relation to
the colour of impurities in coal unless it might be the small amount of yellow
pyrites which occurs. The light has therefore no merit for any cleaning
process, and is a disadvantage whenever it is necessary to distinguish dirt
from coal. It would not be advisable, therefore, to use it on the coal face
where coal is filled or at the picking belt because these are two vital points
for visual cleaning of coal.
Lights are used at a very large number of other places underground, and unless
in any of them colour distinction is required sodium electric discharge
lighting may be considered.
In mining, the advantages of mercury vapour lamps were first stressed by
Professor T. David Jones, and later by the investigator, for the purpose
of coal cleaning both at the face and at the surface. This form of lighting has
been widely adopted underground in the compressed air driven generator type of
lighting unit, and on the surface on very many picking belts. Sodium lighting
has had very little attention paid to it in mine lighting, and it recently came
to the knowledge of the Committee that this method of lighting had been
installed in a mine in Belgium along a locomotive haulage road to increase the
safety of a man haulage scheme. There are very many places in British
collieries where mains lighting is in use other than at the coal face or
picking belts, and it was felt that this afforded an opportunity of improving
the efficiency of underground illumination.
The Sodium Lamp.
The sodium lamp consists of a glass tube bent in the form of a U, the two limbs
being close together. The ends are sealed and each contains an electrode.
Within the tube is a small amount of neon gas, enough to give a pressure of
about 10 mm. of mercury, and some sodium. Between the limbs of the U tube is a
metallic strip connected to one of the lead in wires. When the electrodes are
connected to a suitable form of electrical energy, the neon gas is ionised by
the joint action of the metallic strip outside the tube and the electrodes
within, so that an arc is enabled to strike between the two electrodes. The
heat from this arc vapourises some of the sodium and further ionisation and
vapourisation takes place. The lamp takes about 10 minutes to reach maximum
intensity. A vacuum jacket is placed around the sodium lamp so as to conserve
the heat and to maintain that temperature with less consumption of energy, and
so effect a greater economy of power. This jacket also gives electrical and
mechanical protection to the lamp.
The voltage required to strike this arc is about 380 to 440 when the lamp is
cold, and if that is not available it is necessary to provide it by means of a
transformer. This striking voltage is reduced somewhat (280-300 volts) when the
lamp reaches maximum output.
About 10 per cent. of the total energy consumption is emitted as light. Even
this small percentage is better than that attained by any other illuminant;
thus, whereas a tungsten lamp gives efficiencies of from 9 to 13 lumens per
watt according to size, a sodium vapour lamp gives from 40 to 60 lumens per
watt, including the power consumed in the leak transformer. The other source of
economy is that of the life of the lamps. The average life of a tungsten lamp
is 1,000 hours and they are designed to give an average of just a little more
than that. The average life of a sodium lamp is stated to be 2,500 hours, but
the actual life is considerably in excess of this.
Tests and Results.
A length of underground roadway in a coal mine was placed at the disposal of
the Committee by the Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries, Ltd., for tests to
see whether this form of lighting was likely to give sufficient advantages to
warrant its introduction underground.
This was a straight length of roadway more than 60 yards long, of even grade
and illuminated by six 60-watt tungsten lamps in well glass fittings. The road
was steel arched, bricked to the spring of the arch and lagged above with
corrugated iron sheets.
Several fittings were obtained to suit the new form of lamp. These were as
follows : (1) A trough-shaped sheet steel fitting with a sheet glass visor. (2)
A bulkhead fitting made of cast-iron casing and thick prism glass, to obtain a
wide angle of distribution. (3) A well glass fitting such as is used at present
with the tungsten lamps, lengthened to take the sodium lamp. (4) A well glass
fitting of larger size (to take 150-watt tungsten lamps). (5) An experimental
fitting designed to give better distribution along the road.
It must be borne in mind that the lamp fittings used are all makeshifts. In
spite of this a very decided improvement is obtained in the illumination of the
road with a reduced number of lamps and a much smaller consumption of power.
The economy of power is only a small part of the advantage of this type of
lighting, but it is the one best subject to measurement. Probably the greatest
advantage is the reduction of glare. The glare produced by a lamp depends upon
the brightness of the emitting source. In spite of the "pearling" of
a tungsten lamp, the brightest parts of the bulb emit far more candles per
square centimetre than the naked discharge of the sodium lamp, although the
sodium lamp of equal power is emitting far more light. This is still further
accentuated when the distribution is by means of a prismatic glass fitting
which is particularly suited to the shape of the sodium lamp. The result of
this low brightness is that glare being practically absent, the eyes of those
walking inbye are dark-adapted by the time the end of the illuminated portion
is reached and men can walk straight in without sitting down to wait for dark
adaptation.
There is no satisfactory measure of glare except the physiological effect
produced by it. Miners in particular seem to be more sensitive to glare and
notice the absence of it quicker than those who are not so used to
abnormalities of illumination. The expressions of all those who were asked for
an opinion are in favour of the sodium lighting and those of the men working at
the pit bottom are exceptionally favourable.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Chubb, C. S. | | Investigator | |
| Jones, T. David, Prof. | | | |