8th March 1941, Page: 275, Column: 1
Bearing Lubrication
By R. G. Pomeroy.
[A paper on the "Significance of Safety Factor in Bearing
Lubrication" was read by Mr. R. G. Pomeroy at the December meeting
of the South African Institution of Engineers. The paper is given in the
Journal of the Institution, from which extracts are appended.]
Confusion in the selection of lubricants often arises from the difficulty of
"weighing" the variety of factors which enter into the problem, and
insignificant factors are often permitted to cloud the main issues. This is
evidenced by the continued substitution of heavier oils whenever machine parts
fail or run hot.
The results of tests of the physical and chemical properties, factors of
safety, and limitations of most engineering materials correlate fairly closely
with actual service performance. In the case of oils, however, the results of
laboratory tests often bear little or no relation to the actual performance of
an oil in service, and this still is a deterrent to satisfactory oil
specifications. In practice a great variety of operating conditions and types
of bearings is met, and it is impracticable to simulate all, or even a small
number, on laboratory testing machines, but such machines have served to
confirm many of the mathematical laws of lubrication mentioned in this paper.
At the outset, therefore, it must be appreciated that the choice and
application of high quality lubricants to the diverse needs of modern
machinery, call for specialised knowledge and a keen appreciation of the
mechanical conditions and lubricating requirements involved.
Lubrication is no longer regarded simply as a means of decreasing metallic
friction. It has long been known that the rubbing surfaces of a machine may be
completely separated by a thin film of oil which transmits all the forces on
the bearing and minimises wear of the surfaces. This is fluid film lubrication,
and includes all cases of frictional resistance between solid surfaces
completely separated by a film of fluid of sufficient thickness to conform with
the laws of fluid flow. Other types of friction are :—
(a) Dry or solid friction which occurs between, perfectly clean, dry, solid
surfaces ;
(b) Rolling friction ; and
(c) Boundary or thin film friction.
The last named occurs between solid surfaces separated by a greasy layer or
film of such extreme thinness that the inter-molecular forces between the fluid
and the solid surfaces play a part and determine the character of the
frictional resistance. The minute film no longer exhibits the same properties
of the lubricant as in the case of thick film fluid friction.
Viscosity.
Viscosity is the internal friction of a fluid or the resistance to internal
movement or shear, and is brought about by the effect of the intermolecular
forces within the fluid which cause the molecules to offer resistance to motion
of the one over the other. The obvious way, therefore, of measuring viscosity
is to measure this resistance to shear, and, in scientific work, the expression
"Absolute Viscosity" is applied to observations of this type
expressed in fundamental units of time, force and mass.
Newton's law states that at any point in a fluid the shearing stress is
directly proportional to the rate of shear.
All mineral lubricating oils, in common with most liquids, become thinner on
heating and more viscous on cooling. Brillie explains this phenomenon by the
fact that the cohesion of a liquid results from the fields of force which
constitute the molecules, and that the average distance between the centres of
the fields of force is constant for a given temperature but increases rapidly
with the temperature, resulting in a decrease in viscosity or internal
friction.
Whereas temperature has the effect of thinning lubricating oils, pressure
increases their viscosity. The influence of pressure on the internal friction
of liquids has been known for some time, but engineers have not allowed for it
in lubricating problems because of the comparatively low pressures generally
employed in bearings, and because of lack of precise information about the
behaviour of different types of oil when under pressure.
Specific Gravity and Density.
The specific gravity of a petroleum oil is the ratio Of the weight of a given
volume of oil, at a temperature of 60°F., to the weight of an equal volume
of distilled water at the same temperature, both being corrected for the
buoyancy of air.
The specific gravity of an oil has no real relationship to service conditions,
except possibly with siphon oilers and the separation of the oil from water,
and, apart from its uses in Teflning, it is also of service for weight volume
calculations and conversions from kinematic to absolute viscosity. For such
conversions it is necessary to know the density of an oil at a given
temperature. This value is obtained by multiplying the specific gravity of the
oil at 60°F. by the density of water at 60°F., and this latter figure
is usually taken as 0.999. The density of the oil at other temperatures can
then be calculated from —
D = d — kt,
where D — the required density, d — the density of the oil at
60°F., k = 0.00035 for mineral lubricating oils, t = the
temperature above 60°F.
Hydrodynamic Theory. — The hydrodynamic theory, which explains the
load carrying power of the oil film, assumes that
(a) the bearing is absolutely rigid ;
(b) the journal is in perfect alignment with the bearing ;
(c) the load is steady ;
(d) there is streamline flow in the oil film ;
(e) there is no side or end leakage ;
(f) the viscosity across the oil film is constant; and
(g) the bearing and journal are geometrically perfect.
Surface Irregularities.
All machined or ground surfaces, When examined under a microscope, will be seen
to have a series of projections and depressions.
It might be argued that even if the minute projections on the shaft and bearing
were to come into contact, the "oiliness" of the lubricant should
prevent seizure and the running-in process would remove the major high spots.
This will depend on the finish of the machined surfaces, and, whilst a certain
amount of initial wear might take place during "running-in" without
detrimental results, continued operation under thin film conditions is
undesirable in the case of certain classes of machinery owing to the increase
in the coefficient of friction and consequently the power loss.
Coefficient of Friction.
Dry or solid friction is measured by the force parallel to the surface required
to make a body of a given weight slide over a horizontal surface. The ratio of
the force required to the weight of the body is called the coefficient of
friction. The coefficient of static friction is applied to cases where motion
is imparted to the body from rest, and the kinetic coefficient refers to the
frictional resistance to be overcome to keep the body in motion. The case of
pure solid friction is quite rare and the laws of solid friction are mostly
empirical. Only rough approximations result from the difficulty of obtaining
really "clean" surfaces.
In the case of bearings involving rotary motion the coefficient is defined as
the ratio of the equivalent friction to the total load, the equivalent friction
being the ratio of the friction torque to the radius. It will be seen that, by
using the above definition, a freak case can occur when the load is zero, the
coefficient then being infinity. In accordance with Newton's Law, viscosity may
be defined as the ratio of the shearing stress to the rate of shear.
Or S = ZR,
where S = the shearing stress, Z = the absolute viscosity of the oil, R = the
rate of shear.
If F is the total tangential friction force, D the diameter, and L the length
of the bearing, then
When the oil film is of even thickness, that is in the ideal case, the rate of
shear R is equal to the velocity divided by the thickness of the film,
From first principles, then, it would appear that, in the ideal case which is
only approached in practice, the total friction force
This relation is based on the assumption that the journal runs concentrically
with the bearing, a condition not realised in practice. The above equation also
shows that the friction torque would be independent of the load, but the load
has the effect of varying the film thickness. The assumption of even film
thickness and uniform velocity in the film cannot, therefore, be used and
eccentric running of the journal in the bearing brings about a difference
between the torques on the bearing surface and journal. Side or end leakage
will also influence the coefficient of friction.
Oiliness. — This property is often considered to be the panacea for all
lubricating troubles, but under thick film conditions it plays no part. Its
importance is not denied, however, in cases where the quantity of oil supplied
to a bearing is small, where loads are extremely heavy, or where the mechanical
or operating conditions are such that the formation of a continuous stable
fluid film is prevented.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Pomeroy, R. G. | | | |