22nd February 1941, Page: 263, Column: 1
Salt And Coal Dust
In the introduction to Report of Investigations 3529 on "Tests of Salt as
a Substitute for Rock Dust in the Prevention of Coal Dust Explosions in
Mines," prepared by H. P. Greenwald, H. C. Howarth and
Irving Hartmann and issued by the U.S. Bureau of Mines, it is pointed
out that for some years past the Safety in Mines Research Board of Great
Britain has been making an intensive search for materials that would be more
efficient than rock dust and that could replace it wholly or in part as a means
of preventing the propagation of coal dust explosions in mines. In the course
of this work several rock dusts and numerous inorganic compounds were tested.
The results place incombustible substances in two main groups : (1) Those whose
effect in suppressing the combustion of coal dust is proportional to their
capacity for absorbing heat, and (2) those that show much higher effectiveness
than would be expected from their heat capacity.
One of the compounds investigated by the British Was sodium chloride —
common salt. Laboratory and gallery tests indicated that salt was 5 to 10 times
as effective as a like weight of limestone dust in suppressing the inflammation
of coal dust. Its relative effectiveness was enhanced further when small
proportions of salt were mixed with shale or limestone dusts; possibly this
added effect is due in part to better dispersion of the salt when mixed with
other materials. Obviously, any material so much more effective than rock dust
must command attention, particularly when it is no more expensive than is
common salt. It was decided that the British findings should be checked by
large-scale explosion tests in the Bureau's experimental coal mine. In
addition, moisture-absorption tests were made on mixtures of salt, limestone
and coal dust to determine the extent to which they absorb moisture from
atmospheres of high relative humidity such as exist in many coal mines in the
United States.
The large-scale explosion tests are described in the Report, and an analysis of
the results is given. A noticeable point in the results is that as the salt
content of the dust mixture is increased, the required total incombustible
content decreases, at first rapidly and then more slowly. In a dust mixture
containing 25 per cent. salt the incombustible content of the limiting mixture
was 62 per cent. compared with approximately 75 per cent. for a mixture
containing no salt.
In their summary giving the conclusions arrived at the authors say :—
The large-scale tests show that common rock salt ground to proper fineness and
used dry is several times as effective as limestone dust in preventing the
propagation of flame in coal dust explosions. The results agree with the
British findings qualitatively but not quantitatively; the present tests show a
considerably lower relative effectiveness than did the tests made in Great
Britain. In the American tests of mine-size coal dust, salt was about six times
as effective as limestone when there was 5 per cent. salt in the mixture ; but
this ratio dropped rapidly with successive 5 per cent. increments of salt,
falling to 2 for increments above 15 per cent. total. In so far as commercial
application is concerned, it is as important to consider the effect of each
increment of salt in the mixture as the overall effect of the total present.
The salt used in the tests was quite hygroscopic when ground and had to be
given special treatment to prevent immediate caking in the atmosphere of the
grinding house. Although the fact has not been proved by experiment, general
knowledge of the properties of cheap grades of rock salt makes it appear
probable that this would be equally true of any other brand or grade of salt
that can be sold at a low enough price to compete with satisfactory rock dust
now on the market, even when allowance is made for the greater effectiveness
indicated by the present tests. Evidently it is necessary to have a salt that,
when ground to the requisite fineness, will not absorb moisture or cake in an
atmosphere of 95 per cent. humidity. Until such a product is developed, salt
cannot be recommended as a substitute for rock dusts now in use, no matter how
much more effective it may be or what financial advantages may lie in its use.
Methods of application of salt in coal mines must be settled before it can be
used. It would be necessary to distribute it on roof, ribs, and floor, and it
must be determined whether salt can be handled in rock-dusting machines and
whether it will adhere to ribs and roof as rock dust does. There is no
information as to this. If salt replaces limestone only partly, there arises
the problem of properly mixing the two before application or of making separate
applications of the two materials.
It was observed, also, during the test work that when salt was substituted for
limestone dust, which is much lighter in colour than salt, loss of some of the
improved illumination resulted.
In conclusion, it must be repeated with emphasis that salt cannot be
recommended as a rock-dusting material until the problems connected with its
use are solved.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Greenwald, H. P. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Hartmann, Irving | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Howarth, H. C. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |