8th February 1941, Page: 246, Column: 1
Steel Wire Ropes For Hoisting
Views of South African Engineers
At the November meeting of the South African Institution of Engineers a
contribution to the discussion on the paper by Messrs. J. J. P. Dolan
and W. G. Jackson ("An Investigation into the Permissible Load
Carrying Capacity of Steel Wire Ropes for Hoisting, with special reference to
Deep Level Winding on the Witwatersrand Goldfields"), was read by
Mr. R. S. van der Spuy.* This contribution had been prepared following
discussions by the members of the Association of Mine Resident Engineers, and
outlined points on which there was general agreement. Those taking part in the
discussion following its presentation expressed their appreciation of the fact
that they had before them the collective opinion of a body of engineers
intimately associated with the foremost gold mining industry of the world on a
subject the practical aspects of which they are particularly familiar with.
Extracts from the notes read by Mr. van der Spuy are appended.
Whilst it is generally felt that the section of the rope that gets most
punishment is that next to the capel or splice end — a condition largely
compensated for by ordinary periodic recapping — the development of
deterioration necessitating the discarding and the replacement of the winding
rope occurs most often at points distant from the capel end and may arise from
one or more of a variety of causes. The weakest part of a rope in any
particular case may be regarded as the part where deterioration causes the
responsible engineer to decide on its replacement.
Rope deterioration or weakness at places distant from the capel or splice end
indicated by broken wires, wear, etc., is fortunately always easily detectable.
Causes of Rope Deterioration.
General. — Rope deterioration can be summed up in two main classes
: (a) Wear and corrosion, which are taken care of by the responsible engineer
and can easily be detected. (b) Fatigue resulting from kinetic stresses. These
are complex and can be minimised by giving full consideration to the design and
operation of the winding plant.
It has been proved by statistics that only a small percentage of ropes are
taken off due to low factor of safety, and it is accepted that in most cases
where a rope has failed or has developed a defect so serious as to necessitate
its replacement, the failure has been largely influenced by the intensity of
kinetic stresses.
Wear.
(a) Excessive wear is an obvious danger signal in a working rope. External wear
is caused by the rope rubbing against the sheave wheel and drum flanges and
against adjacent coils. In incline shafts wear is set up by rollers and guide
wheels in addition to the above. Side wear is more pronounced where the hoist
drums are not grooved. With steam hoists having light drums, the ropes are apt
to sway a lot due to the pulsating action of the hoist, and thus swaying is
accentuated in cases where the cut off gear is not functioning perfectly, when
the valve gear is being controlled by the speed governor. When the rope sways
between sheave and drum the wearing effect on the rope is usually the same as
when the angle of lead between those parts is excessive.
A case is quoted where excessive wear took place about 300 feet from the splice
end, and after investigations it Was found that the drivers decelerated rapidly
when this section was about to enter the sheave wheel, thus actually slipping
the sheave on the rope until the sheave had attained the reduced speed of the
rope.
(b) Internal wear is caused by one wire rubbing against another in the
same or adjacent strands. This condition is aggravated by want of internal
lubrication and the displacement of the hemp or manilla core in the rope. In
this connection a pair of 1¼-inch ropes serving in a compound shaft which
had a vertical portion of 650 feet and an incline 2,500 feet with six bend
rollers, had to be discarded after being in use for about six months owing to
marked decrease in diameter. On opening these ropes it was found that the bend
rollers had generated heat which had burned away the internal lubricant and had
charred and decomposed the core, forcing it between the strands to the outside.
Internal wear had taken place and was quite apparent. These ropes were round
strand 6/15 construction.
Corrosion.
(a) External Corrosion. — The effect of external corrosion on
ropes is easily observed. Ropes in upcast and wet shafts, unless well
lubricated, soon show signs of slight external corrosion, usually in the corner
between strands on flats of crown wires where the wires may be deficient in
lubricant due to winding, etc. Sprays in dry downcast shafts when opened up too
much displace the rope dressing, and this allows moisture to attack the rope.
In one case four platform ropes used in sinking a circular shaft were brought
up for recapping. It was then found that they had been attacked by corrosion.
Each outer wire had a small groove in it running lengthways. On recapping, some
of the wires broke off and it was necessary to cut off a good length in order
to obtain a satisfactory short splice. Samples of the water were taken and
theories were advanced about the attack being caused by electrolytic action.
Within three months the ropes were again tested, and they had to be replaced
owing to a large reduction in strength due to corrosion.
(b) Internal corrosion is present in ropes of compound construction when
the outer wires become slack and the strands in some cases can be squeezed in
easily by hand. Another sign of internal corrosion is decreased diameter where
the outside appearance of the rope is satisfactory. This type of corrosion is
not seen and it is a very bad policy to open up a winding rope by means of
Spanish windlasses or spikes in order to examine ropes internally. After a rope
has been opened up in this manner it does not resume its original position, and
thus permits moisture to get inside and cause further corrosion.
Broken Wires.
When the wires begin to break due to deterioration of the steel it becomes
necessary to discard the rope, more particularly when two or more broken wires
are close to each other if not due to faulty welding of wires. It can be taken
that the remaining unbroken wires must have been subjected to the same stresses
as the broken wires and the rope becomes unsafe.
(a) In underground winding equipment horizontal rope races from the winding
engine to the sheave wheel are sometimes used for economical or mining reasons,
and it will usually be found that excessive rope whip takes place when the skip
leaves or enters the tip, sometimes resulting in broken wires in the rope
between sheave and drum when the conveyance is in the tipping position.
(b) Broken wires are sometimes found on winding plants where the cross over of
the rope on the drum is bad and particularly on the dead rope on the drum, so
much so that it has become nearly universal practice with reef engineers to
change this position periodically by pulling in the rope at very short
intervals, say every 2 to 4 months.
Kinetic Stresses.
(a) Electric and Steam Winding. — A Ward-Leonard winding hoist has
very smooth control and when fitted with retarding cams unduly heavy stresses
cannot be set up in winding rope due to acceleration or retardation.
On an A.C. winder the stresses in rope can be kept down to minimum, dependent
mostly on the operator. When reverse current is used excessively, stresses of
very high order can be set up in the rope, but the results of these are easily
discernible in the rope, especially if winding takes place from one or not more
than two stations.
Steam winders set up an oscillation in the rope due to the cyclic variation of
the reciprocating motion. This oscillation in some cases may be damped by the
period of the moving rope and conveyance, but it may be of a high order when
not damped, thus stresses in rope are inversely proportional to length of the
ropes, i.e., shorter the rope the bigger resulting stresses.
(b) Loading and Tipping Stresses. — In the more frequent cases of
winders where the skip is loaded while hanging on the rope, shock loads are
imparted to the rope, dependent on the time taken to load the skip.
Unfortunately, these times and shock are very difficult to calculate in the
design of the loading chutes, In a deep shaft this shock load is absorbed by a
greater volume of rope and thus the resulting stress on the rope is smaller
than that for same loading in shallow shaft.
In the case of cage and truck loadings, no shock load is imparted to the rope
by the loading, but the load on the rope varies from a minimum (with a certain
if not all the weight of cage carried on keps) to a maximum when the load is
raised. Although this is done at slow speeds, it still constitutes a fatiguing
stress of high order as far as capel or splice end is concerned. If the portion
of the rope immediately above the splice is watched while the cage comes to
rest on the keps, it will be noticed that the rope twists up, and immediately
the loaded cage is lifted the rope untwists again.
Usually chains are used as the connection between cage and the rope, with kep
loading and the twist in the rope is then not excessive, but broken wires have
been found in voids in the metal capping due to shock load when the conveyance
is picked up.
(c) Tipping. — The repeated shocks caused at the start and the end
of each upward journey by a badly designed tipping arrangement may be very
harmful, as in such cases only a very short length of rope near the capel is
then supporting the load.
(d) Shock Loads Generally. — A rope is subjected to shock loads
when the skip is being filled dependent on time taken, and when tipped, if the
tip is badly designed. Shock loads are also introduced in cases of emergency
tripping, obstruction in the shaft, sudden lifting of load, with conveyance
resting on keps, etc. Shock loads may result in permanent set in some of the
wires of the rope dependent on the elasticity of rope, i.e., length, and may
become dangerous. As the danger of shock loads is a function of length, it can
safely be said that the longer the rope the greater the elasticity of the rope,
and thus it can withstand greater shock loads away from capel end.
(e) Emergency Braking. — Braking under emergency conditions can be
controlled by brake governors so that the maximum stresses set up in the rope
are in the neighbourhood of 140 per cent. of normal stresses in the rope,
especially with Ward-Leonard winders. Ward-Leonard winders are specially
mentioned as the value of Regenerative braking is advantageous in that
deceleration is applied to the system during the period from emergency tripping
to the time when the brake blocks make contact with brake paths.
In case of A.C. winders (except where electrical dynamic braking is employed)
and in steam winders there is nothing to take the place of this regenerative
braking, and some cases are known where badly designed controlled braking with
an out of balance load may cause excessive stresses in the rope and possibly
greater stresses than if controlled braking was not used.
It is not good practice to test the governor frequently by tripping while
winding, but it must be remembered that a faulty governor which lags may be
very dangerous, especially when required to act when hoist is out of balance.
Stresses set up due to emergency braking, or even acceleration and
deceleration, are dependent on the elastic properties of the rope, and thus the
longer rope is more elastic and smaller stresses are set up. Moreover, the mass
of rope tends to counteract any change and this damps these wave stresses.
(f) Abnormal Stresses. — When ropes have been subjected to some
abnormal stresses caused by accidental occurrence, the decision to discard must
be made by the responsible engineer ; as no two such happenings are similar, no
hard and fast line of action can be laid down. The knowledge and experience of
the engineer must govern the situation under such circumstances.
(g) Bending Stresses. — With the exception of the parts near the
capel end and the drum end every part of the rope is equally affected by
bending.
(h) General Vibration, Oscillation, etc. — Not least of the causes
of deterioration of the rope are the vibrations which occur in differing
degrees due to shaft irregularities, uneven guides, etc. It is well known that
in cases where all other causes of deterioration (such as those
above-mentioned) have been reduced by design and construction to the practical
minimum, the life of the winding rope, although showing some improvement over
less favoured cases, is still very short as compared with other engineering
structures. It is, therefore, reasonable to conclude that these vibrations,
together with oscillating stresses, prevailing more or less continually
throughout every trip up and down the shaft, are chiefly responsible for the
general deterioration of the winding rope, particularly in those cases where
improvement in design has minimised all other causes.
Fatigue.
It is well known that steel, although tough and ductile and able to withstand
severe test loads, will eventually break in a brittle manner under repeated
applications of smaller loads.
In the winding rope fatigue develops as the result of the kinetic stresses
above-mentioned, of which ordinary shaft work between loading and unloading
mentioned under (b) is the most important.
The degree of fatigue will vary according to the number of times the stresses
are imposed and to the tension in the rope. It would therefore appear that, by
some method of combining numbers of repetitions of vibrations, etc., with the
tension, some criterion of relative fatigue should be available.
Shaft Work. — Foot-tons as ordinarily calculated provide a
suitable method for comparison of the work done by similar ropes in the same
shaft with the same loading, but it will be wrong to compare the life of a rope
on a shallow shaft with that of a rope in a deep shaft by means of any of the
methods for calculating foot-tons so far in use. Incidentally, existing methods
based on the simple product of distance and load take a variety of forms and
consequently lack uniformity.
Effective Life.
Ropes are frequently discarded due to their length of life and the amount of
work done, when it is considered that for economic reasons they have given
satisfactory service. The vital factor in cases like this is the amount of work
done. Also where sand and dump haulages use 1 inch to 1¼-inch diameter
ropes, winding ropes of these sizes can be discarded before their hoisting
lives are completed, so that they can give reasonable life when put to work on
the waste dumps.
Factor of Safety.
It is generally felt that with greater depth and consequent added resilience, a
lower factor of safety than the present regulation factor could be allowed with
the same degree of safety.
While agreeing with of minimum discard capacity factor of 8.5 for rock, it is
felt that a factor of safety of less than 4.5 should never be used, as it is
generally accepted that the yield point of a rope is approximately 50 per cent.
of the breaking strain in ropes. Also it is possible under abnormal conditions
to introduce a load double that of the static loading. This being the case, a
factor of safety of 4 or under would mean that loading under abnormal
conditions will be greater than the yield point resulting in permanent set and
the rope would become dangerous.
Having now agreed on a discard factor, a decision has to be made as to the
margin to be allowed above the discard figure to provide for reasonable
depreciation.
In practice, due to high standard of ropes and winding equipment, it has been
found that over 70 per cent. of the ropes used cither show an increase or less
than 5 per cent. decrease in rope strength, and on mines where mostly
electrical winders are employed, almost all the ropes show an increase or less
than 5 per cent. decrease, and it is felt that a percentage reduction in rope
strength of 10 per cent. will cover most cases.
Summary and Conclusions.
(1) As the engineer is mostly concerned with safety, the test result of the
test piece of the rope can be taken for practical-purposes as a good indication
of the breaking strain of the whole rope, as in almost all cases where a retest
has been done the breaking strain has increased.
(2) A capacity factor at discard of 8.5 for rock, together with a discard
factor of safety of 4.5 for rock, which would mean a discard capacity factor of
10 for men, together with discard factor of safety for men to conform with Reg.
34 (8) could be used with the same degree of safety to human life in vertical
shafts as the present regulation factor of 6.
(3) As almost all ropes are discarded for other reasons than a low factor of
safety, a depreciation factor of 10 per cent. would cover all cases.
(4) Periodical recapping at short intervals is sound practice, and although
they are wasteful they are an added precaution, especially with reduced factor
of safety.
(5) Winding conditions such as in the case of sinking or resting the skip or
cage on the bottom of the shaft subject the splice end of the rope to severe
stresses, and reduce the breaking strain of the rope at this point
considerably.
(6) High tensile steel quality-ropes become brittle much sooner than low
tensile steel, but may give increased life if the limiting factor is wear.
(7) From comparison of load extension diagrams it appears that ropes made of
selected high tensile steel quality do not behave as well as ropes of variable
steel quality (although high), in both cases breaking strain being the same.
* Journal of the South African Institution of Engineers.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dolan, J. J. P. | | | |
| Jackson, W. G. | | | |
| Spuy, R. S. van der | | | |