|
25th January 1941, Page: 234, Column: 1 Typical Accidents In Metal MinesState Inspectors' ReportsFrom Miners' Circular 41 by E. H. Denny, issued by the U.S. Bureau of Mines. See also last issue of this journal, page 213. The following descriptions of fatal accidents from falls of rock have been abstracted mainly from reports of State metal-mine inspectors as typical of such accidents. 1. A mucker, age 48, was killed by a fall of rock. He had been visited by the foreman 15 minutes before the accident. He was passing under an open-stope on the 150-foot level when rock fell from above the 100-foot level and hit him on the head. The State reports that safety devices were lacking at the mine, rules covering safety standards were not complied with, and the mine officials displayed a careless attitude towards safety in general. The company carried insurance. It seems obvious that a manway under an open-stope presents the possibility of death or injury from falling rock irrespective of apparent freedom of the stope from loose rock. Often it is impossible to examine an open abandoned stope for loose rock. Lagging over the top of the travelway or a bulkhead at some point in the stope, if the stope is not vertical, will afford at least some chance of protection and escape. 2. A mucker and trammer, age 21, was killed by a fall of rock from the back. He was mucking for a cut-out from a stope when a rock fell from the back, striking him on the head ; he died the following day. According to an eyewitness of the accident, the mine superintendent told him to get out and stay out from under this bad ground, which he failed to do. The accident was classified as due to failure to obey instructions. Disobedience and carelessness undoubtedly were major causes of this fatality. This belongs to a class of accidents in which men are killed through failure to set timber or take down bad ground according to instructions, and into which the adequacy of supervision and discipline also enters. A miner is supposed to keep his working place in a safe condition, and if a superintendent or shift boss finds a place unsafe it may be direct evidence of the miner's carelessness or inexperience. The miner can be sent off the job and the dangerous place fenced until it can be made safe ; the supervising official can stay in the place until the miner makes it safe, and then take whatever measures are necessary to assure that the miner does not endanger his life again ; or, the employee may be issued instructions to make the place safe immediately, and the supervisor move on without seeing that his instructions are followed. The latter constitutes the history of many fatalities — the employee fails to carry out instructions, and the supervising official does not stay to see that they are carried out. As long as this is the procedure, fatalities may be expected, and unquestionably the supervisor has the responsibility of remaining until dangerous conditions are corrected or at least until he has definite knowledge that the corrective work is well under way and in competent hands. 3. A lease foreman was killed by a fall of rock. He and his associates were operating on a leased block of ground and had been benching down at the end of an old stope that extended through to the level above. They had made a shipment and cleaned out the chute on the 1,300-foot level. The man who was killed was standing in the open chute making repairs when a wedge-shaped rock weighing about 75 pounds fell approximately 25 feet from the wall of the stope above and struck him on the head. The walls of the stope were solid and hard. The piece that fell must have been loosened by pounding of the rocks from the benching below. The accident was classed as "unavoidable." This is another instance of working under an open-stope without overhead protection, and as long as such procedure continues to be used in mines and apparently considered acceptable, serious or fatal injuries are likely to occur. 4. A miner was removing mining tools from a stope 15 feet below the surface when rock caved from the hanging wall and killed him. The mine foreman was with him at the time. The report classifies the accident as unavoidable and due to invisible slips in the rock that could not be detected. Accidents from invisible slips occasionally may be unavoidable, but frequent falls of ground from invisible slips indicate a need for closer timbering or changes in mining methods. If, as was stated, the stope was only 15 feet below the surface, the possibility that the surface ground might be broken and loose should have been considered. 5. While a miner was barring down loose rock from the side and back in a stope off a side drift, some of the material fell from the back on another miner (age 23) below, causing injuries from which he died. Two other miners in the stope were eyewitnesses of the accident. The ground and walls in this stope in general were good and solid, and evidently the miner barring down did not take precautions to have his partner in the clear from a piece of loose ground that was larger than he anticipated; the man killed apparently was careless also ; and the question could be raised as to whether these miners had been instructed to bar down only when everyone was in the clear and, if so, whether proper supervision and discipline had been exerted to compel obedience. 6. A miner, age 34, had completed drilling a round of holes in the breast of a drift 3,000 feet in from the tunnel portal. He was removing the air hose and blowpipe at a point 25 feet back from the breast when rock fell on him from the back, killing him instantly. The machine helper was an eyewitness of the accident. The walls in the back of the drift and at the point where the rock fell seemed solid both ways and gave no indication of having been loose. The report classified the accident as unavoidable. Evidently the walls in back of the drift were not solid, and information is not available as to whether the back was tested before or after drilling, except perhaps by visual examination. This accident indicates that machine drilling may loosen rock that appears to be reasonably sound ; this should be borne in mind in drilling work, and back should be tested for possible changes in solidity. The vibrations due to the heavy blows in drilling must have a definite influence on loosening at least some kinds of rock in the vicinity of the hole, and drillers and others working in the vicinity should remember this fact and observe available precautions to protect themselves from falling of rock loosened by these vibrating blows of the drill steel against the rock strata. 7. A miner was mucking into an ore or waste pass at the top of a fissure vein stope. He was standing close to the raise, shovelling directly into it, when a large slab of rock fell from the hanging wall high above his head and knocked him into the raise ; probably half a car of caved rock followed him down to the chute 100 feet below. His skull was fractured, and death was almost instantaneous. The stope where he was mucking was wide and high, and the timbering was inadequate to support the hanging wall, which was very scaly. The foreman and a machineman witnessed the accident. The man who was killed had had little mining experience. The report states that factors in the accident include inadequate timbering of the stope at working places, inexperience of the miner, failure to scale down ground, and lack of company safety rules for procedure in such places. The fact that the victim fell down the raise 100 feet also might indicate the need of grizzlies or at least a guard rail to prevent such falls. All openings into which men shovel or dump material in mines should be protected by substantial grizzlies with openings spread so that a man cannot fall into the region into which the ore or rock goes. If it is impracticable to use grizzlies the Worker should be protected by guard rails, safety rope, or some similar means of preventing falls. 8. A miner, age 44, with many years of mining experience, was killed when a rock fell on his head. Three men, including the victim, proceeded to a raise to work. As it was necessary to draw several cars of muck before drilling and barring down, the miner who was killed sat down in the raise while the other two men trammed muck. Evidently the rock fell on him while he was resting. This man was experienced and had the reputation of being a careful miner, but evidently in this instance he was not careful in testing the back before selecting his resting place. The experienced miner is far more likely to be hurt as described above than is the person who has had relatively little experience ; with the experienced miner, especially one who has not previously been injured, "familiarity breeds contempt," and he usually has ill-concealed scorn for the person who takes definite precautions to test overhead strata before sitting down to rest. Nevertheless, all persons should take such precautions, and if this were done scores of accidents would be avoided every year. 9. A mine timberman, age 41, received a skull fracture and died from a fall of rock. The mine foreman had been in the place before the accident happened. The timberman, who had been on shift only a short time, had stood one set of timber complete, had the posts for another set standing, and was getting ready to put the cap in place when the rock fell from the back. The report states that evidently he did not bar down when he went on shift, thereby violating a rule of the company. The falling rock broke his hard hat and drove a piece of the hat into his skull; however, death would have ensued anyway if his head had been unprotected. In this instance the accident occurred to a person supposedly well qualified to protect not only himself but also others from falling of overhead material. Unquestionably he was careless, and paid for his lapse with his life. This indicates how important it is that experienced men comply with safe procedure in mines, because many of them are prone to believe that their long experience will keep them safe from injury. 10. A machine runner was killed and his helper badly injured by a fall of 50 tons of ore from the back of a cut-and-flll stope. The two men and the stope boss entered the stope some hours after blasting and found that a heavy wedge-shaped block of ground had settled away from two slips and was resting entirely on two sets of timber. The stope boss pointed out that the piece was dangerous and would have to be blasted down. He told the two men to stay away from it and went for explosives for blasting. Just as he left the level he heard a shout and a crash and went back to and the two men buried. Apparently they had proceeded under the loose ground to cover a mill hole before blasting. The fall of ground was so heavy that it knocked down one set of timber and cut another in two. This case is typical in some ways of many accidents that occur in mines ; the men knew the place was hazardous, yet went under the rock in disobedience of instructions ; the boss knew the place was unsafe, and while he warned the men he did not really protect them, as he could have done had he remained near the dangerous place and sent one or both of the men to got the explosives. 11. A trammer, age 24, was killed by a fall of ground in a stope. The stope had been mined to a height of about 16 feet above the drift floor for a length of 48 feet. It was about 5½ feet wide and inclined at about 70°. The mining had been done some weeks before the accident, and several days before the trammer and another miner began to tram the broken ore to the shaft. The pile of ore was about 13 feet high. The day before the accident the mine foreman visited the stope and found that more than half of the pile had been removed and that the receding pile had exposed the end of a large slab of loose ground on the hanging wall. This slab extended from about 6 feet above the drift floor to the back of the stope. He instructed the two men to scale down this slab ; nevertheless, a driller who visited the stope the same afternoon noticed that the men were still working underneath the loose slab. He advised them how it should be scaled down. That evening the mine foreman again visited the stope, although no one was working there. He noticed that two gads had been driven into the slab without dislodging it, and he presumed that the two men would again continue their efforts to get the slab down when they returned the following morning. Evidently, on the following morning they began moving ore without paying further attention to the slab, presuming that as the gads had not dislodged the slab the previous day it was reasonably safe. The slab fell about an hour after they began work ; one man was killed and the other injured. The mine foreman should have followed this matter more attentively and taken measures to bring down the slab by blasting if necessary. This type of accident is by no means unusual, and underground workers are far too prone to assume that after a more or less determined effort has failed to bring down some material suspected of being hazardous, it can then and thereafter be considered safe. Often the apparently unsuccessful effort to dislodge material of this kind has actually loosened the material to such an extent that relatively little extra effort would bring it down. Overhead material that has been Worked on in an attempt to dislodge it should be timbered or otherwise supported until it can be brought down by scaling or otherwise. 12. A machine runner's skull Was crushed by rock that fell from a point 40 feet above him in an open-stope. This man had been drilling and loading short holes in large broken slabs and was kneeling to spit the fuses when a round of holes was blasted in a place in another mine 100 feet away. The jar caused the rock to fall. According to the State report, no other rock had fallen during a year's work in the vicinity of this old open-stope. The mine in which the accident occurred was one of a number of small lease operations common to the district. The lease foreman was careful to examine the walls every day before men went to work. The State mine inspector states that low-grade ore is mined under large open-stopes elsewhere in the district, that the condition of the old stopes and the grade of the ore produced make it impracticable to furnish the protection of close timbering, and that it is a matter of good luck that there are not more such accidents. It is also very poor practice to blast in such mines when workers are in the mine, as blasting in one place is very likely to cause material in another place, made loose by years of exposure and other influences, to fall as a result of the concussions. Under a leasing system, men who lease a block of ground near old workings to pick up ore stringers missed in the original mining often risk their lives under extremely hazardous natural conditions. Usually their financial resources do not allow the employment of the safer mining methods ; sometimes they use little or no timber in or near broken ground ; they have poor or inadequate equipment or tools to carry on their mining ; and the mining company exercises little or no safety supervision. A similar situation often exists in the reopening of old mines where caved and broken ground, rotted timbers, and old unmapped stopes, raises, and winzes are found. These accident reports disclose such practices as failure to test or to test adequately overhanging ground, faulty supervision, carelessness of experienced miners or mine officials or both, carelessness due to inexperience, failure to use proper mining methods, failure of mine officials to furnish timber and of miners to set it when furnished, negligence in following and enforcing safety rules, and lack of safety rules. In short, most of the fatalities from falls of rock appear needless and due to man failure ; however, this type of accident is the one most prolific of deaths and injuries in mines and by far the most difficult to prevent.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||