25th January 1941, Page: 231, Column: 1
Roof Caving
A paper prepared by Mr. J. R. Jenkins, B.Sc, for the South Staffordshire
and Warwickshire Institute of Mining and published in the Transactions of the
Institute of Engineers, on "Some Notes on the Science of Roof Caving and
its Practice on Longwall Machine Faces," had for its purpose to suggest
that where geological and other conditions are suitable a system of strip
packing and caving of intervening wastes, or of complete caving without strip
packs, does more to bring about requirements than any other known system of
longwall roof control. Briefly, this system requires the building of
substantial strip packs, spaced wide enough apart to induce the immediate roof
to collapse or cave in the wastes, behind a row of rigid supports set as near
the face as possible. These supports form a "breaker row," and should
be placed immediately behind the conveyor. If caving is effected between waste
packs, the system is called "semi-caving" ; the term "complete
caving" is applied when conditions allow it to be done along the whole
length of face from road-side pack to road-side pack. A breaker row can be
composed of stout wooden props, releasable steel props, or rigid chocks.
Roof control depends mainly on substantial systematic and uniform support of
the "controllable area" (the area of subsiding roof in the wastes
behind the face conveyors). The more efficient the packing or the greater the
support offered by the fallen material in the wastes, the less will be the
movement and the greater will be the control of the main body of roof. The
downward movement of the superincumbent mass of strata must be considered
irresistible; and it is only capable of being controlled by the solid coal, the
packs and the debris fallen in the wastes. The function of the temporary face
supports, therefore, is to control a comparatively small thickness of nether
roof and to reinforce its self-supporting capacity. In short, the method of
roof caving employs forces induced by ruining in the roof strata to pack the
wastes, giving results which far exceed those of the most expert packer.
Experience has shown that the best results from caving from the safety and
economic standpoints are obtained when the length of sub-cantilever is limited
to a specified maximum span. Although no hard-and-fast rule can be applied,
this is usually 12 to 13 feet with massive rock roofs and 14 to 15 feet with
more yielding materials, such as shales and coals. With caving, as with other
systems of roof control, however rigid is made the breaker row, a limited
minimum degree of controlled subsidence will always take place.
Chocking Systems.
In the light of some points passed in review Mr. Jenkins concludes that
under suitable conditions the most rigid temporary face support can be gained
by the use of steel props and bars with hardwood lids in conjunction with
systematically spaced hardwood chocks. Sufficiently thick lids must be provided
to enable the props to permit the same height reduction as the chocks, thereby
subjecting the roof to a uniform support. The chocks must be set directly
between roof and floor and driven up tightly by double-wedging with long
hardwood wedges, in order to relieve the steel props of excessive weight and
facilitate their withdrawal.
Chock pieces should be of the largest cross-sectional dimensions consistent
with ease of handling. Chocking systems should be so devised that the chocks
fit in between the props and bars of the existing propping system, and they
must be spaced sufficiently close together to prevent crushing of the hardwood
pieces. A chock built of 5-inch section oak will theoretically support 200 tons
before failure, whereas one built of 6-inch oak will carry 288 tons. In general
practice, therefore, 6-inch square oak pieces are used 1½ to 4 feet in
length, a chock spacing of 4½ to 9-foot centres serving the majority of
conditions. If there is a dirt band in the seam, chocks are generally set a
little wider apart to allow adequate spaces between them for the dirt to be
gobbed. A mechanical chock-release device should always be incorporated in such
chocks to facilitate rapid and safe withdrawal. Recent developments in the
practice of the caving system have followed from the effective employment of
such devices.
As broken material occupies more space than solid material, caving of the
wastes results in their becoming completely filled with fallen debris. Upon
this caved material the higher beds above the nether roof subside. Shale roofs
in deep mines will break up along planes of induced cleavage into
suitably-sized fragments.
General Conclusions.
In his general statement of conclusions arrived at Mr. Jenkins says
:—
With a longwall machine face advancing uniformly on a time cycle basis there is
a sort of pressure arch in the immediate roof strata at right angles to the
face. Its front abutment is well in advance over the solid coal, and the
consolidated packs in the settled area behind the face form its back abutment.
The downward movement of the superincumbent strata must be considered
irresistible and capable of control only by the solid coal, the packs, and the
debris fallen in the wastes.
With controlled and systematic roof caving the Immediate roof is broken down in
the wastes by beam action, and as broken material occupies 25 to 50 per cent.
more space than solid stone, wastes become completely filled. This consolidated
fallen debris offers a substantial and uniform support to the higher beds, and
in cases where strip packs are built gives additional support in the
intervening wastes. This system brings about effective roof control, as the
movement of the higher beds over the controllable area is greatly reduced. Only
a small ledge or sub-cantilever of nether roof requires to be carried over the
working area, and such a substantial support is offered to the higher beds that
they are able to span relatively unbroken between the two abutments, this
bridging effect serving to "protect" the sub-cantilever. With roof
caving the function of the temporary face supports is to control a
comparatively small sub-cantilever and to provide a sufficiently rigid fulcrum
against which the. immediate roof can be broken.
Roof caving is the oldest method of roof control. The modern technique of
controlled caving has been evolved through experience to meet the changed
conditions of intensive longwall machine mining. The introduction of such
materials as hardwood and steel allows the rigidity of face supports to be
increased well within their load carrying capacity and the use of mechanical
chock release devices now ensures that the drawing off operation can be
effected as rapidly as any other operation in the 24-hour cycle.
Roof caving can be applied to the majority of seams in this country with a
marked improvement in safety and economy of working. Like any system of roof
control, its application is limited, and certain roofs are so difficult to
control that efficient mechanical solid packing may be the only solution. This
method also applies to special cases, as when mining under waterlogged ground
or under built-up areas at shallow depths. Good conditions at the coal face can
be made by the methods of working and roof control employed, and it would
appear that roof caving is most likely to provide better conditions than any
other system.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jenkins, J. R. | | | |