11th January 1941, Page: 212, Column: 1
Mine Ventilation
Points for States Managers' Discussion
By D. Harrington.
Extracts from U.S. Bureau of Mines Information Circular 7047. Originally
presented before the Western Safety Conference for discussion among American
mining engineers. Mr. Harrington is chief of the health and safety
branch of the Bureau.
Effective ventilation of underground workings requires the establishment and
maintenance of such control of air-currents that the underground workers may
work in safety with maximum comfort and efficiency and without impairment of
health ; and that the mine openings may be made subject to such flow of air as
to remove from the workings at ordinary times harmful gases and dusts ; and
that at times of emergency, such as fire or explosion, there may be circulated
as much or as little air as may be desired, covering portions of the mine or
the mine in its entirety.
Control of air flow is absolutely necessary in any ventilating system, and this
very essential feature is obtainable only by the installation of mechanically
operated fans and other ventilating devices, such as doors, overcasts,
regulators, etc. Every mine, large or small, coal or metal, should be equipped
with a fan from the outset. While much has been written about natural
ventilation and many claims have been made that in specific mines there is
sufficient natural air flow, there are few, if any, mines, coal or metal, where
natural ventilation supplies anything like adequately safe or healthful
conditions for underground workers even at ordinary times ; and at times of
fire or explosion mines that depend on natural ventilation are virtually
helpless and certainly are decidedly dangerous to those unfortunates forced to
be in them.
Coal and Metal Mine Comparison.
Although ventilation and its control have almost always been deemed an integral
part of coal mining, metal mines have rarely paid much, if any, attention to
air circulation until forced to do so by the occurrence of some untoward
condition or accident. Yet metal mines actually have at least as great need of
efficient circulation of air as have coal mines. The coal mine must remove the
dangerous, explosive gas methane as well as fumes from explosives, and in some
places other gases, such as CO2 or hydrogen sulphide or nitrogen.
Metal mines have much greater necessity to remove fumes from explosives because
much larger unit quantities are used ; frequently have occasion to remove
CO2, nitrogen, and other gases from strata; and even the coal
miners' explosive gas, methane, is found occasionally. In addition, circulating
air-currents are urgently needed in many metal mines to reduce the excessively
high humidity and temperature so frequently found in them but rarely in coal
mines. The immense quantities of minutely fine particles of rock dust that
float in the stagnant air of metal mines and that are very largely responsible
for miners' consumption and other diseases so prevalent among metal miners in
many regions could be removed very largely by adequate ventilation. The more or
less generally accepted conclusion that coal miners have a relatively healthful
occupation and that many metal miners contract diseases such as lead poisoning,
miners' consumption, etc., and either die early in life or are incapacitated in
middle age, is due almost wholly to the superior working conditions frequently
found in coal mines, chiefly due to ventilation.
Approximately in order of their importance, the main features that affect air
in metal mines are (1) movement, (2) temperature, (3) relative humidity, (4)
gases, and (5) dusts. In coal mines, the order of importance would probably be
(1) movement, (2) gases, (3) dusts, (4) relative humidity, and (5) temperature.
Importance of Movement of Air.
The matter of movement of air from the surface, through the working faces or
places, and then back, to the surface, is by all means the most important
consideration in effecting adequate ventilation of mines and in protecting the
health and forwarding and maintaining the working efficiency of the underground
workers. If adequate quantities of pure air are directed to the places where
men work, most of the requirements of health and many of the demands of safety
will be well served.
Gases to be found in mine air may come from surface air, from breathing of men
and animals, from lights used, from firing of explosives, from compressed air
used with machines or as blowers, from operation of various kinds of machinery,
and from various coal, rock, or other strata encountered, as well as from mine
fires, active or incipient.
Dust in coal mines occurs through processes somewhat similar to those in metal
mining, in addition to those created by undercutting, overcutting, and
shearing, and much dust is now being created by various kinds of mechanical
loading devices. Coal dust may be very explosive under some conditions, and in
addition it has a health hazard and its presence in large quantities in air
very greatly reduces visibility ; this, in turn, adds greatly to the danger of
working in coal mines.
Some General Conclusions.
Some general conclusions are quoted below :—
In mining, it appears that ventilation, fire protection and prevention, health,
safety, and efficiency are very closely interrelated, and conditions,
installations, and equipment in connection with any one of these considerations
may vitally affect one or all of the others, detrimentally or otherwise.
Ventilation should be under definite, constant supervision, preferably of one
person, who should report to the highest officials. Each mine should be
ventilated wholly within itself; inter-ventilation of mines is likely to be
dangerous, inefficient, and unsatisfactory. Any mine employing more than 200
persons should have one or more persons working exclusively on ventilation if
health, safety, and efficiency are to be protected adequately.
Ventilation is probably the most effective dust-control practice, though it
ranks second to wet methods under some conditions. Where ventilation cap be
applied effectively, dust can be removed from the air or its concentration can
be kept so diluted as to render it almost harmless to workers ; ventilation can
minimise dust hazards of almost all kinds, including spontaneous combustion,
though it may enhance hazards of dust explosibility in some instances. In some
cases ventilation should be induced by exhaust methods, but in others forced or
blowing systems are the more effective, particularly in underground work in
places having high-temperature air due to rock or dripping water or other
condition, such as rapid oxidation of surrounding rock, timber, etc.
Use of Less Explosives Urged.
In general, the larger the quantity of explosive used, the more finely divided
the blasted material, the more heavily the air will be impregnated with dust
and smoke, and the greater will be the quantity of poisonous gases left at the
place ; hence, methods should be used that will tend to reduce the quantity of
explosives used and of gases and dust produced. In this connection it will be
found that the use of stemming or of some types of blasting plugs now available
will more definitely confine the explosive, hence increase its efficiency and
reduce the quantity of explosive used and also reduce the amount of poisonous
gas produced, and possibly reduce the violence of the blast and its tendency to
raise dust and disseminate it into the surrounding air. And it would be well
for users of explosives to investigate types of explosives that are known to
give off minimum quantities of harmful gases on detonation, and to use them;
also, the discontinuance of the use of fuse and the substitution of electric
blasting would aid in reducing the amount of poisonous gases from blasting.
Explosives that have been held in storage too long or that have been stored
under unfavourable conditions as to moisture, temperature, etc., are likely to
give off maximum quantities of harmful gases, if they detonate at all; hence,
utmost care should be taken in the storing of explosives to see that they are
not held too long before being used.
Air Temperatures.
With a dry-bulb air temperature above 75°F., comfort and maximum working
efficiency can be attained only when the air is moving, this being especially
true if the air has high relative humidity. The exact velocity necessary is a
variable, depending largely upon the temperature and humidity. Maturated
atmospheres, up to nearly blood temperature, may be made endurable and even to
a considerable extent comfortable by providing sufficient velocity or movement.
Relative humidity, even up to the saturation point, does not appear to be
harmful to health, comfort, or efficiency until the temperature runs above
75°F. ; and if sufficient movement is supplied, high relative humidity is
not particularly harmful until the temperature is well over 90°F.
When the temperature of the air is above 75°F., mere movement of the air at
working places is more important than anything else in giving adequate
ventilation, provided the air is reasonably free of noxious gases and dusts.
Cost Offset by Savings.
Experimental work in mines reveals that after shafts that previously had
ordinary exposed timbers are smooth-lined, friction generally will be reduced
to such an extent that 50 per cent. or more additional air can be handled by
the same power. Preferably at least the intake air shaft should be fireproof
and, if possible, all shafts or heavily inclined openings that carry air or
through which men travel or are transported should be fireproofed, at least at
and within several hundred feet of the intersection of such mine openings with
the surface.
While the cost of establishing a ventilation system for a large mine is
variable, the cost of operation is not particularly burdensome, and it will
usually be offset by savings in compressed air and in increased efficiency and
health of employees, which frequently will equal the entire cost of the
investment within a few years. If a fire or explosion occurs, an efficiently
installed and operated mechanical ventilation system is of incalculable value,
and the absence of such a safeguard is likely to result in heavy loss of
property and possibly of life.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Harrington, D. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |