11th January 1941, Page: 211, Column: 1
Fault Studies And Ground Movements
A paper by Mr. Harold Hopkins on "Faulting at the Wright-Hargreaves
Mine and Notes on Ground Movements" has been published in the Bulletins of
the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and the Institution of Mining
and Metallurgy for simultaneous discussion. The author informs that the
Wright-Hargreaves Mines, Ltd., comprise part of a group of seven mines long
active in the Kirkland Lake district, in the Province of Ontario. Though each
of these mines works several productive veins, there is one vein common to all
which is known as the North Vein of the camp, not because it is the most
northerly vein mined but because it is the more northerly of the two major
veins of the camp. At the Wright-Hargreaves Mines there are in all ten
important producing veins and most have a N60° — 65°E strike and
in general a steep southerly dip. It is a common belief that most of these
veins lie along faults, but whilst this is true in some cases it is not so in
all, and further, a vein may be along a fault for part of its strike whilst the
rest of the vein may lie along a fracture in line with the fault, this being
due to rotational movements which had taken place during faulting.
Major Movements.
In his summary of faults Mr. Hopkins says the history of faulting at
this property covers seven different ages of major movements, three of which
took place before the formation of the veins. Four of the movements affected
the veins with displacements up to 700 feet in the case of transverse faults
and 860 feet in the case of strike faults. It is a significant fact that
rotation is proved on the vein fault and on all transverse faults with the axes
of rotation of the latter being all to the north, some of them above the
present surface and some at depth. This would indicate that the cause of the
faulting must be searched in areas to the south. Rotation is not so pronounced
on the major strike faults, but on some of the minor strike faults it is shown
by the divergence in vein strikes above and below the faults — divergence
up to 20° being known. Faults of different ages differ in appearance, some
having gouge along their planes with no secondary deposition of minerals,
whilst others are characterised by the presence of quartz, calcite, etc.,
giving them the appearance of barren veins. The strike faults in particular
come in the latter category. In the discussion on the solution of the movements
on the transverse faults it is shown that, because of the rotational movement
on these faults, the horizontal offsets of veins are no guide as to the true
displacements on the faults and that no offset appears if the dip of the vein
coincides with the arc of rotation of the fault.
Significance of Doming.
The following notes are extracted from Mr. Hopkins's discussion of
ground movements :—
"A study of the effects of the faults on mining was made on account of the
occurrence of rock bursts in mines to the west of us, and the knowledge that
faults are regarded with disfavour in other mining districts. B. T. Altson,
speaking of practice at the City Deep, states that 'driving or
crosscutting along dike or fault contacts, or parallel to a fault plane, is
avoided wherever possible.' Many of our crosscuts do, however, closely parallel
faults and so far we have experienced no trouble on that account. It is
noticed, however, on the lower levels in regions where several parallel minor
faults occur, that the porphyry breaks along much closer jointing than
normally, and this may result in more sloughing than would otherwise be the
case . . . The fault intersections in drifts and crosscuts Were examined in
order to determine whether tectonic movements might still be in action, but of
the few hundred intersections examined only a few showed signs of movement and
these were definitely connected to stoping operations . . .
"Much of the literature on ground failures and rock bursts refers to the
theory of doming, as first expounded by Fayol, and an area of the mine
where crosscuts were present in the hanging wall and footwalls of stoped areas
was made the locus of a special study . . . In all cases where movements on the
cracks are observed the south side block is indicated as moving downward and to
the west. The most prominent cracks are those lying between the two vein
systems, and the movements on them rather indicate that they, mostly followed
the mining of the South Vein stopes, which in the majority of cases were of a
later date than the workings on the incline structures. Here is indicated drag
or slide of the stope walls, and to the writer this section appears to be
possibly the most important factor in the crushing and destruction of
horizontal sill pillars. The westerly movement of the loosened blocks is
apparently due to the riding of these down parallel with the Sylvanite fault.
Whilst no rock bursts have occurred in this area it is conceivable that at
horizons of higher pressures these loosened blocks Would be liable to buckling
with the production of a real burst, and the observations here noted provide an
object lesson on what might be expected to occur at lower horizons were similar
excavations not provided with maximum support by concurrent filling.
"That greater pressures are naturally present on deeper horizons is
evidenced in development drifts where arching is noted within a comparatively
short time after drifting . . .
"In looking for causes of rock bursts it seems to the writer that the main
considerations are the taking care of the pressure components of the weight of
the overlying rocks in an endeavour to prevent doming. Some initial expansion
of the immediate walls of a stope at depth, due to decompression, can be
expected and cannot be prevented. This initial movement will show the early
squeezing of head or cushion blocks of stope timbers. The important thing is to
stop or at least control the growth of these movements, wherein lies the
question of supports. Whilst it is true that on the upper horizons of a mine
with medium stoping widths timber stulls will generally support the hanging
walls during the period of mining that region, these stulls will fail after a
period of a few years, and if during that time the orebody has been developed
to much greater extent in depth it is found necessary to strengthen the
supports of the upper region by perhaps complete filling. This new support,
however, does not give all the advantages that would have accrued from initial
filling ; doming has been in operation before this secondary fill is emplaced
and the process will continue until the fill has been compressed. Here may lie
the origin of the legacy of trouble which deep mines have to contend with, and
the wisdom of obtaining information on the size of orebodies far ahead of
actual sloping is apparent.
"Chemical activity has been advocated as a cause of rock bursts, but the
burden of proof rests with the advocates of such activity. Elastic hysteresis
has been blamed ; but P. W. Bridgman, speaking of the normal behaviour
of compressibility, states that 'there are no hysteresis elastic after-effects,
or allied phenomena, but the strain is a simple valued function of the
pressure.' Likewise, L. H. Adams and R. E. Gibson, describing
their experiments on the elastic properties of certain basic rocks and of their
constituent minerals, state, 'we have not been able to observe any hysteresis
in the volume change of igneous rocks when subjected to hydrostatic pressure.'
"In summarising these notes on ground movements it may be said that so
far, in developing to a depth of 6,110 feet and stoping to a depth of 4,000
feet, faults have not caused rock bursts. Rather is it believed that faulting
has relieved any pre-existing regional stresses. Other apparent advantages
which the faults give us are the largo offsets in the case of the transverse
faults, which break the continuity across the property of stope excavations
several times, and the gaps of the strike faults which are natural horizontal
pillars large enough to be effective. These two fault systems in effect divide
the mine into separate mining sections. Evidence of doming has been shown
coupled with the downward drag of stope walls, the force of which is thought
responsible for crush bursts. Buckling of the loosened stope walls inside the
domes is believed to be responsible for additional bursts. If doming in the
walls of mine excavations can be responsible for so much trouble, then the
necessity of preventing the formation and growth of doming, by filling
concurrently with mining, is obvious ; and the greater the ore shoot to be
mined the greater is the necessity for immediate and maximum support."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Adams, L. H. | | | |
| Altson, B. T. | | | |
| Bridgman, P. W. | | | |
| Fayol, — | | | |
| Gibson, R. E. | | | |
| Hopkins, Harold | | | |