11th January 1941, Page: 209, Column: 1
Sheathed Explosives In Belgium
Readers of this journal will recall that the Fifth International Conference of
Directors of Mine Safety, scheduled to be held at the Central Experiment
Station of the U.S. Bureau of Mines in September, 1939, Was postponed because
of conditions in Europe. With the permission of the authors the Bureau has
published some of the papers, including "A Twenty Years' Survey of the Use
of Sheathed Explosives in Belgium," which had been prepared by M. Ad. Breyre,
Chief Inspector of Mines and Director of the Institut des Mines,
Pasturages, Belgium. Some of M. Breyre's observations, from Report of
Investigations 3530, are presented herewith:—
For more than 20 years, Belgium, leading all the coal-mining countries, has
made increasing use of sheathed explosives, which were first suggested by the
late E. Lemaire, predecessor of the author as Director of the Institut
National des Mines.
The sheath consists of an annular envelope of suitable material, 3 millimetres
thick, laterally surrounding each cartridge of explosive. At least 65 grams of
sheathing material is used per 100 grams of explosive ingredients. The usual
weight is 80 grams per 100 grams of explosive. The sheathing material covers
only the sides of the explosive cartridge, the ends being left uncovered to
ensure propagation of detonation throughout the whole file of cartridges
forming the explosive charge. The envelope that immediately surrounds the
explosive ingredients is carefully waxed to keep out moisture. The outside
envelope is unwaxed.
Types of Sheath.
Three types of sheath are now used in Belgium, namely: (1) the powdery sheath,
(2) semi-rigid sheathing, and (3) the tubular sheath.
(1) The powdery sheath is the one most commonly used and consists of 25 per
cent. binding material (plaster, clay, or china clay) and 75 per cent.
flame-extinguishing material, either fluorides (sodium or calcium) or a mixture
of chlorides (sodium or potassium) and fluoride containing at least 35 per
cent. fluoride. All sheathing material is finely ground. The explosive
cartridge is waxed by dipping it into a bath of molten wax, which fills the
slightest spaces between the paper folds with wax and thus ensures good
preservation of the explosive. Waxing of the explosive cartridge is common to
all sheathed explosives used in Belgium. The cartridge is filled with sheathing
material. Sometimes the cartridge is glued to the bottom of the envelope to
prevent sheathing material from getting between the ends.
The completed sheathed cartridge with closed envelope has a contrivance to
reduce thickness of paper over the ends. To avoid several folds of paper, a
thin paper disc is glued on the ends or the sides bent inward over the end. The
sheathing material is packed in the cartridge either by hand or by simple
mechanical devices. The cartridge must always be centred carefully during the
filling operation.
(2) The semi-rigid sheathing is characterised by the use of plaster in the
sheathing material as a binding agent. Once the cartridge is sheathed, the
whole is soaked in a water bath ; the plaster hardens and binds the sheathing
material, which loses its pulverulent form without losing its essential
property of being pulverised by the explosion. The soaked cartridge is dried
afterwards to drive off the excess of water. This procedure requires the use of
an outside envelope of several thicknesses of strong blotting paper, which
results in a rather considerable thickness of folded paper over the ends of the
cartridge. This does no harm when the explosive contains nitroglycerine, but
would not be advisable with an explosive containing ammonium nitrate without
nitro-glycerine. The following composition has been approved for this sheath :
Orthose feldspar, 55 per cent. ; Potassium sulphate, 35 per cent. ; Plastic, 10
per cent.
(3) The tubular sheath consists of a tube 3 millimetres thick, which fits
tightly on the explosive cartridge. The sheathing material, of the same
composition as that given under (1), is bound together with plastic clay and
has a semi-rigidity that permits slipping the sheath over the cartridge by the
use of a small mechanical device. The annular cylinder of sheathing material is
encased in strong paper folded over on the inside for 12 millimetres to give
the necessary rigidity to the whole system. The sheathed cartridges are loaded
into the borehole without extra thicknesses of paper between the ends of the
cartridges.
The three aforementioned types of sheath are approximately equivalent, as far
as safety is concerned. A total of 10 million sheathed cartridges of the three
types will be manufactured in Belgium during 1939. This applies to the common
cartridge of 30-millimetre diameter for the explosive and 36 to 37 millimetres
for the sheathed explosive.
Since a certain date, a few cartridges of smaller diameter (26 millimetres for
the explosive and 32 millimetres for the sheath) have been asked for,
especially for blasting in not too hard rocks, where advances of 2 to 2.5
metres can be made. The advantage of smaller-diameter cartridges is to allow
distribution of the explosive charge over a greater length, which is favourable
to a more regular breaking up of the stratum. A 100-gram cartridge of
30-millimetre diameter has a length of 13 to 14 centimetres, while a
26-millimetre-diameter cartridge has a length of 17 to 18 centimetres.
As it is recognised that detonation of explosives, especially of ammonium
nitrate explosives, gives less satisfactory results with smaller diameter over
increased length of charge, permission to cartridge sheathed explosives in 26
to 32-millimetre size has been granted for certain explosives only after
special gap tests had been made to determine their sensitiveness to detonation.
It is thought that this will remain an exceptional case.
Safety of Sheathed Explosives.
As far as safety is concerned, sheathed explosives certainly can be considered
the best explosives existing, from the point of view of protection against
firedamp and coal dust. The object aimed at with the sheath was to extinguish,
by means of a dense suspension of non-inflammable material, all detonation
flames, so to speak, at their incipience within the breaks formed in rocks
during blasting.
Those flame-extinguishing materials capable of removing the maximum amount of
heat from the gases at high temperature through volatilisation, decomposition,
and production of flame-extinguishing gases seem to be destined to play the
chief role. In Belgium, flame-extinguishing materials of maximum efficiency but
at the same time cheap have been sought.
The safety afforded by sheathed explosives is such that the usual mortar test
in a gaseous atmosphere cannot be applied any longer, as the test mortar would
be filled with explosive without reaching the charge that causes ignition.
Testing Procedure.
To obtain an idea of the efficiency of a particular sheath, two testing
procedures are used : (a) Firing of a suspended charge in an inflammable
mixture ; (b) Mortar testing with a dangerous explosive.
(a) The explosives testing gallery (1.65 metres diameter) contains an explosion
chamber 5 metres long that can be partitioned off by means of a paper
diaphragm. An 800-gram charge of sheathed explosive is suspended in this
chamber. The eight cartridges in the charge are placed end to end in a file and
tied to a horizontal metal rod suspended in the direction of the gallery axis.
An electric detonator is inserted in one of the end cartridges. A 30-millimetre
length of sheathing material extends beyond each end of the charge.
The explosive chamber is filled with a gaseous mixture containing 8 to 10 per
cent. methane, obtained from the natural firedamp of the testing station. This
firedamp actually contains 20 to 25 per cent. nitrogen and 80 to 75 per cent.
methane. All explosives testing is carried out with this mixture, to which the
necessary quantity of oxygen is added to form atmospheric air with the
nitrogen. This natural firedamp for testing sheaths is used, as it is a less
virulent standard and thus enables us to obtain a better appreciation of the
sheathing properties.
A satisfactory sheath prevents an ignition with an 800-gram charge of sheathed
S.G.P. explosive, while 200 grams of the same explosive without its sheathing
does ignite the firedamp mixture.
(b) They try to determine how much the addition of sheathing material increases
the charge limit of a dangerous explosive, such as dynamite, when fired from a
mortar inside the testing gallery. The shot is fired into a gaseous mixture
containing 9 per cent. methane. A small portion of a cartridge of No. 1
dynamite (a standard explosive containing 75 per cent. nitroglycerine and 25
per cent. kicselguhr) causes ignition of the gaseous mixture, while a
satisfactory sheathing permits firing 350 to 400 grams of the same explosive
without ignition.
Practical Tests.
Very extensive tests were made under the direction of M. Lefebvre,
Inspector of Mines, in actual mine galleries. The results are summarised as
follows :—
The use of a sheath decreases the useful effect developed by the explosive by
about 1 to 2 per cent. and increases the time necessary for drilling the larger
borehole about 1 to 3 per cent. The increase in cost is less than 1 per cent.
of the total cost for excavating 1 metre length of gallery.
Sheathed explosives produce much less fumes, and when used for blasting coal
give a better grade of coal because of the cushioning effect of the sheath.
These tests created an erroneous opinion in the minds of certain industrial men
to the effect that there was a considerable decrease in explosive strength, but
this has been dissipated.
Difficulties Were Encountered.
At the beginning, certain difficulties encountered were due to explosives
cartridges badly centred within the sheath ; the outside envelope would burst
too easily while the cartridge was being introduced into the borehole,
particularly at the very beginning before the diameter of the boreholes had
been increased to take care of the sheathing. As a result, sheathing material
would come between the ends of successive cartridges, forming a, cushion of
inert material that created chances of missfires. In addition, inadequate
instructions to shot-firers led them to remove the sheath at the time of use.
Then Lemaire got his idea of a rigid sheathing. It Was intended to be a
tube immediately surrounding the explosive, without any paper intervening. By
this means temptation for the men to remove the sheath would be withdrawn, for
if they did so the explosive would be spilled on the floor and become useless.
A single outside envelope of silicatised paper surrounded the tube, and the
ends were formed of silicatised paper caps fitting tightly on the envelope. The
rigid sheathing was composed of a mixture of chloride and fluoride containing
25 per cent. plastic clay and dried at a maximum temperature of 100°C, ,the
idea being not to impair complete pulverisation on detonation.
An order, dated 23rd May, 1924, required exclusive use of rigid sheathing, but
it never could be enforced because of the insurmountable manufacturing
difficulties — infiltration of salts between sheathing and explosive,
defective baking, and rapid decomposition of the explosive. These difficulties
were not overcome by silicatisation of the inside of the tubular sheaths but
could have been eliminated by baking at high temperature, which would have
impaired pulverisation of the sheath.
An order, dated 14th August, 1930, has definitely fixed the sheathing
requirements, and except for special cases involving certain compositions,
these conditions have not been altered since.
All the practical difficulties met have been overcome through the loyal
collaboration of explosives manufacturers and collieries with the Mining
Administration. The explosives manufacturers also overcame the difficulties
that developed in practical use, such as too brittle outside envelopes. Excess
thickness of paper at the ends of cartridges was eliminated by such artifices
as the paper disc glued over the ends of the cartridges. At the same time this
paper disc reduced the possibility of sheathing material coming between the end
of the cartridge and the bottom of the envelope. By the use of different types
of sheathing machines, which are both simple and very efficient, the occasional
unequal density of the sheath and the more or less poor centring of the
hand-filled cartridge have virtually disappeared.
On the side of the collieries, the management has endeavoured to provide
larger-diameter tools wherever sheathed explosives are to be used.
Sheathing Materials.
Lemaire had made observations of the selective character of certain
substances as sheathing materials, depending on the composition of the
explosive ingredients. He had tested several substances, among which was sodium
bicarbonate, but he had satisfied himself that the chlorides and fluorides were
very efficient and of low cost.
It may be said that the action of the sheath is mainly physical, by its cooling
and mass effect. It is very probable that it acts chemically also, indirectly,
by hindering the reactions, making gases less active, or directly, by partial
volatilisation or decomposition of the ingredients with the production of
certain gases, such as carbon dioxide, when sodium bicarbonate is used.
Attention is called to the following substances : Kieselguhr, lead sulphate,
iron filings, ferrous oxalate, sodium bicarbonate, sodium thiosulphate, and
sodium bisulphite. Judging from tests, the efficiency of sheathing seems to
depend mainly on the heat capacity of the substance used ; for instance, iron
filings give satisfactory results. The chemical properties of the materials
seem also to play a part.
In 1933, after sodium bicarbonate had boon tested more extensively and its
tendency to agglomerate neutralised, it was approved as a sheathing material.
M. Breyre makes several references to studies in this country and
Germany, and concluding his paper says : "While we have followed with very
particular interest all work pursued abroad on sheathed explosives, and have
tested for ourselves what may seem to be improvements, we have not deemed it
necessary to modify the Belgian sheath (which has been improved and perfected
during more than 20 years' experience) because of the increased costs. We will,
of course, not fail to follow closely all research work carried out abroad as
well as that in Belgium."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Breyre, Ad. | | Chief Inspector of Mines | |
| Lefebvre, M. | | Inspector of Mines | |
| Lemaire, E. | | | |