28th December 1940, Page: 193, Column: 1
The Storage Of Coal
Effects Without Rise in Temperature
By Frank Scarf, Douglas A. Hall, and Cecil W. Yearsley.
From paper presented at recent meeting of the South Staffordshire and
Warwickshire Institute of Mining Engineers. Investigation carried out by the
Fuel Research Board and published by permission of the Department of Scientific
and Industrial Research.
Processes Due to Storage.
As soon as the atmosphere is allowed access to coal in mining operations two
processes are initiated : the first, a chemical change, is oxidation, while the
second is of a physical nature, namely, disintegration or size degradation,
i.e., change in size grading. Under any given storage conditions the rapidity
of these processes depends upon the size grading and the rank of the coal, but
they doubtless occur even in large anthracite. In lignites, oxidation is so
pronounced as to preclude the possibility of bulk storage in open dumps, and in
bituminous coal storage precautions have to be taken to prevent spontaneous
ignition. It is evident that when severe heating occurs the effects upon the
nature and composition of the coal will be mainly a function of the temperature
attained and its duration, and thus deterioration of every possible degree
between the just measurable and that representing total combustion could be
experienced. Were it not impracticable, therefore, it would be preferable to
leave coal in situ until it is required. In practice, however, the methods of
coal production, distribution, and utilisation render it necessary that
reserves of wrought coal should be available. Storage dumps form the most
convenient reservoir ensuring steady flow between winning and utilisation. It
is difficult to estimate, even roughly, the amount of coal in storage at any
time, but it must aggregate many millions of tons. The U.S.A. Bureau of Mines
estimated the amount of coal in stock during the decade 1916-1925 as varying
between 20 and 63 million tons. These figures are exclusive of household
stocks, and represent mainly those held by industrial and power-plants. On the
basis of these figures it seems likely that, even in normal times, in Great
Britain similarly held stocks may approximate up to 20 million tons ; on this
quantity a deterioration of quality amounting to 1 per cent. represents a
wastage of up to 200,000 tons.
Except in cases where it is possible to exclude oxygen almost completely (e.g.,
under-water storage), the phenomena referred to above proceed in all stored
coal and must represent a very large annual fuel wastage. Where it is not
practicable to eliminate this loss by exclusion of air from stocks it can be
minimised by observing during the formation of dumps precautions which are
directed towards securing a low rate of oxidation by the prevention of
spontaneous heating. The recent general trend towards the more scientific use
of coal has brought with it a wider appreciation of the fact that coal does
deteriorate during storage. It has also revealed a lack of systematic and
co-ordinated data on the subject; at the same time it has provided users with a
supposed cause for complaint, which, in many cases at least, is based only on a
marred appearance of the fuel. In this way, very poor weathering qualities have
been imputed to Coleford Highdelf coal from the Forest of Dean. The present
work gives no support to such a reputation ; it has been shown that this coal,
in size grades of over ½ inch, suffers no serious deterioration during two
years of storage at atmospheric, temperatures.
Points not Realised.
The fact that coal undergoes alteration during the interval of time between its
mining and its eventual consumption appears to have been known for a
considerable time. It is probable that attention was first drawn to it by the
phenomenon of spontaneous combustion, which would undoubtedly occur as soon as
the practice of placing mined coal in large heaps was adopted, whilst the
necessity for taking precautions against such combustion had not been realised.
That coal is affected by exposure to the air when there is no visible evidence
of heating or combustion, appears not to have been recognised until about the
middle of the last century.
Many investigators into the loss of calorific value of coal during storage have
failed to take account of the effects of changes in weight due to absorption of
oxygen or to changes in the quantity and character of the mineral constituents
in the fuel. As a result of the process of weathering it is generally held that
coal increases in weight (at normal temperatures) and suffers a decrease in
carbon-content, volatile matter, and calorific value. Frequently there has been
a failure to make allowance for weight changes in computing the latter losses,
but more recently reliable investigators have recognised that, so long as the
temperature of the coal does not reach a point at which carbon oxides are
evolved, the reduction in carbon percentage is mainly or wholly due to the
dilution caused by increase in weight. On the other hand, the reduction in
calorific value is due not only to dilution but also to oxidation, and is
therefore greater than the decrease in carbon percentage, being to some extent
a real loss. There appears to be a general consensus of opinion that even where
heating has not been observed the apparent loss in calorific value may be as
much as 10 per cent., but it is evident from more recent work that the real
loss is very much smaller and may be negligible. Nevertheless, even where the
whole of the apparent loss has been accounted for by the gain in weight, on
purely theoretical grounds the chemical absorption of oxygen must necessitate
an evolution of heat-energy, and this heat represents an equal amount which
will eventually not be available when the coal is burned.
Effects of Ventilation.
Efficient storage of coal may be achieved either by exclusion of air
(preservation approaching that of coal in the seam) or by ventilation. The
effects of ventilation are twofold : (a) The provision of an adequate supply of
oxygen which enables oxidation to proceed at its maximum rate for the
particular size and temperature of the coal, and (b) a cooling current of air
through the dump which sweeps away heat liberated in the first process. A dump
cannot fire spontaneously without some ventilation to provide the necessary
oxygen. Insufficient ventilation may provide all the oxygen necessary for
oxidation (spontaneous combustion) without giving an appreciable cooling
effect. Thus a little air may be a great source of danger. Ventilation,
therefore, to be effective, must be efficient. In like manner it will be seen
that storage by exclusion of air must be thorough to be satisfactory, although
it is not necessary that the exclusion shall be comparable with that provided
by the overburden of a coal-seam in situ. It should be noted that efficient
storage by exclusion of air is preferable to storage by efficient ventilation
in that the coal will absorb less oxygen and so suffer leas deterioration
(particularly loss of calorific value and coking power). Air may be excluded
from stored coal by a variety of methods, e.g., immersion under water,
protection by an impervious cover, rolling during formation of dumps, or
filling the voids with an inert gas.
Investigations on Coleford Highdelf Coal.
The experimental investigation into the effects of storage without rise in
temperature on Coleford Highdelf coal involved the periodical removal and
analysis of coal-samples which had been deposited in dumps ; auxiliary branches
of the investigation were instituted which. did not involve the dumps. In all
cases the conditions were such as to preclude the possibility of there
occurring any greater rises in temperature other than those due to
meteorological variations. The changes which took place from one sampling time
to the next were frequently small, and this rendered accuracy in sampling and
analysis and constancy in technique of paramount importance. The experimental
tolerances permitted were sufficiently small to restrict analytical errors
within narrow limits.
Summary and Interpretation.
The effects of storage without rise in temperature on various grades of
Coleford Highdelf coal having been investigated, it has been shown that these
effects increase, though not proportionately, with decreasing particle size. In
grades above ½-inch they are hardly measurable in the space of 2 to 3
years by ordinary analysis, except in so far as loss of coke-forming propensity
is concerned. This appears to be a property which is influenced by oxidation
more quickly and to a greater extent than others. Thus the accompanying
increase in coke-yield, changes in elementary composition (increase in oxygen
and decrease in carbon-contents), decrease in calorific value and increase in
moisture-holding propensity, can be measured with any degree of certainty only
after the lapse of a considerable time. It is evident that the value of a coal
for coke or gas manufacture may be seriously affected long before its
composition or its heating value, but if the fuel is in lump form the
deterioration is slow. Conversely, it may be said that, in the storage of
coking coals, in practice no other criterion of value need be considered than
the coke-forming propensity, for if the coking powers are retained the fuel
will not have suffered any material deterioration.
In the case of grades below ½-inch the effects of weathering gradually
become more pronounced with decreasing particle size ; disseminated particles
below 1/400 inch suffer in a few days deterioration which is easily measurable
by analysis. Nevertheless, as has been shown, the rate of increase of
deterioration is very much less than the rate of increase of specific surface
area, and it seems from this that weathering is penetrative in its effects on
coal substance.
Changes in mineral impurities present in the coal become evident to the eye in
the early stages of storage and produce a rusty appearance ; the coal loses its
initial brightness. The quality of the fuel, however, as indicated by analysis,
is not in any way impaired by this. It has been shown that the pyrites oxidises
to sulphate, which reacts with carbonates. The latter are decomposed, carbon
dioxide being evolved, and finally, in exposed conditions, the sulphates
produced are leached-out. There is, therefore, a slow fall in the quantity of
mineral impurities present in the coal, at least until all the pyrites has been
oxidised and removed. At the same time the impurities remaining tend to
concentrate in the fine grades. The removal of sulphates and carbonates has
other effects, notably on the gaseous products of carbonisation. The
investigation into mineral-matter distribution and changes has also shown that
in fresh coal the mineral-matter content does not continually increase with
decreasing particle size, but reaches a maximum in the size grade of
1/180-1/400 inch. Thus the fraction below 1/400 inch contains less sulphur and
less mineral matter than the slightly coarser-grained fraction. This has been
found to hold not only for all samples of fresh pearls (such samples have been
taken over a period of 4 years without variation in the phenomenon) but also
for similar grades from coalfields other than the Forest of Dean. We therefore
agree with Heywood that "the commonly held generalisation that in
natural coal dust the finer the material the higher is the ash-content is not
correct." Heywood says that this holds only down to a fineness of
100 to 270 meshes per inch, beyond which "ash percentage invariably
decreases." This fineness closely corresponds to the fraction which we
have found to contain the highest ash-contents in fresh coal. In weathered
coal, however, the 1/400-0 inch fraction does contain more mineral matter than
the 1/180-1/400 inch fraction, so that Heywood's use of the word
"invariably" is hardly justified.
Disintegration of coal was observed to take place during storage, but the
methods used in the present investigation for the placing of samples in the
dumps were not amenable to the measurement of the disintegration.
No weight records were obtained, as, in the absence of heating, it can be
assumed that the coal-substance during weathering has absorbed and retained in
its structure as much oxygen as is represented by the increase shown in the
analyses, and has thus increased in weight to the same extent. On this basis
the degree
to which analytical changes are due to dilution, and are therefore unreal, may
be calculated.
The deterioration in large coal and doubles was found to be very small. The
composition before and after weathering of the pure coal of the dump pearls on
the mineral-free dry basis was as follows :—
On the basis outlined above, therefore, 100 parts of the fresh coal-substance
became 100.79 parts, with an oxygen percentage of 8.34, by the absorption of
0.79 part of oxygen. The calculated analysis of the weathered coal, assuming no
gains or losses in carbon, etc., is as shown in the last column of the table.
By comparison of these figures with those actually found after weathering
(shown in the middle column of the same table) it would appear that the
reduction in carbon-content is only that due to dilution by oxygen. Of the fall
in calorific value, however, less than two-thirds is accounted for thus, the
remainder — over 40 calories per gramme, or about ½ per cent. of the
total heat-value of the coal — being the true loss caused by the
evolution of heat during oxidation. Almost the whole of the observed reduction
in mineral matter is real, as also is the increase in moisture-content.
It appears probable that oxidation produces compounds in the coal-substance
which have carboxyl groups attached and which on heating break up into carbon
dioxide, carbon monoxide, and water, and a residue which is less volatile than
the original unoxygenated compounds. This would cause an increase in the
carbon-dioxide content of the gases evolved in carbonisation, an increase in
the coke-yield, a decrease in volatile matter, and possibly a loss of
coke-forming propensity ; it would account for the increase which was actually
found in the coke-yield from pearls (0.6 per cent. was found after allowing for
the change in mineral matter). This, therefore, is a real change, as dilution
per se would cause a reduction in the coke formed.
The apparent heat-loss due to dilution is, of course, also a real loss in the
fact that it leads to loss of efficiency, but its assessment as real loss is
not directly calculable.
In the case of the pearls cited above, the reduction in heating value as a fuel
is probably about 1 per cent. in 28 months ; the reduction in coking power is
very much greater and may be sufficient to rob the coal of its value for
carbonisation purposes. It is evident, however, that the results obtained in
this work do not substantiate statements that Coleford Highdelf coal has poor
storage qualities, at least in so far as storage without rise in temperature is
concerned.
The effects of exposure upon any one type of coal depends mainly upon such
factors as particle size, time, temperature, degree of degradation (affecting
particle size), and the nature of the exposure (wind, frost, rainfall). It has
been shown that the mixing of large coal with much fines is conducive to rapid
deterioration in the fine coal; in a large dump this may cause a rise in
temperature sufficient to set up serious deterioration in the large coal ; it
may lead eventually to spontaneous ignition. Experiments designed to
investigate the effects on coal of storage with rise in temperature are at
present in progress. In this new series, Coleford Highdelf and other coals are
stored in a number of dumps such as are used in practice. It is hoped that the
results of these experiments will provide practical data upon coal-storage, in
addition to showing the effects on coal of storage with rise in temperature.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hall, Douglas A. | | | |
| Heywood, — | | | |
| Scarf, Frank | | | |
| Yearsley, Cecil W. | | | |