14th December 1940, Page: 186, Column: 1
Fallacies Concerning Lubricants
At the September meeting of the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of
South Africa, Mr. Wilfred E. Gooday read a paper bearing the above
caption, in the course of which he called attention to a number of erroneous
views on lubricants. Incidentally he proved himself an adept at apposite
quotations and ready wit. Nor was he disposed to absolve himself, as in the
opening section of his paper he remarked that the first fallacy was "the
assumption that anyone who reads a paper on the subject of lubricants knows all
about them," telling his audience "I can rely upon myself to explode
that fallacious premise." He then proceeded to say that as compared with
what we have yet to learn, we know very little about the composition of the
heavier petroleum products ; the family names of their constituents are well
known but, if we try to distinguish by christian names all the members of the
different families, we find many gaps occupied by a great variety of
unidentified progeny. So, if we are asked for an account of the composition of
crude oil from which a mineral lubricating oil has been derived, our only
truthful reply is an incomplete one. We can say that there are paraffinic,
naphthenic, asphaltic and other hydrocarbons present, or broadly, should one of
these classes of hydrocarbons predominate, we may say that the crude oil is of
asphaltic or of paraffinic base or, in equivocal cases, of mixed base.
Although the complete composition of lubricating oils eludes our analysis, it
is possible to describe an oil's characteristics by means of empirical tests.
These tests arose and were developed mainly in petroleum refineries as a means
of process control, but they have escaped to other laboratories where some of
them have attained a significance that they do not merit. The author hereabouts
observed that perhaps the earliest reference to oil testing is in Leviticus :
"The priest shall dip his right finger in the oil that is in his left
hand." This suggests, at least, he added, the time-worn tradition behind
our modern laboratories but, joking apart, ideas comparable with such primitive
conceptions of oils linger on with scriptural authority to a ripe old age.
Under appropriate sub-heads Mr. Gooday dealt with specific gravity,
flash-point, colour, viscosity; noting, as regards the latter, that the most
widespread fallacy has now very nearly expired — it took a long time to
die — it may be described colloquially as : "the heavier the oil the
better" — "heavy" implying body or viscosity and not
weight. It was thought that heavy-bodied, viscous oils possessed more
"guts," but consideration of the effect of excessive fluid friction
— immediately observable in the operation of a high-speed, textile
spindle — and the need for quick heat removal — example, bearings
of the steam turbine — have dissipated the false premise on which the
earlier view was based and "guts" became unwanted. Practice to-day
leans towards the lightest bodied oil that will respond adequately to the
duties of a lubricant; in the reduction of friction, the promotion of rapid
heat transfer and, for cylinder lubrication, in the preservation of piston
seal. The performance of these functions is dependent not solely upon
viscosity, but obviously that property is an important factor in each case.
Lubricating Greases.
Acidity, sludge, renovation and cleaning were next discussed, and on the
question of lubricating greases Mr. Gooday said: Semi-solid lubricants
or lubricating greases vary from light coloured cup greases, known sometimes as
solidified oils, to hot-neck greases and black block greases that are plastic
to brittle solids at atmospheric temperatures. They are employed for almost all
industrial and for automotive, marine and railway lubrication where their
characteristics show them to be easier of application or more effective than
lubricating oils.
They are particularly useful where it is essential to prevent finely divided
materials such as flour, cement and other dusty impurities gaining access to
bearings ; where corrosive vapours might damage bearing surfaces ; where
splashing of lubricant must not occur, in food and textile processes ; where
leakage of lubricant must be avoided ; where lubrication must be effected under
water and where difficulty of approach renders it impracticable to use oil and
in innumerable services embracing : (a) plain bearings ; (b) ball and roller
bearings ; (c) rolling mill necks ; (d) gears and pinions ; (e) wagon, mine and
colliery tram axles, and (f) ropes.
There are many types of lubricating greases differing in their manufacture and
displaying diverse characteristics, such as colour, texture, consistency and
melting-point, which go to show wide divergence in physical and chemical
constitution. These products may be classified under half-a-dozen headings :
(a) cup greases; (b) sponge and fibre greases ; (c) block greases ; (d) rolling
mill greases ; (e) wagon axle greases, and (f) tram and gear greases.
The foregoing classification indicates the widespread scope for these important
commodities and suggests perhaps that it might be a fertile field for mistakes.
There are at least two persistent fallacies that should be revealed. The first,
as observed by Mr. Gooday, relates to greases in general but
particularly to the class of cup greases :
It is often alleged that lubrication is accomplished only by the mineral oil
contained in a grease. Where products of unsuitable quality are involved or
even where fine quality greases are wrongly applied, oil may separate from the
matrix and this unwelcome phenomenon may be the source of the supposition that
the soap content is merely the vehicle by means of which oil is applied. This
is not true, for it is the mixture as a whole that should give effectively the
service demanded of it.
The second fallacy is due to misleading nomenclature. The so-called fibre
greases do not contain implanted fibres ; they possess a fibrous structure
arising from their constitution and method of manufacture, and it is from their
texture only that they derive their name. This name is all the more misleading
because, in some instances, where conditions are severe and high temperatures
prevail, woollen yarn or asbestos fibres are introduced into sponge greases to
bring about an even and gradual feeding of the lubricant.
Specifications.
Passing on to specifications Mr. Gooday remarked that lubricating oil
specifications may be described as being either protective, selective or
descriptive.
The protective type will include clauses that prohibit the supply of
unsuitable or contaminated oils ; they are comparatively simple to prepare ;
with genuine products easy to meet and on the whole quite harmless.
The selective type is intended to define the best lubricant for the
purpose in view. It attempts to achieve an impossibility, and herein lies the
fallacy of such specifications.
The merely descriptive type will enunciate chosen test figures of an oil
known to be satisfactory. If accurately met it will restrict the sources of
supply and probably will exclude the use of more satisfactory products.
Mr. Gooday wondered why we can do no better than that. In the first
place, we are still in ignorance of much of the mechanism of lubrication, and
secondly, we have yet to ascertain the complete chemical composition of mineral
oils. In other words, the engineer cannot define accurately what he wants and
the lubrication technologist cannot describe precisely what he recommends. What
a fertile field for fallacies !
The Central Fallacy.
Proposing a vote of thanks to the Author Dr. P. E. Hall said that
associated with lubrication, as Mr. Gooday had outlined are a large
number of varied fallacies. These are all derived, however, from one leading
fallacy in a way which can best be illustrated by the old couplet—
"Big fleas have little fleas upon their backs to bite 'em,
Little fleas
have smaller fleas and so ad infinitum."
The central fallacy is that, in our present state of ignorance with regard to
the mechanism of lubrication, we should attempt to interpret empirical findings
— valuable though they may be — as if they were fundamental facts
in a well grounded and soundly erected lubrication structure.
Let us be frank, added Dr. Hall, and say that the lubrication engineer
has only a very hazy idea of how his lubricant functions. That being the case
he can give only an equally hazy idea of what it is he requires. The production
technologist has only an elementary idea of the composition of his raw
materials and the effects of his various processes on their properties as
lubricants. It is a matter for congratulation in these hit and miss
circumstances that the practice of lubrication has advanced to its present
position.
Physico-chemical Phenomena.
Professor W. J. Walker seconded the vote, and in the course of his
remarks said he was in whole-hearted agreement with the opinion that Protective
Specifications for lubricating oils are the only type which logically deserve
any existence. Selective and descriptive specifications of lubricating oils are
little else but displays of prejudice and ignorance.
Referring to the property of viscosity, the Professor leaned very heavily
towards the view that this property together with the property of adsorption,
plays the major part in effective lubrication. He thought it might not be out
of place to give his own views of the physico-chemical phenomena accompanying
lubrication. A fixed oil, i.e., an oil of definite molecular structure, not a
mixture, functions as a lubricant primarily by virtue of its viscosity and
secondly by virtue of the adsorptive power of the metal or metals of the
bearing for that oil. The fixed oils have, in general, appreciably greater
adsorptive attraction for metals than have the hydrocarbon oils, hence the
virtue of compounded oils. When a compounded oil is made up, the compounding is
effected either by purely physical means of some kind, such as heating, or by
the physico-chemical action of one or more additional ingredients. In general,
the compounding of fixed and hydrocarbon oils requires the application of one
or other different methods for effecting the homogeneous mixing of the two
types of oil. In other words, their miscibility or mutual absorptive capacity
is relatively small and requires to be artificially promoted. While such
compounded oils are functioning as lubricants the Professor imagines that the
metal of the bearings, exerting its greater adsorptive attraction for the fixed
oil, withdraws a portion of that oil from circulation. This portion of the
fixed oil constitutes, in addition to the viscous film, an underlying adsorbed
film, the strength and thickness of which depends wholly on the natural
adsorptive forces between the fixed oil and the metal surfaces.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Gooday, Wilfred E. | | | |
| Hall, P. E., Dr. | | | |
| Walker, W. J., Prof. | | | |