30th November 1940, Page: 163, Column: 1
Results Of U.S. Carbonisation Tests
The author of U.S. Bureau of Mines Report of Investigations 3482 on
"Correlation of Analysis of Coal with the Products of Carbonisation in
Externally Heated Retorts" is Mr. V. F. Parry, the senior fuel
technologist of the Bureau field station at Golden in Colorado. Appended are
extracts from the Report.
Coal is a compressed mass of heterogeneous, macerated, metamorphosed plant
remains that have collected in the earth's crust. Probably no two beds of coal
have identical properties, and different parts of the same bed may vary
considerably when measured by some of the many empirical tests that have been
developed to classify or differentiate the properties of coal. Because of this
great variability in properties, the commercial processing of coal to produce
coke and by-products has developed largely as an art based on experience,
rather than as a science. Much empirical chemical research, however, has been
and is being conducted on coal carbonisation, and this work is of practical
value in obtaining larger yields of gas and by-products and in the improvement
of the physical properties of the coke.
Both ultimate and proximate analyses have been used for correlating purposes.
In the United States the proximate analysis is used for the classification of
coal according to rank and grade. The proximate analysis can be employed
usefully in the coal carbonisation industry because separation of the
combustible matter of coal into volatile matter and fixed carbon is, in fact, a
small carbonisation test conducted on 1 gram of coal heated in a platinum
crucible.
The best-known methods of assaying coals for low temperature carbonisation are
(1) the Fischer method, in which 50 to 250 grams of coal is heated in an
aluminium retort (according to a definite schedule) to a temperature of
500° or 550°C. ; (2) the Fuel Research Board method, in which 20 grams
of coal is heated to 550° or 600°C. in a small silica tube ; and (3)
Bureau of Mines oil shale-assay method, in which 225 grams of coal is heated in
a copper or cast-iron retort. Tar, light oil, gas, and coke yields are
determined by these methods, and the analysis of the gas may be made.
Davis and Galloway have compared these three methods on American
coals and have concluded that the Fischer method is most suitable for
routine determination of the primary or low temperature carbonisation products
of coal and lignite.
In the field of high temperature carbonisation, the most widely used
small-scale laboratory test is the United States Steel Corporation distillation
procedure in which 20 grams of coal is heated in a ¾-inch diameter silica
tube according to an empirical schedule that has been found to produce results
closely comparable to those obtained in coke-oven practice. This test requires
a skilled operator to obtain reliable results because of the fine adjustments
and control necessary during the heating schedule. The Fuel Research Board of
Great Britain also has developed a high-temperature distillation assay in which
20 grams of coal is heated rapidly to 900°C. in an electrically-heated
silica tube.
Report of Investigations 3482 presents results of a study of the relation of
the proximate analysis and oxygen content of coal to the products obtained on
carbonisation in laboratory scale equipment with the object of detecting
general trends that are significant in commercial practice. General conclusions
only are justified, and some latitude in correlation must be recognised.
Nevertheless, the establishment of general trends should help to estimate
probable products from known analytical data on the available coals. Formulae
and graphs indicating such general trends are given in the paper, and in his
summary and conclusions Mr. Parry says :—
Since the proximate analysis is a small-scale carbonisation test that separates
volatile constituents from solid residue, it was assumed that valuable
deductions could be made regarding commercial carbonisation of coal, by
correlating the carbonising results at different temperatures in different
types of retorts with the proximate analysis and oxygen content. In making this
study, the following questions were set up as objectives in the correlation of
experimental carbonising results with the properties of the coals tested : (1)
What properties of a coal are significant in predicting plant results ? (2)
What are the major effects Of temperature, rate of heating, and size of retort
on the coke, gas, and by-products formed when coal is carbonised in externally
heated retorts ? (3) Given a proximate and ultimate analysis, what conclusions
can be drawn as to the probable results of carbonisation ?
The results from carbonisation tests of 125 coals, when correlated with the
analysis, support the following conclusions :—
1. The amount of tar that will form in an externally heated retort is
directly proportional to the square of the oxygen-free volatile matter
contained in the coal charged to the retort and inversely proportional to the
absolute temperature of carbonisation. The oxygen-free volatile matter is
defined as the percentage of volatile matter minus percentage of oxygen
combined with the coal. It excludes the oxygen in the water.
2. The amount of water that will form during destructive distillation at
low temperatures is directly proportional to the oxygen content of the coal
substance raised to the 1.3 power. The average of 100 distillations in the
Fischer retort indicates that the amount of water formed can be expressed by
the following formula : Water-formed percentage = 0.35 X oxygen1.3.
3. The amount of gas in B.t.u. per pound of coal is directly
proportional to the volatile heating value and inversely proportional to the
square of the volatile matter in the coal. The formation of gas at carbonising
temperatures between 500°C. and 725°C. is proportional to the average
absolute temperature of the wall of the retort raised to the 3.5 power. The
formation of gas at carbonising temperatures between 725°C. and
1,100°C. is proportional to the square root of the average absolute
temperature of the wall of the retort.
Because of this differentiation of the effect of temperature on gas formation
725°C. is arbitrarily taken as the dividing point between low temperature
and high temperature carbonisation.
4. The amount of coke resulting from carbonisation is the sum of fixed
carbon plus ash plus a factor, "R." Factor "R" is called
residual volatile matter and is defined as the percentage of the original coal
as carbonised that remains in the coke as a product of decomposition from
volatile matter in the coal. It is shown that the value of "R" is
related to the oxygen-free volatile, matter, the absolute temperature of
carbonisation, and the shape and size of the retort.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Davis, — | | | |
| Fischer, — | | | |
| Galloway, — | | | |
| Parry, V. F. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |