2nd November 1940, Page: 132, Column: 1
Ventilation Surveys
By L. R. Boyfield.
Extracts from paper on "Practical Notes on a Ventilation Survey" read
at the October meeting of the Midland Counties Institution of Engineers.
At the colliery in which this ventilation survey was made a steam-driven fan,
situated at the top of the upcast shaft, circulated 185,000 cubic feet of air
per minute, with an underground water-gauge of 6 inches. It was decided in view
of future developments that a complete and accurate pressure survey should be
made of the airways. This survey, when completed, would give the individual
pressure losses along airways due to air-crossings, junctions, bends, and
sudden changes in the cross-sectional area ; also the pressure losses due to
any particular type and area of support. With the data thus made available, the
existing airways, where necessary, could be reconditioned in order to enable
them to pass the estimated maximum quantity of air required for the life of the
district which they serve, without absorbing too large a ventilating pressure,
and thus increasing the water-gauge for the mine. This latter effect would
result in too high a figure for the power cost for ventilation.
After consideration of the most suitable means of making the survey to give the
information, required, the method of measuring the pressure losses by means of
a manometer and pressure pipes was adopted.
Apparatus Employed.
The apparatus consisted of (a) An inclined manometer, to measure the
pressure-difference in inches of water and graduated to read from 0 to 0.33
inch in intervals of 0.001 inch ; (b) Two pitot tubes, for measuring the static
and total pressures ; (c) Flexible hose pressure piping, 240 yards, ¼-inch
diameter — one length of 120 yards and two of 60 yards ; (d) Two rubber
tubing connections, from the manometer to the pressure pipes, and two rubber
tubing connections from the pitot tubes to the pressure-pipes ; (e) A windmill
anemometer, for measuring the velocity of the air at the pitot tubes ; (f) A
hygrometer, for measuring the wet and dry-bulb temperature of the air.
The manometer consisted of an aluminium reservoir containing paraffin of
specific gravity 0.806, communicating with a curved celluloid gauge-tube. The
graduations on the manometer were not evenly spaced but approached nearer to
one another towards the downstream end. This was due to the gradient of the
gauge-tube, which was not constant. Water was not used in the manometer owing
to its being insufficiently fluid and its tendency to stick to the glass, thus
giving an irregular meniscus. The manometer was designed to fit on to a
theodolite tripod, which made for ready and accurate levelling. The levelling
base was of the four-screw type with a Hoffman ball-and-socket joint for quick
levelling. To prepare the instrument for use it was set up on the tripod,
accurately levelled by the aid of the two bubble levels, the oil cap removed
and paraffin poured into it by the aid of a funnel. The displacer-screw for the
adjustment of zero position was placed in the halfway position, and the
paraffin poured in until the reading was zero.
The pitot tubes were of the standard type with concentric static and total
pressure tubes. The centre tube indicated total pressure ; the small holes
drilled through the outer tube cause the annulus round the centre tube to be at
static pressure. Nipples at the end of the stem enabled the two pressures to be
led away by means of rubber connections to the manometer. In the survey the
static-pressure tube was connected to the manometer only by means of the
pressure-pipes. When the pitot tubes are in use, the head must point directly
upstream, and be inclined at the same gradient as the airway. If this
precaution is taken corrections are obviated, and the static pressure in the
airways is measured direct. To maintain the pitot tubes as the same gradient as
the roadway, the cupholders were taken off the heads of two raining dial
tripods and discs substituted, and the pitot tubes were fitted through these
discs and rested on the heads of the dial legs. The discs held the pitot tubes
in position, themselves being secured by three screws on each of the dial
heads.
Method of Carrying Out Survey.
As the pressure survey was to cover the ventilating circuit for the mine, it
was necessary to divide the survey into a series of small surveys, each
following a separate ventilation circuit.
The first survey was commenced from the upcast shaft along the return airway to
the coal face, along the face, into the intake airway and back to the downcast
shaft. At the junctions where the return airways from other districts joined
the return airway which was being surveyed, station marks were left. These
station marks were noted as the future starting-points for the surveys of those
districts.
Similarly, station marks were left on the intake side at the points where
splitting of the air-current occurred. The surveys for such districts were
closed on these points, unless the airways were being reconditioned, whereby
the resistance of the airway would be altered. In such cases the airway would
be re-surveyed, and the different pressure loss determined.
The pressure loss along an airway was obtained by measuring the pressure loss
between two points along which the cross-sectional area and support were
uniform. Where the type of support altered the pressure loss along the airway
for the different type of support was measured. If the change of support was
accompanied by a sudden difference in cross-sectional area, the pressure loss
due to this change in area was measured separately. These pressure losses were
similarly measured at junctions, air-crossings, and bends in the airway. These
losses were tabulated in detail and their sum was the total pressure loss for
the ventilating circuit under survey.
Precautions Taken.
It is essential that each reading should be made as accurately as possible, as
the total W.G. for the ventilating circuit is obtained by adding together the
individual pressure losses.
At the time the pressure readings were taken, no person was allowed to stand in
the air-current in the airway within 10 yards of the pitot tubes. This was
necessary because of the possible effect on the air-velocity, particularly if
the area was small. In such case the increased velocity measured would give
rise to an appreciable inaccuracy in the pressure-difference.
For the same reason the manometer was not set up at the station point along
with the pitot tube.
When recording the static pressure loss due to bends, junctions, or sudden
changes in cross-sectional area, the position of the station was such as to
allow the large variations in air-velocity and the eddy currents which occur at
such points, to approach normal for the airway.
When the pressure-pipe was used for the first reading on any survey, time was
allowed for the air in the pressure-pipe and in the manometer to approach the
temperature of the airway.
In the case of the mine under consideration, the average underground
water-gauge during the period when the pressure survey was made was 6 inches.
The total water-gauge obtained on two of the ventilating circuits surveyed was
5.954 and 6.071 inches. Considering the fact that the survey was conducted
whilst the pit was working normally, and that each circuit averaged two weeks
to complete, the total W.G. obtained by the pressure survey proved that the
method adopted was practical and accurate.
Information Derived.
Pressure-distance graphs clearly indicate the points along the airways causing
too high a pressure loss. Taking into consideration the estimated maximum
quantity of air that the airway will be required to pass, the cross-sectional
area and type of support best suited for these conditions can be decided.
To improve the ventilation of a district, it is not a matter of guesswork as to
what the area of the roadway should be or what repairs should be carried out.
All the facts about the air flowing in that airway should be known, so that the
effect of reconditioning the airway by enlarging it or by reducing the angle of
the bonds, may be accurately foretold.
Whilst repair work was being carried out on a main intake airway 1,200 yards
long and passing 55,000 cubic feet of air per minute, the resistance of the
ripping lip was found to be equivalent to 140 feet of the reconditioned airway
— the roadway was now being supported by 12-foot splay rings, bricked
between rings, while the supports being extracted were 10-foot girders on
7-foot legs.
The effect of this reconditioning, when completed, was to reduce the
pressure-drop along the roadway by 0.5 inch W.G. with the same quantity of air
passing.
The information obtained by the pressure survey will indicate to the management
the points which, if attended to, would quickly repay the cost in improved
ventilation. If such surveys were made yearly or half-yearly a complete picture
of the mine-ventilation circuits would be always available.
Advantages of Manometer and Pressure-pipe Survey. — The method of
survey is a simple one and may be carried out by the ordinary surveying staff.
Provided care is taken when setting up the instruments, accurate and precise
results can be obtained.
The results obtained give the direct loss of pressure along each length of
airway, and no correction for level need be made.
As the manometer reads to 0.001 inch o£ water, the pressure loss along a
very short length of airway can be accurately measured.
The resistance of various types of supports for standard lengths, e.g., 1,000
feet, and constant cross-section, can be obtained and this information used
when deciding upon the cross-section and type of support required to pass a
given quantity of air when reconditioning an airway.
The resistance of air-crossings, junctions, bends, and any contracted point can
be measured separately, and the effect of improvement to the airway estimated
with a high degree of accuracy.
The improvement due to the reconditioning of an airway may be easily measured.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Boyfield, L. R. | | | |