19th October 1940, Page: 122, Column: 1
Scottish Coals And Their Uses
Volume 39 of the Memoirs of the Geological Survey* — special reports of
the mineral resources of Great Britain — issued by the Department of
Scientific and Industrial Research, constitutes an interesting "Synopsis
of the Mineral Resources of Scotland." This Memoir of 59 pages was
compiled in the Geological Survey Offices in Edinburgh under the direction of
Dr. M. Macgregor, M.A., D.Sc, and is divided into sections dealing with
coals, oil shales and mineral oil, ironstones, etc. ; a diagram showing the
geological formations in Scotland, with the principal economic minerals
obtained from each, is included. There is also an index to the volume.
In the Introduction it is stated that from an economic point of view by far the
most important formation is the Carboniferous, from which come not only all the
valuable coals, but in addition the refractory fireclays, ganisters, oil
shales, ironstones, limestones, etc., that play so important a part in the
industrial activities of Scotland.
The following particulars are abstracted from the section on Coals, in which it
is noted in passing that there is a small area of inferior coal of Jurassic age
at Brora, in Sutherland.
The valuable seams of coal occur in the Productive Coal Measures and Limestone
Coal Group. A few coals of workable thickness are found in the other
sub-divisions, but have only been wrought locally and on a comparatively small
scale. Outside the limits of the Midland Valley, Carboniferous rocks containing
workable coals are present in the Sanquhar-Kirkconnel basin of Productive Coal
Measures, in the small field of Limestone Coal Group coals at Machrihanish and
in the Canonbie district adjoining the Solway Firth.
Classification of Coals.
The Scottish coalfields include a wide variety of types of coal which may be
roughly grouped under the following headings:—
(a) Coals with Low or Moderately Low Caking Properties. — The
volatile matter in this group varies as a rule between 30 and 40 per cent.
(air-dried basis). Such coals are widely distributed and are found both in the
Productive Coal Measures and in the limestone Coal Group, more particularly in
the former. They are employed not only for household purposes but also for
steam-raising and in blast-furnace practice. They include the so-called
"splint coals" (hard coals composed largely of durain), which are of
special value in blast-furnaces and for use as a locomotive fuel. Many of the
coals of this group, whether of the feebly-caking or medium-caking types, would
yield suitable material for the low temperature carbonisation processes which
are being developed for the production of domestic smokeless fuel.
(b) Coals with High Caking Properties. — Coals of this type are
used for the production of metallurgical coke. It is sometimes stated that
Scotland lacks sufficient supplies of good caking coal for this purpose, but
such is not the case. There are adequate quantities to supply the existing
coke-ovens, while much coal that is suitable for metallurgical coke production
is at present disposed of in the open market. Indeed, a good deal more could be
done in the way of the selection of coals in both the above groups to meet
particular purposes. At present the coals fall, from the marketing point of
view, into the following broad categories :—
(i) The bright coals, with low ash content yielding a brown residue, find their
chief outlet in the domestic market.
(ii) The bright coals, with a whitish ash content and with varying caking
properties, are disposed of largely to gas-making undertakings.
(iii) The duller, harder coals are used mainly for steam-raising and similar
industrial purposes.
(iv) The good caking coals, found principally in the Limestone Coal Group, are
utilised in the metallurgical coke industry.
(c) Steam- and Navigation Coals. — In these the percentage of
volatile matter varies from about 15 to 25 (air-dried basis). In Scotland they
are of more local occurrence than the types already mentioned, being restricted
in distribution to the vicinity of sills or sheets of igneous rocks. They are
found, for example, in parts Of the Central Coalfield and Fife, where the
Limestone Coal Group has been invaded by sheets of dolerite. Similar coals
occur in the Productive Coal Measures of the Shotts district (Lanarkshire) and
elsewhere. Their main use is in circumstances where a high temperature of
combustion and little smoke are desirable.
(d) Anthracite. — In some localities in Scotland anthracites are
to be found with volatile matter contents similar to those in other well-known
coalfields, percentages of less than 8 on the air-dried material being not
uncommon. Such seams occur in the vicinity of igneous intrusions, especially in
areas where the intrusion has taken place during periods of marked crustal
stress. These anthracites are employed where slow or smokeless combustion is
required and in such operations as malting and the manufacture of producer-gas.
(e) Cannel Coals. — Cannel (i.e., Candle) coals, in which the
volatile matter exceeds 40 per cent. (air-dried basis), were at one time
extensively employed in the manufacture of illuminating gas and are still used
to some extent for enriching coal-gas. They were also worked locally as a
source of oil. While widely distributed, they vary much in thickness and
quality. Very often they form compound seams with ordinary coal, but the cannel
portions are lenticular and inconstant.
By far the richest and best-known of this type was the Torbanite or Boghead
"Gas" coal of the Armadale district, which has long since been worked
out. The best portions of other well-known gas coals, such as the Lesmahagow
Gas Coal, are also exhausted. Nevertheless there are certainly important
reserves of cannel coal in Scotland, but it should be remembered that, in the
event of these proving economically important as a source of oil, supplies will
have to be drawn from widely separated sources. It is only from certain seams
and from certain collieries that cannel could be obtained in quantity.
An outstanding feature of Scottish coals is the large number of seams which
show a low sulphur-content. The quantity is generally of the order of 1 per
cent. Chlorine, which is undesirable where the fuel is in contact with
firebrick-lined furnaces or retorts, is also of a low order.
Regional Distribution.
In a few general considerations it is emphasised that the Scottish coalfields
are localised in a well-defined belt extending in a north-east to south-west
direction along the Midland Valley. These coalfields may be broadly grouped
into :—
1. The Coalfields of Fife, including the Productive Coal Measures of the rich
Dysart-Wemyss field and the Limestone Coal Group of the central and western
parts of the county.
2. The Stirling-Clackmannan Coalfield, comprising the Coal Measures of the
Alloa-Dollar fields and the Limestone Coal Group of Bannockburn, Polmaise, etc.
3. The Central Coalfield, in which the main structural feature is the broad
Lanarkshire Basin with its central area of Productive Coal Measures, and its
fringing belt of Carboniferous Limestone strata.
4. The Ayrshire Coalfields, situated in the northern and central parts of the
county and including : (a) In North Ayrshire the Limestone Coal Group of the
Kilbirnie and Dairy districts and the Productive Coal Measures of Kilwinning,
Kilmarnock and Galston ; (b) The wide syncline of Carboniferous rocks fringing
and underlying the Permian sandstones and lavas of the Mauch-line Basin ; (c)
Farther south, the Limestone Coal Group of New Cumnock, Patna and Dailly, and
the Productive Coal Measures of New Cumnock and Dalmellington ; (d) In the
extreme east of the county the Muirkirk field of Limestone Coal Group age.
5. The Coalfields of Mid and East Lothian, stretching along the Firth of Forth
for about eight miles eastwards from Edinburgh and extending inland for a
distance of twelve miles. This region includes both Productive Coal Measures
and Limestone Coal Group coals.
6. Minor Coalfields : (a) The Douglas Valley-Glenbuck field, which includes
both of the coal-bearing sub-divisions of the Carboniferous ; (b) The
Sanquhar-Kirkconnel field of Productive Coal Measures only (c) The Machrihanish
Coalfield of Limestone Coal Group age ; (d) The Canonbie Coalfield in which a
full development of the Carboniferous is present; (e) The Brora Coalfield of
Jurassic age.
With the exception of the three last-mentioned fields it may be stated that the
boundaries and extent of the coal-bearing areas are very accurately known and
that a great deal of detailed information is now available from mining and
boring records as to the number, thickness, and quality of the seams of coal
they contain. The limits within which workable seams occur or are likely to
occur have been very carefully mapped.
The distribution outlined above is an expression of the folding to which the
Carboniferous rocks have been subjected as a result of crustal movements and of
the denudation which has subsequently taken place. The major coalfield areas
take the form of broad basins or synclines underlain and flanked by older
barren rocks. Within each of these major areas, again, folding and faulting
have combined to produce a number of more or less separate basins or mining
fields, and it is to this complex system of folds and faults that the
difficulties encountered in working the coals are largely due. Other factors
that affect the economic value of particular areas are : (a) The occurrence of
large spreads of volcanic materials which sometimes replace coals that are
elsewhere workable ; (b) Rapid attenuation of the sequence in a particular
direction, often accompanied by a concurrent thinning of the included coals.
Depth of Workable Seams.
It will be clear from what has been said that some of the coalfields contain
two series of coal-bearing rocks — the Productive Coal Measures and the
Limestone Coal Group. In such cases it is necessary to bore or sink through the
Productive Coal Measures and Millstone Grit into the underlying Carboniferous
Limestone Series to reach the lower group of coals. In other areas, where the
Coal Measures have been removed by erosion, only the lower series of valuable
coals is present.
It follows that the workable seams lie in some districts at shallow or
comparatively shallow depths. This applies to the Coal Measures seams in
general, the only important exception being the concealed area of Coal Measures
underlying the Permian sandstones and lavas of the Mauchline Basin in Central
Ayrshire. Here the estimated maximum depth to the lowest workable coal in the
Coal Measures is about 4,000 feet.** The Limestone Coal Group, again, is
exposed at the surface or lies at shallow depths over wide areas. Locally,
however, where it is overlain by a thick development of Coal Measures, the
depth to the lowest workable coal exceeds 4,000 feet. Thus, in the deepest part
of the Midlothian. Basin, between Portobello and Musselburgh, the lowest
workable coal in this group is estimated to lie at a depth of nearly 5,000
feet, while in the Dysart-Leven area of East Fife the depth attained is
probably at least 6,000 feet.***
In both the Productive Coal Measures and the Limestone Coal Group there is a
marked variation in the number and thickness of workable seams in the different
districts. There are, for example, areas within the Central Coalfield where the
Limestone Coal Group includes ten or even more seams of workable thickness ;
but in other areas such as the Carluke-Auchenheath district, on the south side
of the Lanarkshire basin, only two or three workable seams occur. Indeed, in
certain areas, such as the Hamilton district, it does not include a single
workable seam. A good deal of work has been done, however, on this very
important question of variation in thickness and economic value, and it is
possible to indicate approximately the less economically important fields.
The exhaustion, or approaching exhaustion, of a number of coalfield areas is
also an important consideration. While there are ample reserves of coal
available, the centres of production are bound, in course of time, to change
considerably. An indication of this is found in the increase in output from
Fife and Ayrshire in 1936 as compared with 1920, and the decrease in the output
of Lanarkshire for the same period. In a number of areas again, noticeably in
parts of Lanarkshire, the thicker seams are practically exhausted and only some
of the thinner coals remain to be exploited. In course of time Glasgow and the
other industrial centres of the Clyde valley will have to draw their supplies
from farther and farther afield.
* H.M. Stationary Office. Price 1s. net.
** So far as is known the Limestone Coal Group here does not contain any
workable seams.
*** No doubt greater depths are reached in some of the under-sea extensions.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Macgregor, M., Dr. | | Geological Survey | |