5th October 1940, Page: 107, Column: 1
Preservation Of Mining Timber
South African Investigations
At the July meeting of the South African Institution of Engineers a paper was
presented on "The Preservation of Mining Timber, with Particular Reference
to the Effect of Air Pressure, Moisture Content, Initial Vacuum and Temperature
on the Absorption of Preservative." The authors of the paper are Messrs.
J. W. Bowen, M.Sc, and B. R. Lomberg, B.Sc, and in their
introduction they explain that all experimental work was carried out at the
Timber Research Laboratory of the Transvaal Chamber of Mines.
Timber treated with "Yard Mixture" for experimental purposes has now
been underground for approximately seven years. The state of this timber,
considering the adverse conditions under which it is being tested, is good.
Unfortunately, this length of life has not always been obtained from timber
treated in large scale preservation plants. This applies particularly to large
poles which tend to decay in about four to five years.
In "Yard Mixture" zinc sulphate and triolith are used at 3 per cent.
and 0.3 per cent. strength respectively. The cost of the treatment, independent
of plant, is approximately 1.2d. per cubic foot. It is stressed that where
extra long life is desired from timber extra care in treatment and an increased
concentration of triolith is considered necessary.
Objects of Investigation.
The objects of the investigation were to determine : (1) The effect of pressure
on absorption. (2) The effect of an initial vacuum followed by pressure
treatment on absorption. (3) The effect of the moisture content of timber on
absorption. (4) The effect of temperature of the preservative on absorption.
(5) The absorption of preservative by the two principal timbers used
underground, i.e., Wattle (Acacia mollissima) and Saligna (Eucalyptus saligna).
(6) The influence of duration of treatment on absorption in connection with the
above factors.
Material for Test.
Timber. — Wattle (Acacia mollissima) and Saligna (Eucalyptus
saligna) were the species of timber used throughout the investigation. The test
pieces were unit chock mat pieces, 2 feet long, 6 inches in diameter faced on
two sides to give a 4-inch rise. Each treatment charge consisted of ten
billets, in all approximately 3 cubic feet.
Preservative. — The preservative was "Yard Mixture."
This consists of 3 per cent. zinc sulphate plus 0.3 per cent. triolith.
Triolith is a proprietary compound composed of approximately 55 per cent.
sodium fluoride, 35 per cent. sodium bichromate and 10 per cent. dinitrophenol.
Preservation Plant. — Large scale laboratory plant consisting
essentially of a storage tank, treatment cylinder, pressure tank, line to air
pressure and a vacuum pump and the necessary gauges for pressure, vacuum and
the estimation of absorption of preservatives, was used for the impregnation of
the test pieces.
Summary of Experiments.
Following a description of the conditions under which the experiments were
carried out the authors summarise the points as follows :—
(1) It appears from the difference in effective life obtained from experimental
and mass treated timber that the treatment given commercially is not always as
thorough as possible.
(2) Absorption of preservative has been correlated with the diameter of the
timber to be treated. Large poles, on account of the smaller percentage
sapwood, appear to absorb less preservative than smaller poles. It is revealed,
however, that very little difference in absorption actually occurs.
(3) As to the effect on absorption of increasing the air pressure, this brings
about a corresponding increase in absorption of preservative.
(4) It is shown that the time of treatment has considerable bearing on
absorption of preservative.
(5) Increasing the temperature of the treating solution does not appreciably
increase absorption.
(6) It is important to have the timber reasonably dry before treatment. It is
suggested that the timber be seasoned for some time before treatment, otherwise
low absorptions are likely to be obtained.
(7) A comparison is drawn between absorption obtained with wattle and gum.
Wattle does not absorb preservative as readily as the gum.
(8) The question of using an initial vacuum prior to the application of
pressure has been investigated. With woods which are relatively difficult to
impregnate the use of an initial vacuum increases absorption considerably.
Conclusions and Recommendations.
(1) The effect of pressure on absorption. — Pressure plays a very big
part in absorption. Up to 110 lb. pressure it appears that absorption is
directly proportional to pressure. It is recommended that the maximum air
pressure available be used at all timber impregnating plants.
(2) The effect of increasing the time of treatment on absorption. — Where
long life is required from timber underground it is advisable to increase the
time the timber is subjected to pressure. Timber, on being subjected to
pressure for 20 minutes, absorbs only 82 per cent. of the preservative which it
would absorb if subjected to the same pressure for 1 hour.
(3) The effect of the temperature of the solution on absorption. — The
temperature of the treating solution in the case of relatively easily
impregnated wood appears to have little effect on increased absorption. The use
of hot solutions is not justified.
(4) The effect of moisture content of timber on absorption. — From the
results obtained it is advisable to include in buying specifications a clause
stating that timber must be seasoned for some time prior to despatch to a mine.
In the rainy season it is advisable to allow the timber to dry out before
treatment. This factor is of considerable importance in the effective life
obtained from timber.
(5) Saligna absorbs considerably more preservative than wattle. On account of
the greater durability of untreated wattle, however, there appears to be little
difference between the life obtained from treated saligna and wattle.
(6) An initial vacuum prior to the application of pressure greatly increases
the absorption. This is more noticeable in timbers like wattle which are
difficult to impregnate than in readily impregnated timber like saligna. Where
long life is required from timber an initial vacuum of 20 inches for 10 minutes
followed by pressure ensures excellent absorption.
(7) For maximum absorption for mixed timbers the following is recommended :
Twenty-three inches of vacuum for 10 minutes, followed by 110 lb. pressure for
10 minutes.
(8) It is recommended that once a month, or at suitable intervals, a special
mixture of 4 per cent. zinc sulphate and 0.6 per cent. triolith be made up and
all timbers required for special purposes be treated with this preservative and
stored until required.
Absorptions About Equal.
As recorded in the Journal of the South African Institution of Engineers, in
discussion following the reading of the paper Mr. N. B. Eckbo stated
that the success of timber preservation with water-borne solutions in such
timbers as saligna and wattle is so dependent on a maximum absorption that any
efforts in this direction are extremely well directed. Since the preservative
to be injected replaces the moisture previously evaporated from the wood, it is
obvious that the drier the wood the more it is capable of absorbing.
Absorptions are just about equal irrespective of the method of timber
treatment.
Following up on the results set forth in the paper, Mr. Eckbo suggests
that immediate attention might profitably be directed to (1) The use of
stronger solutions, as recommended ; (2) The more thorough drying of the wood
to be treated; (3) Increase in absorptions, not only as a consequence of (2),
but also by alterations in the treating technique ; (4) Larger scale service
tests with variously treated materials in different preservatives so as to
establish more conclusively the advantages gained and dispel any doubt about
the life of the present output.
Mr. J. A. Loseby expressed the view that Messrs. Bowen and
Lomberg have done a valuable piece of work and have shown clearly how
the different variables affect the absorption of preservative. Their
recommendations should undoubtedly give excellent results when applied on a
large scale to sound timber. In Mr. Loseby's opinion the importance
cannot be overstressed of ensuring that the timber is sound before treatment in
a case where the treating conditions are not of such a nature as to sterilise
the wood. This is the more important where the species dealt with have
non-durable heartwood. He feels that the solution, in part at least, of the
problem which led to the present investigation will quite possibly be found by
paying special attention to methods of stacking and yard hygiene.
The Main Question.
Having directed attention to the points that (a) much depends on the size and
condition of the timber to be treated, and that (b) the suggestion to increase
the strength of the solution from 3 per cent. to 4 per cent. zinc sulphate and
from 0.3 per cent. to 0.6 per cent. triolith raises the question of cost,
Mr. H. A. Read submitted that the main question is whether it is
desirable to attempt to obtain optimum treatment of all timber used in the
mines. Support of stoping operations is a progressive process. Very large
quantities of timber used in the support of stopes ultimately take the weight
of the hanging and cannot be recovered. It would thus seem not so important to
treat the timber used in stope support with strong solution. In some mines the
hanging comes down so rapidly that the value of any treatment is doubtful, and
one large mine has, in fact, considerably reduced the use of treated timber for
this reason. This leads to the question of more effective treatment of timber
used in airways, shafts, cribbing above incline shafts and permanent ways. For
this purpose it is highly desirable that more effective methods of preservation
should be adopted. With regard to shaft timbers, pitchpine, generally used for
shaft purposes, should be protected. The heartwood of pitchpine cannot be
impregnated. Sapwood, found in most pitchpine of large section, readily takes
treatment, and it is for this reason important that shaft timbers should be
preserved. Cases of very rapid deterioration of untreated shaft timbers are
known, and the replacement of timber which has failed owing to fungal attack is
both irksome and costly. These remarks also apply to the timbering in permanent
ways.
Mr. Read does not think that officers in charge of treatment plants will
have any difficulty in adopting the suggestion of the authors that a solution
of higher strength should be used for such purposes.
Consideration might be given to superimposing an oil treatment after the normal
treatment as an alternative to increasing the strength of solutions. This point
has, as far as Mr. Read is aware, not been fully investigated yet.
A point which has emerged from investigations is that the suppression of attack
on timber underground by the very numerous fungi found in the mines will tend
to prevent the pollution of the air. All fungal organisms consume oxygen and
give off CO2 in appreciable quantities. Experiments have shown that
the quantity of CO2 given off increases when the fungus is in active
growth. An experiment was carried out many years ago by the late F. G. A. Roberts
in which a stope was blocked off and the air measured at the intake
and outlet. This pointed to the conclusion that there was an appreciable
increase in CO2 at the outlet, i.e., after the air had passed
through timbering which had been partly destroyed by fungal attack.
Another important point is the reduction of the fire risk. It can be stated
beyond doubt that the treatment of timber by the so-called "Yard"
mixture makes the timber practically fire-proof, and this fact has been
recognised by many mine managers. The number of outbreaks of fire underground
since the treatment of timber has become general has been definitely reduced.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bowen, J. W. | | | |
| Eckbo, N. B. | | | |
| Lomberg, B. R. | | | |
| Loseby, J. A. | | | |
| Read, H. A. | | | |
| Roberts, F. G. A. | | | |