5th October 1940, Page: 104, Column: 2
Administrative Side Of Indian Coal Trade
Mr. J. B. Ross, M.L.C., in his presidential address to the Mining,
Geological and Metallurgical Institute of India devoted himself to the economic
problem of the Indian coal trade as it exists to-day and as he sees it from the
administrative rather than the executive point of view. He said that a few
years ago the potential capacity of Indian collieries was estimated in
responsible quarters at 25 millions of tons per annum. In 1937 there was a
visible increase in demand and the output figures showed a total of more than
the 25 millions, whilst in the following year the output rose to no less than
28,342,907 tons. Prices at the end of that year dropped considerably. Price
cutting is an underlying weakness which presents an almost insoluble problem to
those engaged in the Indian coal trade who are desirous of maintaining the
trade in a reasonably prosperous condition.
From a study of conditions in the Bengal and Bihar fields, he summarised the
difficulties under three main headings: (1) Productive capacity being in excess
of demand ; (2) Lack of efficient marketing organisations amongst smaller
colliery owners ; (3) Lack of co-operation within the industry generally.
The first item is a question of fact; but it is his opinion that, when demand
reaches the figure of 27 millions of tons plus 1¼ million tons of colliery
consumption, as it did in 1939, the productive capacity has been reached and
that the drop in prices that year, therefore, was not due to this factor. The
increased demand in 1938 cannot be put down directly to war conditions, but
doubtless the unsettled state of Europe had a beneficial effect on Indian
industry generally.
That the demand in 1939 received a fillip from the declaration of war there is
no doubt whatever and, so long as the war continues, price levels are likely to
show a rising curve, as also must production costs. If, however, industrial
activity is permitted after the war to return to the 1936 level, the outlook
for the coal industry will indeed be gloomy, as the competition which now
exists for participation in the present exceptional demand will be accentuated
to the point where the inexorable law of the survival of the fittest begins to
operate and collieries producing the lowest grades of coal and those which are
unable to produce at costs within prices prevailing are forced to close down.
It is the second point that Mr. Ross considers to be the root cause of
the economic difficulties of the coal trade. So far as the larger collieries
are concerned, they have efficient sales organisations by means of which they
are able to tap the main consuming markets and to obtain a suitable offtake for
their production. The smaller collieries are severely handicapped in this
respect as their output is generally insufficient to permit them the luxury of
a whole time salesman. Nevertheless, these small collieries, for the most part
in the Jharia field, may be said to set the price standards for the year. The
output of most of these collieries is in itself an uneconomical figure and,
particularly in the rains, when pumping troubles are at their worst, pillars
are in many cases robbed and galleries widened beyond the safety margin to
maintain output. Whilst every sympathy must be felt for these people in their
plight, since they constitute the greatest obstacle to the maintenance of the
trade on a stable and reasonably prosperous basis, Mr. Ross is, like all
others who have the interests of the industry at heart, anxious to find a
solution which will bring about a cessation of cut-throat competition and the
establishment of better conditions in which these small colliery owners will
share.
Having in view the enormous quantities of coal already lost in the Jharia field
under existing circumstances through the leaving of barriers and by fires and
collapse and the large quantity which seems likely to be lost in the next few
years, the President said that Government should be sufficiently interested to
take the steps which are within its power to make amalgamations of contiguous
small collieries, where practicable, compulsory by providing through
legislation the necessary facilities and removing such legal obstructions as
demands for way leave, royalty complications and other factors likely to
interfere with this method of rationalising a section of the coal industry,
which is in bad case and which is in no position to extricate itself.
Recommendations on these lines were made by the Coal Mining Committee of 1937
and are presumably still under the consideration of Government.
Mr. Ross cited a number of areas in which amalgamation on the lines he
suggested would prove a boon, not only to the industry but to the productive
capacity of the area itself.
He does not suggest that amalgamations will be by any means easily brought
about, but the general principle which should be followed Would be to have a
valuation fixed for each property by a qualified assessor, and this would be
the basis of allotment of shares in the joint Company to the original
proprietors who would elect their Board of Directors in the ordinary manner by
strength of shareholding. In the nett result of such amalgamations, much of the
existing useless competition at low prices would disappear to the benefit of
the industry generally. It would be, in the President's opinion, a step in the
right direction and would in all probability assist in bringing about that much
needed co-operation in the industry without which prosperous conditions cannot
be maintained.
Referring to the lack of co-operation within the industry generally, Mr.
Ross said that in Bengal there are three Associations which claim to
represent the coal trade. The natural result of this arrangement is that there
are frequently three different sets of opinions on matters concerning the
welfare of the industry expressed according to the interests of the membership
of the different bodies and, unfortunately, in many instances against the
interests of the trade as a whole. In this connection he desired to make it
clear that he attached no blame to any particular one of the three. It is the
natural outcome of their separate existences, but the fact remains,
nevertheless, that when Government consults each of these bodies for the views
of the coal trade, it is not an uncommon occurrence for widely conflicting
opinions to be received.
On many occasions efforts have been made by the leaders of each of these bodies
to work in co-operation with the others, but inevitably some point emerges on
which fundamental differences of opinion arise, and for the time-being such
co-operation ceases and each body goes its own way, not always for the good of
the industry. The co-operation and co-ordination of effort required would
appear to Mr. Ross to be best brought about by a Central Committee
elected by the different associations on which each association within the
trade would have full representation. Such a committee would be limited in size
to enable its deliberations to be effective and its decisions would represent
the views of the industry as a whole. He is aware that a committee of this
nature will not meet with universal approval within the industry, but it
represents, in his view, a step in the right direction towards co-operative
thinking and action of which the trade stands so badly in need and which the
present diversity of interests makes so difficult of attainment.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ross, J. B. | | President | |