7th September 1940, Page: 69, Column: 2
Firedamp Ignition By Explosives
U.S. Investigations
In the last forty years or more many studies of the ignition of inflammable gas
mixtures have been made, and Technical Paper 603 issued by the U.S. Bureau of
Mines on "Phenomenon in the Ignition of Firedamp by Explosives —
Part 1, Particles from the Detonation," gives the results of some further
experimental studies of this important problem. The authors of the Paper are
S. L. Gerhard and Wilbert J. Huff. In their introductory
statement they explain that the Explosives Division of the Bureau conducts a
series of laboratory examinations and empirical performance tests to maintain
appropriate standards of quality. In the most important test an explosive
charge is fired from a steel cannon into a gallery atmosphere containing a
mixture of natural gas and air ; in another an explosive charge is fired into a
mixture of coal dust, natural gas, and air. Somewhat similar systems of control
over the characteristics of coal-mining explosives are exercised by leading
nations involved in this industry. The application of these empirical tests and
the development of sound Held practice indicated by such control have been
important factors in the reduction of accidents in coal mines. The standards of
safety thus attained, however, should be considered only transitory, as
economic trends alter mining technique.
The compounding of explosives is largely an empirical art governed by the
method of trial and error, which is both expensive and time consuming. Without
a clear understanding of the basic physical and chemical phenomena involved in
the ignition process, at least insofar as it applies to the initiation of
firedamp and coal-dust explosions, the compounding of safer explosives has
proceeded very slowly.
The Explosives Division of the Bureau has also engaged in research on many
phases of the basic problems involved in developing safer explosives. To-day,
one group of investigators is studying the kinetics of the underlying chemical
reactions involved in ignition and explosions, while another group is
investigating the limits of inflammability of combustible gases and vapours in
air or oxygen, including admixtures of these with common inert gases. The
present work deals with a third activity — the examination of the
phenomena occurring when an explosive is fired into gas-air mixtures. The
development of more information on the phenomena of ignition and the
formulation of the essential factors for safety on a scientific basis may
simplify the compounding of less hazardous explosives.
Data are given from experiments of other investigations, and it is noted that
the decomposition of an explosive charge is very rapid but not instantaneous ;
as detonation cannot occur simultaneously throughout the charge, parts may be
ejected incompletely decomposed. Experimental evidence of this fact was
described by Lemaire many years ago. He found that with certain
explosives the flame of the explosion resembles a fireworks display and that in
certain photographs of flames the trajectories of burning particles of the
explosive could be observed. Payman and Robinson, by means of
schlieren photographs of the discharge from a cannon borehole, showed the
presence of solid particles.
The review of experimental data and derived opinions deals largely with British
and continental European researches employing explosives used in the several
countries making the experiments. Such explosives are not identical with those
used in the United States. The conclusions reached have been based largely upon
explosives fired unstemmed or even unconfined, conditions not in accord with
practice specified in the United States for permissible explosives.
Whether the action of the particles from the explosive be incendive or
suppressive, as maintained by contradictory theories, the Authors say it
appears desirable to find out whether or not they are emitted by stemmed shots
using typical American permissible and other explosives. Should their existence
be established the inquiry might be directed to the determination of the part
they play, if any, in the ignition of firedamp.
Details are given of the work undertaken, with the results of which the
Circular is mainly concerned, and in their summary and conclusions the Authors
observe :
Particles are ejected when an explosive is detonated. This is indicated by
particles collected in front of the borehole, by the ignition of inflammable
targets such as guncotton and balloons filled with explosive gas-oxygen
mixtures, and by numerous photographs showing traces of sparks. It is not yet
possible to ascribe sparks to any particular ingredient of the explosive. Some
particles from American explosives appear to be inert, and others may be
actively decomposing. The latter doubtless burn up completely, as indicated by
the fact that no traces of them could be collected, except on adhesive surfaces
that quenched combustion. However, targets have been ignited, even when no
sparks are visible.
The absence of visible sparks from European explosives may be due to the large
amounts of cooling agents they contain, although photographically invisible
centres of ignition from German explosives also appear to ignite inflammable
targets.
The effects of other emissions from the borehole also were investigated, and
the results obtained indicate that the particles alone may have been
responsible for the ignitions of balloons and guncotton at distances greater
than 1 metre from the borehole. The shock wave was found to have no effect on
the targets, as indicated by the fact that the regions where ignitions occurred
coincided rather closely with the regions into which particles were ejected.
Furthermore, it was found that neither the ranges nor the areas of ignition
could he correlated with the ignition of firedamp by identical shots in the
gallery.
The proof that incendive particles can ignite firedamp under mining conditions
is not yet complete. Before the theories attributing ignitive or suppressive
action to such particles can be accepted conclusively for American explosives
more information concerning the characteristics of these particles should be
obtained. The investigation is being continued.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Gerhard, S. L. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Huff, Wilbert J. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Lemaire, — | | | |
| Payman, — | | | |
| Robinson, — | | | |