24th August 1940, Page: 60, Column: 2
Suggested Engineer's Training
At the annual general meeting of the South African Institution of Engineers
Mr. V. Pickles, the retiring president, devoted his valedictory address
to the place of the engineer in the general scheme of things. He likes to think
that the principal motive behind the movement for raising the status of the
engineer is to increase his influence for the public good as distinct from his
economic standard. In the past as it seems to appear to him the training has
been too one-sided to enable the engineer to take an unbiased and balanced view
of non-engineering matters, with the result that he is apt to assign too great
a weight to what might be termed the materialistic aspects of life. In general,
his mind becomes too clogged with engineering matters for him to give that
consideration to ordinary human affairs which is so necessary if he is to wield
any great influence in guiding those affairs.
Mr. Pickles is aware that many may not agree with this opinion, but it
has struck him that during the budding engineer's student days the attempt is
made to cram into him a great deal of knowledge in too short a space of time.
The aim seems to be to impart as much technical knowledge as possible rather
than to lay a firm foundation for acquiring a wider knowledge in after life.
Such an intensive training must have a tendency to close a young man's mind to
other things, to art and literature, and to those subjects which make up what
we know as general education. In the usual case the engineer's only general
education is that he receives during his school days, usually an irresponsible
age during which learning is a drudgery. As many of us know, Mr. Pickles
proceeded to say, knowledge acquired under such conditions does not penetrate
deeply, and while we may finish our school days with a respectable character
our general knowledge is often of a sketchy nature. For this reason lie thinks
that the engineer's training might with advantage include the earlier stages of
classical reading, sufficient to give him a thirst for more which he could
satisfy in his post university days.
Many will say that life is too short to do more than specialise. Formally this
may be so, but it does not alter the desirability for formulating a scheme for
training which deliberately will include periods available for acquiring a
broader knowledge of life than is the case to-day.
The plea Mr. Pickles wishes to emphasise is to so enlarge the equipment
of the young engineer that his facility for straight thinking can be utilised
in non-engineering matters, and if his training can be framed so as to enable
him to acquire that greater understanding of human affairs it will be a step
towards making him a much more useful member of society.
Proposing a vote of thanks to Mr. Pickles for his address a point made
by Mr. K. Richardson, a past-president, was that it is fashionable to
blame the engineer for many troubles of the world and to say that his ingenuity
has resulted in the terrible weapons of destruction that modern warfare
employs. Mr. Richardson thinks the answer to this was given, by
Dr. Jeans, that it was not the fault of the engineer that such troubles were
caused by his ingenuity, but rather that the engineer was satisfied when he had
invented apparatus to save labour and so forth, and did not carry on and take
greater charge of the affairs of the world, and see that his inventions were
correctly applied.
The vote was seconded by Professor W. J. Walker, also a past-president,
who expressed the view that modern developments in economics do not emphasise
the fact that the science of economics is concerned with material welfare, or
material wellbeing, but that it is a science which deals essentially with the
disposal of scarce means for the securing of given ends. The ends may be
material or spiritual ; whether they be material or spiritual is surely and
clearly a matter for human choice. The Professor feels that the main trouble is
not that engineering is a materialistic science but that in pursuing its
development without reference to human values we have gone sadly astray.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jeans, —, Dr. | | | |
| Pickles, V. | | President | |
| Richardson, K. | | Past President | |
| Walker, W. J., Prof. | | Past President | |