24th August 1940, Page: 52, Column: 1
Training Of Mining Engineers
By Sidney B. Haslam, M.I.Mech.E., M.I.E.E.
Extracts from presidential address delivered at the annual meeting of the
Association of Mining Electrical Engineers (The Mining Electrical Engineer).
There is now a definite tendency, fostered by the Royal Commission, to bring
the two branches of mining engineering — Electrical and Mechanical
— into closer communion, and by encouraging a member of one branch to
qualify in the other to obtain an official expert in both. This, in my opinion,
is most desirable, and I suggest that each member of this Association should
aim at, and fit himself for, the position superior to that which he now holds,
with, as a final goal, the status of chief engineer.
I must make it quite clear that I am not so much concerned with the education
and training of the few who can afford to undertake this without considering
expense, but rather with the many who must obtain the necessary theoretical
training whilst earning a wage. Let us assume that a good general education to
the standard of the Matriculation Examinations has been obtained and the youth,
having decided on his profession, now wonders how best to get the necessary
training. This is a somewhat controversial subject. He can either adopt (1) a
practical followed by a theoretical training, (2) the theoretical followed by
the practical, or (3) a sandwich course.
There is another course, that of practice during the day, and theory at evening
classes, and this may be the only course available to many. By all means that
course should be taken if it be the only possibility of acquiring knowledge.
That many very good men have been turned out in the past by this system is well
known and agreed, but I submit that conditions to-day are very different, and
so much more varied knowledge has to be assimilated. Under the conditions of
strain following a hard day's physical work, it is only a very exceptional mind
that can tune into, and concentrate upon, the more extensive theory necessary
in these more advanced times.
The sequence of the practical and the theoretical training is still a debatable
matter. General opinion leans towards the "theory first" sequence. It
is claimed that if three or more years of practical work are undertaken
immediately after leaving school, the habit of systematic study, which is so
essential, must to some extent be lost. To recapture this will call for
additional toil and effort and may result in a reduced standard of attainment.
It is most important that education and training should be so arranged as to
maintain interest. In the past practical knowledge did, in my opinion, help and
create interest in the theories governing that practice, and I am still
uncertain as to whether that does not apply in the case of mechanical subjects.
In electrical engineering, more than any other. I feel that the college trained
man will find his practical work easier, and of greater interest because he
knows the theoretical whys and wherefores of the practical work he is called
upon to do. The youth taking the practical course first cannot be greatly
interested when called upon to handle material and to take his share in the
making of articles and the assembly or erection of plant, the purpose of which
is altogether unknown to him. He would have to be exceptionally able and
observant to imbibe much knowledge from these actions likely to be of use to
him in later life. If, however, he has had previous technical training, he will
recognise the work he is doing, and do it with added interest because it helps
to prove the theories previously taken on trust.
My own views are in favour of the Sandwich System, and, as I firmly believe
that this will be the most general method of training in the future, I suggest
the following advantages :—
(1) The break in the educational career previously referred to does not occur,
and the habit of learning is retained.
(2) There can be no question as to the greater ease of technical instruction
given to a student who has a general and growing knowledge of practical
engineering, and the work on both sides becomes more interesting.
(3) There is a great advantage to be derived by a student working on these
lines, in that he is broadening his general outlook, and discovering humanity.
This is one advantage I would specially emphasise. The close contact with his
fellow men for some years, doing similar work under similar conditions, must
help to form character and to strengthen immature ideals.
Apart from other considerations, the lines on which theoretical training will
move must depend to a considerable extent on the facilities available. It is
reasonable to assume that the embryonic mining electrical engineer is native to
an industrial area, either in one of the larger towns or cities, or in
proximity to a colliery. If the former, he is indeed fortunate because the
technical education available in these towns or cities is based on excellent
lines.
The Education Authorities in all industrial areas are continually improving the
facilities available to the student, even in the smaller towns or colliery
villages.
I may be pardoned if I refer to the scheme of mining education administered by
the Glamorgan County Council. No doubt other equally excellent schemes are in
operation in other parts of the country, but it will be understood that I can
speak from more intimate and personal knowledge of my own district. This
scheme, which covers the whole coalfield, is controlled by a Joint Advisory
Committee representing all the Local Education Authorities in the area. Under
it, a number of Junior and Senior Course Centres have been arranged throughout
the coalfield, leading up to three advanced centres : Swansea in the West,
Treforest in the Centre, and Crumlin in the East.
Actually, two courses are provided, specially arranged for the training of
young engineers for collieries. These are :—
(a) A full-time course (four years on Sandwich System) which is a combined
course in electrical and mechanical engineering. While this is a Diploma
Course, matriculated students taking the course may attend lectures in the
Degree Course, and take the External London University B.Sc. Degree
Examinations in Engineering. To my mind this is essentially the type of course
and training for the student who has ambitions to become in future the chief
engineer.
(b) Part-time day and evening courses in electrical engineering, leading to
Ordinary and Higher National Certificates. A youth entering at 16 years of age
should get his ordinary certificate at 19 and his higher certificate at 21.
This course is common with the mechanical students for the first two years, and
therefore provides suitable and excellent training for the mining electrical
engineer.
It must be realised that with the Sandwich System both mind and body are
undergoing training under conditions which should mould the character according
to the pattern provided. The work of the technical establishments is supervised
by men specially selected not only for their technical attainments but also to
provide the pattern.
It is no less than the duty of the employer to provide facilities for his staff
of employees to obtain such technical training as they may desire. Here one
must include a proviso that the character and application to duty of the
candidate are such that the employer may reasonably expect results from the
technical training he helps to provide, results to his advantage and therefore
to the advantage of the industry as well as to the employee in question.
It always appears to me that there is a risk of too much credit being given to
purely scholastic attainments, whereas we must realise that education covers
more than this, and qualities of leadership and character count heavily when a
balance has to be struck. This is where the individual selection and
encouragement comes in, and I am persuaded to suggest further responsibilities
on the employer.
He should allow a selected number of his apprentices, limited if necessary,
facilities for entering on a Sandwich Course. He should see that any student,
positioned so that evening classes provide the only means of technical
education, can leave work in ample time to change and have a meal before
leaving for the class. As far as possible he should see that the wage-earner
does not lose wages in the endeavour to make himself more efficient.
If travelling is necessary, owing to distance from classes, the employer might
well make such travelling expenses a charge on his profits, in the sure and
certain knowledge of a rich reward in the future.
I would conclude by saying to the Student : lose no opportunity of learning, no
matter from whom, or in what manner the instruction may come.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Haslam, Sidney B. | | President | |