10th August 1940, Page: 37, Column: 1
Steam Boiler Troubles
South African Investigations
In subsequent discussion of the paper read before the South African Institution
of Engineers by Messrs. F. J. Redman and H. A. J. McDonic on
"Some Problems in the Operation and Maintenance of Steam Boiler
Plant,"* Mr. W. O. Andrews made some remarks on the external
corrosion of air-heaters and economisers. Extracts from his contribution are
appended.
By W. O. Andrews.
Investigations have recently been made into the cause and possible remedies of
the external corrosion of air-heaters and economisers with special reference to
the plant installed at the Klip and Vereeniging Power Stations. Special
attention has been paid to the dew point of the gases.
From theoretical considerations and from examinations of deposits found in the
corroded areas it is highly probable that the trouble is initiated by dew
deposited from the flue gases on the relatively cool metal surfaces. By contact
with the sulphurous constituents of the gases the film of moisture is converted
into sulphuric acid, which is the actual corrosive agent. As the products of
corrosion are hygroscopic they remain moist even at temperatures appreciably
above the original dew point. Under these conditions more sulphurous
constituents are absorbed and more acid formed, and so the action continues.
Accepting this theory as correct, it is obviously important to avoid the
initial deposition of moisture. The problem resolved itself into one of
maintaining the inlet air or inlet water at a temperature above the dew point
at all times.
Tests have been carried out in order to determine the temperature at which dew
separates out from the flue gases. From samples of chimney gases abstracted
from the boilers at Klip and Vereeniging under normal operating conditions of
full load, it has been established that the dew point is about 40°C.
Further tests have shown that during periods of steam soot-blowing the dew
point is appreciably raised and may reach about 50°C. The dew point is also
affected by the percentage of excess air used for combustion and increases with
the CO2 content. The exact relation between these two variables has
not yet been determined, but in the meantime it may be assumed to be a straight
line law.
From these tests it was concluded that the temperature of the inlet air to the
air-heaters under full load conditions should be maintained at about 50°C.
in order to ensure that no moisture is deposited. Owing to localised increase
in dew point caused by the use of steam soot-blowers, the blowers in the
air-heaters should not be used. There is less objection to the use of blowers
in the economisers.
A further investigation has been carried out to determine whether dew might be
deposited during the special conditions obtaining when the boiler is started
up. For this purpose a test was carried out at Vereeniging Power Station on a
boiler, the air-heater of which had been partially renewed owing to corrosion.
The air-heaters of this boiler are fitted with air by-passes, the dampers of
which were recently modified to make them more effective. No provision is made
for recirculating the air, which is drawn from a warm position in the boiler
house. The temperature averages about 40°C, but varies between 30 and
60°C. depending largely on atmospheric conditions. The economiser is not
fitted with a gas by-pass.
The method of test was to compare the dew point of the flue gases with the
temperatures of the air-heater and economiser from the time of starting up
until the boiler was on full load. The dew point of the flue gases was
calculated from the dew points of the outer air and of the flue gases at full
load. A knowledge of these figures together with the CO2 content of
the gases enabled the required figure to be obtained.
Before the fires were lit the outer surfaces of the air-heater and economiser
were inspected to make sure they were dry. This precaution is very necessary,
especially after the surfaces have been cleaned by hosing down with water. In
this connection it should be pointed out that it is unwise to hasten the drying
of the economiser by filling it with hot water. If this is done there is danger
that the moisture driven off from the economiser may condense on the cool
surfaces of the air-heater. A better method of drying is to run the fans for a
short period.
In order to prevent moisture from the flue gases depositing on the economiser
during the starting up period the cold water in the tubes was displaced by hot
water from the feed range until the water outlet from the economiser registered
about 50 to 60°C.
At this stage the fires were lit. The air-heater was by-passed on the air side
and observations were made periodically of temperature, dew point, etc., until
the boiler was steaming at full load, a total period of four hours. The initial
dew point of the flue gas was 13°C. and gradually increased to about
40°C., when the boiler was on full load.
Owing to the fact that the economiser was filled with hot water beforehand, the
lowest temperature of the water in the tubes was well above the dew point of
the gases at all times, and the margin of safety was still further increased as
the boiler went on load.
With regard to the air-heater, the conditions are reversed. That is to say,
that there was a satisfactory margin between the air inlet temperature and the
dew point when the flres were lit, but this margin was reduced to only
10°C. when the boiler was on full load.
In the winter months the inlet air temperature, which is not under control, may
be reduced by 10 to 20°C. below the figures obtaining during the present
test. Under these conditions the margin of safety may disappear, especially
during soot-blowing when the dew point is temporarily raised by 5 to 10°C.
From the results of these starting up tests at Vereeniging it was concluded
that there is little risk of corrosion due to deposition of moisture on the
metal surfaces provided the following precautions are taken :—
(1) Examine economiser and air-heater to make sure that they are dry before
lighting the fires.
(2) Fill economiser with hot water.
(3) To avoid raising the dew point too rapidly, take not less than 3½ to 4
hours from time of lighting fires to full load.
It was also concluded that when the boiler was on full load the conditions were
not so satisfactory, as there is danger that dew might form on the air-heaters
in the winter months. The only effective remedy would be to raise the
temperature of the inlet air.
* See "The Science and Art of Mining," No. 14, Vol. 50, page 212.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Andrews, W. O. | | | |
| McDonic, H. A. J. | | | |
| Redman, F. J. | | | |