10th August 1940, Page: 36, Column: 2
Causes Of Rope Deterioration
At the October (1939) meeting of the South African Institution of Engineers a
paper was submitted by Messrs. J. J. P. Dolan and W. G. Jackson
on "An Investigation into the Permissible Load Carrying Capacity of Steel
Wire Ropes for Hoisting, with special reference to Deep Level Winding on the
Witwatersrand Goldfields." A summary was given in No. 13 Vol. 50 of this
journal embodying the Authors' conclusions. Discussion of the paper has been
sustained, and in a written contribution to the Journal of the Institution
Mr. W. B. Carlson (Technical Associate) presents the appended
considerations.
By W. B. Carlson.
Any point in a winding rope may be said to deteriorate through some, or all, of
the following causes :—
(1) Alteration to static stress due to placement and removal of effective load.
(2) The reciprocating stress cycle occurring each wind. (3) Subsidiary higher
frequency stress cycles due to the natural period of vibration, uneven braking,
uneven shaft guides, etc. (4) Kinetic loading stresses. (5) Bending stresses at
sheaf and drum. (6) Torsional stresses. (7) Crushing stresses. (8) Wear. (9)
Corrosion.
Of all these potential causes of deterioration at any selected point in a rope,
not a single one of them may logically be represented by the product of
suspended mass and the distance travelled. It would be as logical to stretch a
wire taut between the front and rear seat of a motor car and claim that the
deterioration of the wire was fundamentally proportional to the product of the
stress in the wire and the distance travelled by the car.
Therefore, it is not the work done by a rope which determines its
deterioration, but that done on it, just as, in a fatigue testing machine, it
is the total work done on the specimen before fracture or some function of this
value, which is taken as the criterion for comparison. The Authors themselves
refer to the total work done on the copes during laboratory tensile fracture
tests, and these are very useful figures, but it is misleading to compare them,
even in a relative manner, with the work done by the ropes. The product of rope
stress and rope stretch bears no relation to the product of rope stress and
distance travelled.
Considering in turn the afore-mentioned causes of rope deterioration, the total
deterioration of any one point in the rope due to them will be as follows
:—
(1) Proportional to the rope stress due to the average effective load, and to
the number of trips made ;
(2) Proportional to the sum of the change in rope stress due to the maximum
hanging length which can occur below the point considered, and the force of
inertia when breaking ; also to the number of trips made ;
(3) Proportional to the degree of disturbance caused by uneven braking and by
shaft guides, and to the total length of time during which they act;
(4) Proportional to the kinetic portion of the rope stresses induced by
loading, and to the number of loadings made ;
(5) Proportional to the stress due to bending, and to the number of trips made
;
(6) Proportional to the torsional stress induced by each change of loading, and
to the number of changes of loading ;
(7) Proportional to the crushing stress induced and to the number of times it
is induced ;
(8) Proportional to the number of times a point in the rope passes a wearing
object, such as the sheaf;
(9) Proportional to time, to corrosive influence, and to the number of stress
cycles (or the number of trips made).
It is therefore apparent that, while loading and number of trips play an
important part in producing rope deterioration, the distance travelled by load
and rope bears little relation thereto.
Some engineers may say that this is all very well, but that, when all is said
and done, it is the work done by a rope which determines its usefulness. The
answer to this is simply that two identical ropes, subjected to different
conditions of service, cannot be expected necessarily to give the same output.
Therefore, if we are to assess rope performance, we must of necessity consider
the prevailing rope treatment.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carlson, W. B. | | Technical Associate | |
| Dolan, J. J. P. | | | |
| Jackson, W. G. | | | |