Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th July 1940, Page: 17, Column: 1

Accidents And Their Prevention

These notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1938. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office.

Surface Accidents

In connection with operations in and about coal mines surface accidents take their toll and are more frequent than may be generally realised. For instance, in the Yorkshire inspection division they represent 11.8 per cent. of all reportable casualties. The percentage is 10.3 in Scotland, 9.2 in the Northern area, 8.6 in the Swansea and Midland and Southern districts, 8.4 in Cardiff and Forest of Dean, and 6.8 in the North Midland and North Western divisions respectively. In view of these proportions it would appear to be admissible and conceivably of advantage to cull some particulars of surface accidents as presented by the Mines Inspectors in their annual reports.

Keep a Proper Outlook.

In Scotland 20 persons were killed in 1938 and 36 were injured as the result of accidents on the surface. In his notes on haulage and transport Mr. T. Ashley observes that three fatalities occurred while moving wagons ; two could have been avoided with ordinary forethought, and the third was caused by a breach of the regulations. A wagon lowerer used a long thin prop while attempting to move stationary wagons by the impact of other wagons on an adjacent line.

Four of the five other fatalities and one of the two non-fatal accidents all occurred to persons walking on or near railway lines and being run down either by locomotives or wagons. In two instances the accidents were partly accounted for by the strong winds that were blowing, but in all, a proper outlook apparently was not kept either by the persons involved or, in some instances, by the locomotive drivers or the attendants in charge of the wagons.

Fence Creeper Gangways.

Creeper gangways should be completely fenced on both sides with post and rail fencing ; and, at the ends, where the tubs enter and leave, horizontal rods should be placed across the tub-track clear of the top of the tubs. Flat iron rods or broad pieces of belting should be suspended from the bars above the track. End fences should be placed well clear of the tumbler holes, which should be covered over to the fullest extent possible. The Inspector adds that a ready means of signalling for starting and stopping the creeper should also be provided, but preferably the creeper, if driven electrically, should be fitted with remote controls placed at both ends of the creeper.

Danger of Loose Garments.

The failure to wear close-fitting garments such as dungarees or boiler suits by persons engaged with machinery — in this instance a crane driver — resulted not in injury to the wearer as usually occurs, but in causing fatal injury to a labourer at a mine in Fife who was standing in a nearly empty railway wagon in which he was shovelling small coal in preparation for it being lifted by a mechanical grab. The crane driver when getting out of the cab caught his jacket on the lever operating the turntable. This swung round the jib with the grab and the latter crushed the labourer against the side of the wagon. The crane driver also failed to put the machinery out of gear before leaving the cab.

Fatality Due to Impatience.

There were 11 surface deaths and 61 persons were injured in the Northern Division.

A boy, aged 14, was crushed between the buffers of two wagons, and died soon afterwards. In the care of a charge-hand whose sole duty it was to supervise boys, he was loading timber into a truck, which was the second of a set of coupled wagons standing in the timber yard. In front of this set, and separated from it by a distance of four feet only, stood another set of five coupled wagons. The chargeman heard a locomotive approaching and walked towards the front of the standing wagons, where he met a shunter who told him he was going to take away the set of five empty wagons. The chargeman said, "Wait until I warn the boy," and turned to do so. The shunter signalled to the driver to push trucks already coupled to the locomotive against the set of five before the chargeman could reach the boy. As soon as the chargeman saw the trucks move he shouted a warning but he found the boy fast between the set of trucks. It would appear that the boy had finished his job and was passing through the four feet space between the wagons to join his foreman when they joined up. In his report Mr. W. J. Charlton says the accident was due entirely to the impatience of the shunter.

A token lad, aged 16, was observed by a weighman to be fast by a foot in a double-link creeper chain which was in motion just outside the weigh cabin. The weighman ran to switch current off the motor driving the chain, a distance of 13 yards, but before the chain came to rest the boy was dragged to the driving drum and fatally injured. The boy's duty was to take tokens off tubs after they had been tipped and take them to the weigh cabin, passing alongside the conveyor on a good floor. The creeper had been in use some 20 years without accident and the boy had done this work for 11 months. It would appear that he had stood on the creeper chain to ride up the short incline.

"Ought Never to have Happened."

Reporting on surface accidents in Yorkshire Mr. H. J. Humphrys informs that 17 persons were killed and 51 seriously injured, compared with 9 and 34 respectively for the previous year. The large percentage increases revealed by these figures are, perhaps, the most unsatisfactory feature of this report. Four of the persons killed were engaged on erection work and were employees of outside firms of contractors. Referring to these the Inspector says it should be pointed out that the managements are responsible for the safety of these outside men employed on colliery premises.

A wagon lowerer was crushed against a masonry pillar under the screening plant by a wagon which was allowed to gravitate towards him for a distance of 33 feet. It became derailed when he attempted to bring it to a standstill by means of a triangular wooden scotch placed across the rails. The rail next the pillar was three-quarters of an inch lower than the other at this point. The wagon should have been accompanied and brought to rest by the brakes. It was wrong to allow it to run unaccompanied and uncontrolled. In new plants clearances should be ample.

Two screenmen were cleaning the track on the low side of an empty wagon standing under the screens. Seventy yards beyond, four empty wagons were standing, held only by a single brake. A shunter lowered two wagons, one containing sand, into the road on which the five wagons were standing. The two bumped into the four, the single brake failed to hold and all ran into the one, which moved forward and fatally crushed the two screenmen. This accident, Mr. Humphrys remarks, ought never to have happened. The shunter should have secured the wagons properly and the men should not have been working in such a position, especially with the screens at work, unless warning flags and a portable stop-block had been provided.

Accident of Distressing Nature.

An unusually distressing fatality occurred on a burning spoil heap which had been on fire several years. It had become a nuisance in the district and the most satisfactory of the many ways tried to abate it was to spread over the whole surface a layer of specially treated line washery reject containing about 70 per cent. of incombustible matter. Upwards of an acre of the heap had been covered by a 1-foot 6-inch layer about 12 months previously and conditions were much improved. The heap continued to burn underneath, however, and it was necessary to spread another layer which it was decided should be 2 feet 6 inches thick. This work was commenced from one side of the spoil heap and a tram track was laid on it. Three labourers tipped a tub of dirt at the edge of the new layer and in rerailing it one of them stood on the original layer. In lifting the tub, the downward pressure of his feet caused him to sink through the thin hard crust into a crevasse of red hot material below. The mass closed in and he was engulfed. Assistance was immediately forthcoming and every effort was made to recover the body, but without avail, for there can be no doubt that it was speedily cremated.

The Wrong Method.

Nine deaths and 33 other casualties in the North Midland Division corresponds closely with recent records, the safety rates being — 159,000 shifts worked above ground per casualty and 787,000 tons per casualty.

A landsale yard attendant asked a motor lorry driver, who had gone to the yard for the purpose of loading coal, to push a wagon of coal with the lorry while he held a 4-foot 6-inch prop between the lorry and the wagon. When the lorry moved backwards the prop slipped and struck him, causing fatal injuries. The yard man was 60 years of age and had been engaged there for many years, and in the view of the Mines Inspector, Mr. G. Cook, should have been well aware of the danger of such a method of pushing wagons.

One of the fatal accidents involved a wagon lowerer at a washery. It was part of his duty to attend a chute some 25 feet above the ground to deflect the washery dirt either on to a conveyor belt or to the wagon as required. He was found between the conveyor belt and the return roller, having apparently slipped and been dragged through an aperture at the side of the belt. Commenting on the accident the Inspector says it shows that adequate fencing of moving parts of machinery is necessary at all points and responsible persons should carefully examine all plant to see that this is done, not only to safeguard persons under normal working conditions, but also to obviate the possibility of persons stumbling and falling when near machinery.

Omitted to Take Precautions.

Lack of ordinary precautions when unloading a railway wagon was responsible for the death of one of the persons engaged on the work. A new steam pipe had been raised on bearers on the top of the wagon with a view to rolling it over and allowing it to fall to the ground. Without first seeing that all was clear the man in charge gave instructions for the pipe to be rolled over the side of the wagon. A prop on the wagon floor had been left projecting out of the door and the pipe falling upon it caused the prop to strike the man as he was attempting to pull it clear.

Accidents to Lads.

There was no fatal accident in Mr. Cook's district to any person under the age of 18 but there were five boys under 16 and three under 18 reportably injured during 1938 compared with the average of 4.3 and 1.7, respectively, over the years 1935-37.

The accidents to the boys under 16 were all of a simple character. Three of them were caused by the boys stumbling and, in falling, fracturing an arm. The other two were caused by tubs. In one case the boy was pushing an empty tub and did not see that another tub was approaching from behind ; and in the other case a boy was helping a labourer to twist a tub on the flat-sheets and his arm was caught between the tub and a fence.

Two of the boys under 18 were injured by wagons moving under the screens whilst they were crossing the rails. One fell and broke his arm and the other was crushed between two wagons as he attempted to cross between them as a short cut instead of following the proper path.

The remaining accident was due to the all too common cause of tubs running from behind whilst pushing at another in front. Although repeated warnings may be given of the danger of pushing at tubs where the tubs usually run by gravity the Inspector thinks more supervision is required in the training of boys when they first commence work to see that they do not fall into this dangerous habit.

Badge Holders Escaped Injury.

Noting the fact that in the year under review two fatal and 30 reportable non-fatal accidents happened on the surface in the North Western Division, a decrease of three and four respectively on the 1937 figures, Mr. E. H. Frazer, the Inspector, says the only comment called for by the fatalities is that boys' bodies and feet are usually smaller than men's and, where there is any possibility of a boy being in the vicinity, machinery fencing should be constructed with that in mind.

The non-fatal accidents would merit little comment either, except for the fact that six of them happened to boys under 17 years of age, none of whom had attended a safety class. Mr. Frazer appends the following particulars and comments :—

A boy of 14 employed in screens was, along with other boys, amusing himself in a meal period by pushing tubs on the pit bank when another tub ran into him from behind and broke his arm. He had no business to be on the pit bank and the surface foreman should have cleared the boys out of harm's reach.

An apprentice fitter, aged 15, was helping to carry an iron pipe. He got cramp or a muscular spasm which, combined with the weight he was supporting, caused a thigh bone to snap. The pipe did not fall on him. The work was unsuitable for that particular lad.

A youth of 16 was descending a ladder from a railway wagon in the slap-dash manner of young folk, when he fell off and hit a wheelbarrow, breaking his arm.

A boy of 15 was running round from one side of the screens to the other when he caught his boot toe on a slightly projecting plank and fell, breaking his arm. He had no occasion to run, but boys like to do it.

A screen boy of 14 put his foot through the framework of a picking table and a nut on the returning empty belt plates jammed it against an upright and broke his ankle. The fencing was not what it should have been where boys were employed.

A boy of 14 was pulling an empty tub when a loose iron on his clog caught a rail and tripped him up. He broke his forearm.

It is significant, the Inspector finally observes, that no reportable accident happened to safety badge holders who form the majority of boys employed.

Unusual Accidents.

Nine persons working on the surface were killed (increase seven) and 35 were injured (increase three) in the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division, of which Mr. J. Macleod Carey is the Inspector. He remarks that two accidents were of a rather unusual kind. Taking the simpler one first, a cylinder cover had been removed from an air compressor by means of an overhead crane and rested on its base beside the compressor. The piston was then removed with the same crane and traversed in the opposite direction. One of the chains from the crane fouled the cylinder cover while the piston was being traversed and toppled it over on to the foreman in charge. Mr. Carey refers to it as an obvious omission not to have seen the chains were clear.

The more extraordinary case is worthy of particular comment. The circumstances were as follows : A leakage had developed in a 22-inch diameter compressed air main, which conveys compressed air to a group of collieries, at a point where the column rose on a slight gradient. A trap for draining water from the system was installed at the bottom of the gradient and was operated twice daily. When the leakage was first noticed a temporary rubber patch was applied and secured in place by bolted glands, enabling work to be carried on until the week-end. On the day of the accident, a foreman and an assistant, together with a welder, were about to execute repairs of a more permanent nature, but apparently for some reason decided to resort again to rubber patching. They put on a thick patch of rubber and secured it in position by a pair of bolted glands. Finding that the leak was not stopped they proceeded to drive wooden cleats between the glands and the pipe. As they were doing this the pipe burst, and was wrenched away from the main column and was subsequently found 88 feet away from its original position. There was a rent, 7 feet 8 inches in length and a maximum width of 1 foot 7 inches extending from the place where the rubber patch was applied to the end of the pipe. An examination of the pipe showed that considerable wastage of the metal had taken place, due probably to the continual collection of water at this particular place. The foreman and the welder were killed by the force of the explosion, and the assistant was severely injured. The air pressure in the main was 80 pounds per square inch.

Accidents Simply Explained.

Five deaths and 15 persons injured in the Swansea area compares favourably with 9 and 25 respectively in 1937. Two of the deaths occurred on sidings, and one of them shows that here as in other inspection districts the elements may combine with other factors to cause an accident. As explained by Mr. P. S. Lea a wagon attendant was crossing the sidings under the screens about 9 p.m. when he was knocked down by a wagon being lowered by another man. The screens and washery were idle at the time but a gale, with heavy rain, was raging. The wagon was only travelling at walking speed but the attendant evidently neither saw nor heard it. The sidings were well lighted electrically.

A screen official, aged 70, descended a ladder from the screens to the sidings and when crossing them was knocked down by wagons pushed by a locomotive, the whistle of which was blown continuously. The exit used by the screen official was not ordinarily used and it is not known where he was going. His eyesight and hearing were good.

A fatal tramway accident involved an underground repairer who was going to work on the night shift. He ascended some steps leading to a tramway between the slant and the screens and was run over by a journey of full trams. The attendant had warned several men of the approach of the journey but the repairer, who had lost the sight of one eye, evidently did not see it. The tramway is electrically lighted.

One fatal accident occurred in connection with machinery. A single-cylindered engine in the screens stalled and the engineman asked a tipper to help him. Steam was shut off the engine and they got inside the fence to turn the flywheel. When it moved the tipper lost his balance, fell and sustained a fracture of the skull. The rim of the flywheel was afterwards slotted to enable a lever to be used.

The Crane Collapsed.

There was also an appreciable improvement in respect of accidents on the surface in the Midland and Southern Division, where three persons lost their lives and nineteen were reportably injured. These figures actually show five fewer persons killed and nine fewer injured as compared with the previous year. Naturally the Inspector, Mr. E. Rowley, is very pleased to report the reduction. His remarks on the fatal accidents are as under :—

A fatal accident occurred to an ash-wheeler who, when pulling an empty skip up a single-line track rising at 1 in 100 from the tip to the boiler house, was run into by a full skip moving in the opposite direction. It was dark and windy at the time, but the track was lighted by 300 candle-power lamps at intervals of 50 yards, and if the ash-wheeler and the man accompanying the full skip had been keeping a look out the accident should not have happened. However, steps were afterwards taken to prevent more than one tub at a time entering the single line.

A scotch derrick crane was being erected on colliery premises by the employees of a firm of constructional engineers, when the crane collapsed and the erector in charge of the jib was fatally injured. At the time of the accident only one land-tie had been weighted, and the cotter-pin intended to keep the gland-irons in position on top of the mast was not in place, but the crane was being used to lift an anchor-weight on to the remaining tie. It is probable that as this was being done the jib touched one of the stays, whereupon the whole structure heeled over and collapsed. Obviously, the crane should not have been used until the anchor-weights were in place on both ties, and the crane as a whole had been examined.

Another accident which terminated fatally might have had but trivial results if the victim had been in a normal state of health. He had grazed his finger whilst shovelling ashes into a mortar mill, and though immediate attention was given at the surface ambulance room, he died sixteen days later primarily from diabetic coma and pyaemia, with infection and suppuration of the injured finger as a secondary cause.

Experienced Men Injured.

Two non-fatal accidents occurred in connection with screening and cleaning plants. During the erection of plant by a firm of constructional engineers, the foreman in charge started up a conveyor belt for a trial run. Some adjustment was found to be necessary and the belt was stopped for this to be done. It was then started again, and finding it to be satisfactory, the foreman went to stop the motor. In his absence his assistant saw some dirt on the tension drum and tried to remove it with a piece of wood. The wood slipped, and the man's arm was drawn in between the belt and the drum. The drum could have been cleaned quite easily with the power switched off and, comments Mr. Rowley, it was extremely stupid of an experienced man to take such unnecessary risks.

The other accident happened to a screen foreman who, during a temporary stoppage of the picking belts whilst extra dirt was being removed, went through a gate in the fence surrounding the driving gear apparently just for a general look round. Noticing some obstruction on the underside of a conveyor, he was leaning over some bevel gears to remove it when the machinery was started up and his leg was caught and severely lacerated. The foreman had not told any of the screen hands where he was going, and quite naturally the signal, to start up was given as soon as the extra dirt had been cleared. The man should not have attempted to go through the fence, the Inspector observes, until he had made arrangements for the machinery not to be restarted until he himself gave the signal.

Although there was no contravention of Section 55 in this case, Mr. Rowley takes the opportunity of pointing out that a surround fence does not necessarily provide adequate protection. For instance, in large screening plants it may be that a single continuous fence surrounds several separately driven pieces of plant. Circumstances may arise where it is desired to give some attention to one part of this plant whilst the other parts are still in motion. In such cases each individual piece of plant must be adequately protected.

The Inspector concludes by noting in connection with the four accidents in the machinery section that three happened to highly experienced men, two of them being employed by firms of constructional engineers. It is, he fears, a case of "familiarity breeding contempt" — an attitude which can be overcome only by insistence upon proper discipline.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ashley, Theodore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Carey, Joseph Macleod    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Cook, George    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Frazer, Edgar Hamilton    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Humphrys, Herbert John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lea, Paul Salthouse    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Rowley, Elijah    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jul 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Jul 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Aug 1940  Notes On Safety Organisation (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Aug 1940  Notes On Safety Organisation. — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Sep 1940  Training Boys In Safety Principles (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Sep 1940  Health, Welfare And Education (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print