|
29th June 1940, Page: 401, Column: 1 Accidents And Their PreventionThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1938. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Miscellaneous Underground Accidents. Ignition by Coal-cutter Picks. In his Scotland report Mr. T. Ashley refers to two ignitions in the undercut which occurred in the Hartley Seam at a Stirlingshire colliery, in the same section and within five days of one another. He says there have been similar ignitions in this seam before, but previously they occurred in different sections. Usually the seam is underlain by about 12 inches of soft fireclay before a hard sandstone is found, but in this section, which was approaching a fault, the fireclay was replaced by a dough varying from one-half inch to two inches thick, the sandstone below having an irregular rolling surface. Dr. H. Hyde, Junior Inspector of Mines, who investigated the occurrence, states "Specimens of the sandstone in the pavement on the face in which the ignitions took place were examined and compared with others from an adjacent face with normal strata. A hand specimen of the former showed it to be a fine grained, finely laminated grey sandstone with numerous thin films of carbonised plant material with which a small amount of pyrite was associated. Subsequent to deposition and consolidation the rock had been subjected to slight shearing movements and the pyrite, originally molecular, had been flattened into thin films. Microscopic examination showed a fine, even grained structure with carbonaceous films and threads of bituminous material, but pyrite was not identified in the thin sections. Hand specimen and microscopic examinations of the sandstone from normal strata showed it to be similar to the above but of coarser grain and undisturbed since deposition. The main relevant difference between the two specimens is in the grain size, the rock which caused the ignitions being much finer than the normal rock and so probably more liable to produce sparks." Safety Interests Considered. Discussing accidents arising out of the use of coal-cutters Mr. Ashley voices the opinion that it would be in the interest of safety if all coal-cutting machines were made or altered where possible so that it was not necessary for the assistant machineman to go to the gearhead end of the machine to operate the handle engaging and disengaging the cutting chain. In some makes this can be done from the driving end. The only accident that occurred in Scotland while actually cutting was due to the picks striking an ironstone nodule causing the machine to kick out. Unfortunately the gummer was working by the side of the machine instead of at the back, and his leg was crushed between the machine and a conveyor. None of the accidents which were caused by contact with the cutting picks could have been prevented by the use of a guard, because no guard can be used during the operations that were being carried out at the time. A guard, however, is essential when the machine is cutting and there are several types in use, but the spiral "gummer" with the deflection plate covering the exposed part of the chain forms a most effective guard, and, with the "gummer" fitted to the machine, so long as the chain is in the cut it is not possible for contact to be made with any part of the chain or picks. Trailing Cable Accident. At a Cumberland mine in the Northern Division two hewers were killed by electric shock, and Mr. W. J. Charlton in giving particulars of the accident says a seam 20 inches in thickness was worked longwall and was undercut by an electrically-driven coal-cutting machine, the coal being filled into tubs at the roadheads of gateways 13 yards apart. The gate-end switch was on a main dip and the trailing cable led from it along a level gateway to the face, a distance of 28 yards. At 20 yards a branch gate was turned off to the left on a gradient of 1 in 10 and in that gate two hewers were filling ripping dirt into tubs. The machineman told the hewers that as there were no props at the junction on the gateway he would have to leave the trailing cable on the floor, and they must be careful to avoid it. Some time later, the machineman got a slight shock. He left the face, and on reaching the junction found a full tub on the flatsheet there. He appears to have touched the tub and got a shock, for when his marrow, who had left the face by another gateway, got round to the junction, having switched the current off at the gate-end switch as he passed it, he found the two hewers lying unconscious and the coal-cutter attendant sitting in a dazed condition. Artificial respiration was tried on the two hewers but they were dead. Investigation revealed that the tub had run on to the trailing cable, and a wheel had made contact with one of the live conductors. The current was alternating, at 600 volts, neutral point earthed. The trailing cable was cab tyre sheathed with four cores. The cause of the accident was failure to suspend the trailing cable at the junction, or otherwise place it in a safe position. Colliery Notice to Shot-firers. Mr. H. J. Humphrys, the Yorkshire Inspector in Charge, has reproduced the notice to deputies and shot-firers at the Park Mill and Emley Moor Mines of Messrs. Stringer and Son Ltd., as follows :— "Your particular attention is again drawn to all the provisions of the Coal Mines Act, and of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order, and especially to the following points :— (1) A shot-firer must always: (a) Charge and fire one shot only at a time. (b) Examine all contiguous accessible places within 20 yards of a shot-hole immediately before and immediately after firing. (c) Couple up the cable to the detonator wires himself. (d) See that all persons nearby have taken proper shelter. (e) Take suitable steps to prevent any person approaching the shot. (f) Couple up the cable to the battery himself when he is in a position of safety. (g) Keep the handle off the battery until immediately before the shot is to be fired, and a few seconds before attaching the handle of the battery he must shout the word FIRE and listen for any reply to his warning. (h) Keep the removable handle of the battery on his own person at all times. (2) It is absolutely forbidden to charge any hole in which a break has been found. (3) The minimum length of scrapers and stemmers are:
(4) It is the duty of all deputies to see that all scrapers and stemmers in use that are less than the above are immediately exchanged for new ones of the proper lengths. (5) The rate of firing shots shall not at any time exceed six per hour." Call for Improved Conditions. A machineman received a slight shock when operating a four horse-power heading machine supplied with current at 600 volts direct current. It was due to leakage across the insulation of the plug connecting the incoming cable to the control switch owing to mud and water having entered the plug. In Mr. Humphrys' view, however, the use of this pressure on such small machines is not justified and entails unnecessary risk owing to the small clearances employed. He is glad to say the machine in question was replaced by another operating at 123 volts alternating current. He has objected to such a high pressure for these small machines in other instances. A filler was injured in circumstances which might have had much more serious results. A set of six full tubs was allowed to gravitate unattended, with the result that it came into violent contact with a cable carrying current at 600 volts alternating current suspended from the roadway supports near the point where it entered a circuit breaker controlling a haulage motor. The consequence was that the casting of the switch was broken and the cable drawn completely out of it. The filler was called to the place by a haulage hand and in stepping over the live cable ends received a shock which caused him to collapse against a prop. A man who attempted to pull him away received a shock but he was disengaged in a minute or two, when it was found his left thumb was severely burnt. The cable was said to have been suspended clear of the moving tubs, and if this is so the banger must have broken and it is obvious that due consideration should be given to this possibility, and the method and manner of suspension should be such that the failure of the suspension does not involve such dire possibilities as might have occurred here. Tightening Up Supervision. A chain coal-cutting machine was being manoeuvred into position for commencing the cut in a seam 2 feet 3 inches thick. As the jib was hard up against the face the chain was revolved as the jib was slewed round. One of the machinemen was in a kneeling position within three feet of the end of the jib in order to get a close view, but when the jib cleared the face the tension was released and it jumped forward and the machineman was fatally injured by the revolving picks. The supervision was deficient, for two overmen were present and they should have restrained the machineman from taking up such a dangerous position. After the accident the manager circularised officials and machinemen instructing them (1) that the chain should not be revolved out of the cut unless absolutely necessary, (2) if it is necessary persons must be at least four yards from the revolving picks, and (3) when necessary to approach nearer, the machine must be stopped and not restarted until the person is at least four yards away. Failed to Fulfil G.R. Whilst no fatalities due to the use of electricity were reported in the North Midland Division, there were five non-fatal accidents, and the Divisional Inspector, Mr. G. Cook, refers to four of them in the following terms: At one mine an electrician went to investigate the cause of a gate-end switch tripping out. The switch was of a hand operated type and the ingoing cable was attached by means of a five-pin flit-plug, the arrangements being such that, unless the flit-plug was in position, the no-volt coil of the switch was so energised and the switch could not be closed. Although his assistant suggested that the supply to the switch should be cut off at the sub-station he was over-ruled by the electrician who unbolted and withdrew the plug, which was alive, and proceeded to examine the switch. After making some adjustment he re-connected the flit-plug and, with the door of the switch removed, operated it with the pressure on. Further adjustment being necessary, the flit-plug was again removed and, in cleaning it before replacing it for the second time, the electrician touched the live contacts and received a shock and burns. The injured man's actions were negligent in the extreme and might have resulted in a serious accident. Ho failed to fulfil General Regulations (Electricity) 127 (iv) and 131 (g). In two of the other cases (one by a chief electrician) examinations of switches were being made with the covers removed and the power on, and while doing so they came into contact with the live parts of the switch. Another accident involved a youth of 18½ years who was adjusting the contacts of a starter of a face conveyor. Just as he completed the work on one conveyor, a filler informed him that the conveyor on the other side of the face was not working properly and be went to. examine this. In the confusion arising from the opening and closing of the switches to try out the latter conveyor he had either forgotten to open the isolator of the gate-end box for the second conveyor before commencing to adjust the contacts of the starter, or the filler had closed the isolator by mistake when he went to switch the current on for the first conveyor. In any event, Mr. Cook remarks, a youth of this age could not be considered competent to undertake such work as this, which required technical knowledge and experience. When the Haulage Stopped. In this Division two fatal accidents caused by coal-cutting machines occurred during cutting operations. In one, the machine chargeman became alarmed by a small fall of roof in front of the machine. He cut off the haulage gear but did not stop the cutters and attempted to crawl over the machine. He slipped as he was doing so and his right foot went over the face side of the machine and was caught by the cutter picks. The machine was fitted with a guard but this could not protect the cutter chain at the leading side into which he fell. In the other, a jib man was lifting a piece of coal, which had fallen on the machine, when it broke in his hands and caused him to lose his balance. He slipped feet-first towards the chain and the revolving picks dragged him into the cut. In this case also the haulage had been stopped but the cutter chain was left running. In a case of stoppage of the haulage due to the crossing of the signal wires, the man in charge of the hauler went to correct the fault, and returning 25 minutes later started up the electric motor with the drum-clutch out. He then heard the driving belt slipping, so he switched off the current. On investigating, he discovered a youth trapped between the 16-inch belt and a four-foot diameter pulley and so severely injured that he died later. The youth, who was eighteen years of age, had climbed two fences to reach the place and had lain down on the belt sad gone to sleep whilst the hauler was standing. Danger of Dual Control. One of the non-fatal accidents illustrates the danger of dual control of a haulage gear and also, Mr. Cook adds, the necessity for bringing all greasing points to the outside of the fencing where they can be attended to in safety. Two haulage attendants were authorised to work the motor of an auxiliary electric hauler and to assist in manipulating empty tubs at the loading point. The switch controlling the hauler was positioned close to where they attended the tubs, and unless there was something wrong it was not necessary to go to the hauler. A bearing on the hauler had been heating during the shift and during a stand period one of the men had gone to screw down a grease cup which necessitated putting his hand over the fence. In the mean- time there was a signal to start and the other man shouted to the first and, thinking he got a reply, started the hauler; the result was that the first man was caught in the gearing of the machinery and sustained a broken arm. Alternatives to Shot-firing. Coal-bursters are, to an increasing extent, replacing explosives for bringing down coal, and occasionally ripping. Pointing out that in 11138 thirty-eight new coal-bursters were put into use in the North Western Division, Mr. E. H. Frazer says that in a full year this number would eliminate something like a quarter of a million shots, that is, practically three per cent. of all shots fired in the Division. One big advantage that hydraulic coal-bursters have over explosives is that it is unnecessary to withdraw men from a face when coal is being got down. In these days of intensive mining, when man-density in conveyor faces is high, it may mean a saving of more than a man-hour per shot, besides the saving in cost of explosives and shot-firer's wages. To this the Inspector adds that the quality of coal is improved, roofs are less disturbed, and the risk of an explosion is reduced. H.M. Inspectors are urging the adoption of hydraulic bursters, and/or pneumatic picks in every face where shot-firing is undesirable on account of the possibility of firedamp emissions. Cardox as a substitute for explosive is finding favour slowly but surely. Experiments conducted at seven North Staffordshire pits have demonstrated that there is no danger in firing shots simultaneously, if Cardox or Hydrox is used, because the risk entailed by a miss-fire with either is non-existent. The trials have disclosed so far no case of a miss-fire that would not have occurred if every shell had been connected singly to an exploder. The few miss-fires have all been traced to some other cause than simultaneous firing. Isolated instances have occurred when the sheath had been removed from a sheathed cartridge by a shot-firer, who evidently failed to appreciate that it was a safety device and for some trivial, or perhaps merely fanciful, advantage, was prepared to risk the lives of many of his fellow workers. Unsafe Practices Disclosed. A driller was standing with his right foot near the jib of a statutory coal-cutting machine, in order to drill a shot-hole in coal with a percussive drill. A coal-cutter attendant coupled up the hose pipes from the mains to the machine and called for air to be turned on. Coincidently with this operation a fall of roof clod occurred, part of which struck the air-valve lever on the machine and opened it to such an extent that the cutter chain and picks were set in motion. The driller's clog was caught by the picks and, before the coal-cutterman could get to the machine to turn off the air, the driller was dragged against the face and fatally lacerated. The accident disclosed unsafe practices by machinemen. The clutch should have been taken out when the machine was left, so that if the engine started it could not move the picks, and the machineman should have been at the starting handle when air was turned on. Acetylene Gas Explosion. In his report on the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division Mr. J. Macleod Carey makes brief reference to and conveys the lesson of a small explosion of acetylene gas which occurred at a very wet mine where the workmen use acetylene lamps. The necessary calcium carbide is taken in and out of the mine in tins, and is not normally stored in the mine. On the occasion of the accident, carbide was left overnight in a powder canister in one of the working stalls. The collier and his assistant, on arriving at their working place next morning, went to get carbide from the canister. As soon as the lid was opened, gas was ignited by one of the naked lights and both men were seriously burned, the assistant later succumbing to his injuries. Water must have got into the canister during the night and generated the gas to form an explosive mixture. Carbide should not, therefore, be left in the mine. Inspector wants Practice Stopped. In Paper No. 4 on "The Safe Use of Explosives in Coal Mines," issued by the Safety in Mines Research Board, the question of joints between cartridges in a shot-hole is discussed and illustrated by diagrams. It is there stated "The importance of using one cartridge only wherever possible will be realised. When more than one cartridge must be used, as few as possible should be placed in a shot-hole, and the hole should be cleaned as free from dust as possible." Mr. P. S. Lea in his Swansea report considers that this Paper should be supplied to all officials and he trusts the recommendations will be carried out. In all cases which have come to his notice the matter has been taken up with the colliery company concerned and larger sizes of cartridges have been obtained. To send a shot-firer to fire ripping shots with only two-ounce cartridges is unfair to a hard-worked official, and he asks managers to take steps to stop the practice. Accident Whilst Flitting Machine. The description of one accident given by Mr. Lea may be quoted, thus: Two cuttermen were in charge of an electrically driven overhead chain machine working in a seam 1 foot 6 inches thick overlain by 10 inches of rashings in which the cut was made. Normally there was 3¼-inch clearance between the picks and the roof. The face had been standing and, owing to subsidence, part of a cut was made in the weak clift roof. The men were instructed to flit the machine, so they swung the jib back over the body of the machine and locked it in that position. They started to flit but found the picks were scraping the roof. They dragged it back and decided to cut the roof as they went along. The chain was started, and while it was running one of them crept into a space of 1 foot 6 inches between the machine and the face to get hold of the haulage rope. He was caught by the picks and fatally injured. The chain should not have been started up. The roof was weak and any obstruction could have been moved by means of a hand pick. A guard was provided for normal working of the machine. Detonators in Metal Case Exploded. An accident is referred to by Mr. E. Rowley of the Midland and Southern Division which he says brought to light a danger not usually appreciated. A shot-firer, carrying a metal canister containing 56 low tension detonators, went into a telephone recess to leave his jacket, and inadvertently placed the canister on top of an uncovered battery of eight leclanche cells. Immediately there was an explosion which shattered the canister, and so severely damaged the shot-firer's right hand that it had to be amputated. Experiments showed that in certain circumstances detonators inside a metal case could be exploded quite easily when the case made contact with opposite poles of a similar battery of cells, or even one of lower voltage. Following this accident the metal canisters were replaced by leather cases at the colliery in question, and throughout the Division either leather cases or metal canisters with an insulating lining are now in use. Experiment Succeeded. At a colliery in Warwickshire an interesting development is in the cutting of the seam top and bottom. Formerly the seam, which is 3 to 4½ feet thick, was worked normally with a machine cutting in the bottom fireclay. As difficulty was experienced with the friable carbonaceous shale roof, it was decided to try the experiment of taking another cut in the top, leaving six inches of coal next the shale roof. The bottom cut is made first, and the top one some four to five hours later. The result has been improved roof conditions, cleaner coal, less slack and a reduction of about 50 per cent. in the number of shots required. Old Plans Unreliable. An inrush of water occurred at a colliery in Somerset, and though fortunately no person was involved, Mr. Rowley says it is of interest as showing the unreliability of old plans and the dangers which may arise therefrom. He gives the following particulars: The colliery had been worked for over 100 years, and plans of the Globe Seam in which the inrush occurred showed workings to the dip of the shafts. These workings were undated but were probably at least 80 years old. The modern workings were advancing to the rise towards this old waste around which a barrier of some 46 yards wide had been demarcated. When the most advanced working place arrived some ten yards from the barrier line droppers of water appeared in the roof, and there was some bleeding in the coal itself. The face was stopped and a number of boreholes were driven to a length of ten yards in advance. Owing to difficulties in boring, these operations took some time and the water in the roof and coal dried up. As the boreholes also proved dry, the management came to the conclusion that the water was contained naturally in the strata, and had no connection with the old workings. They therefore decided to resume work in the places farthest away from the barrier. The position had, however, been kept under observation by H.M. Inspectors, and on their advice this decision was reversed and all work in the seam was stopped pending the proving of the waste with suitable precautions. Less than 48 hours later, when there was nobody in the seam, water broke through the coal face at a point some 80 yards away from the nearest part of the old workings as shown on the plan. Although the bottom level was flooded, it was possible, owing to the high inclination of the seam, to get along the top airway to the point of inrush, when it was seen that a hole of about three feet square had been burst through the face, and that the rush of water had swept out props and rails from the jig and piled up debris along the face. The lesson — that little or no reliance can be placed upon old plans — is obvious. It should also be noted that the "old men" could and did work to the dip on a high inclination. Mr. Rowley concludes that in this instance it is supposed that the method adopted by them was to draw tubs of coal or water up the incline to the shaft bottom by means of a tail rope attached to the bottom of the cage.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||