|
18th May 1940, Page: 358, Column: 1 Bord-And-Pillar-Broken WorkingsExtracts from the North of England Safety in Mines Research Committee's "Sixth Progress Report of an Investigation into the Causes of Falls in Bord-and-Pillar Workings-Broken Workings," presented by Mr. Arthur Walker (Investigator) at the April meeting of the Institute. Method of Working. The driving of bords and walls divides a coal seam into a series of pillars which form the main support for the general roof mass in whole workings ; the pillars contain a proportion of from 50 to 80 per cent. of the original seam. In shallow workings the bords are often wider and nearer together than the walls (walls from 2 to 3 yards and bords 4 to 6 yards wide), forming rectangular pillars which may be as small as 5 x 10 yards. In the deeper seams, bords and walls are generally of equal width, from 4 to 6 yards, and the pillars are frequently square with sides 40-50 yards in length. Pillars are generally extracted by "lifts" about 15 feet in width, driven along the edges adjoining the goaf. By this means the size of each pillar is gradually reduced until only a "stook" about 15 feet square remains ; this is removed in one operation by driving forward with two loose ends. There are many variations of the method of extracting pillars by lifts, depending upon local conditions and considerations of haulage. Since the introduction of machine mining, pillars have been extracted in some instances by retreating longwall faces extending the length of one pillar or along several pillars in series. The original method of working the bord-and-pillar system was to develop whole workings over a large area before commencing to extract the pillars by retreating broken workings. The bords and walls frequently collapsed, with the result that new roads had to be made through them in developing broken workings. The modern practice is to extract the pillars as soon as possible after they are formed, leaving only sufficient pillars for the support of the main roadways. Nature of Roof Loads. Investigations in whole workings have shown that the driving of narrow roadways results in the development of a pressure arch above each roadway ; the beds within the pressure arch bend slightly and no longer carry the weight of the overlying mass of strata. An increase in the width of a working place increases the span of the pressure arch above it and so increases the load carried by the arch. It follows that in wide workings, brokens or longwall, the weight of a much larger mass of the strata above the excavation will be transmitted to the remaining solid coal than is transmitted to the coal in front of narrow workings, and the effect of transmitted pressure will be much more marked. Where the roof consists of shale it has been observed that a structure closely resembling cleat occurs in the roof in advance of the face of some longwall workings. This has been described as "induced cleavage," and while it is common in longwall workings it has not been found to occur in whole or broken bord-and-pillar workings. Observations made in a seam where longwall conveyor faces were won out by whole workings showed that this induced cleavage gradually developed as the longwall face was advanced from the pillars. The seam is 3½ feet thick at a depth of 600 feet, and the roof consists of a bed of shale about 15 feet thick. Gradual development of induced cleavage as the width of the goaf increases is evidence of an increasing pressure upon the coal in advance of the face. Roof conditions in the gateway were very good in the vicinity of the face, but showed marked deterioration at about 100 yards back from the longwall face. A record of the extent of height reduction, obtained by an auto-recorder set within the pack at the side of the gateway, showed a gradually reducing rate of convergence until the face had advanced 97 yards from the instrument; thereafter there was a greatly increased rate of convergence while the face was driven a further 6 yards, after which a fall of roof displaced the recorder. The rate of convergence was very low afterwards and height reduction had practically ceased when the face had advanced 160 yards from the recorder. Careful observations in broken workings in the seam showed that no induced cleavage was developed in the roofs. This appears to be due to the reduction of constraint afforded by the whole workings. The coal pillars, and to some extent the roof beds, are free to move laterally ; this lateral movement will cause the pressure above the pillars to spread over a greater area, and therefore to be of less unit intensity, than when it acts upon unworked coal in advance of a longwall face. Loading Conditions in Broken Workings. The effect of lateral relief afforded by the driving of whole workings is to cause the forward-pressure zone, above coal pillars, to cover a greater area than would be the case if it was carried upon solid coal. The pressure per unit area on pillars in broken workings will thus tend to be less than that on the solid coal in front of a longwall face at a similar depth, but whereas longwall faces are now generally more or less straight in direction the line of retreat in broken workings is often very irregular. As a result, whereas the roof pressure tends to be evenly distributed along the whole length of a longwall face, except at a fast end, concentration of pressure in a limited area in broken workings may result in a higher local pressure than in longwall workings in the same seam. It is suggested that greatly improved roof conditions would result if local concentration of pressure were avoided by maintaining a regular line of retreat, as straight as possible, in broken workings. A common method of broken working is to extract the pillars in triangular formation. It results in the pillar which projects into the goaf being loaded by concentrated pressure set up by the goaf behind the pillars and by the goaves to the right and left on each side. This causes abnormal crushing of the pillar and so results in the transference of part of the pressure to the pillars more remote from the goaf. It is a common practice to extract the pillar which projects into the goaf by means of two "splits" at right angles driven through the middle of the pillar. By this means more men can be employed to extract the pillar, and the view is often expressed that this reduces the time and expense of dealing with the trouble behind the face, but there is a tendency for the trouble to be intensified during the shorter time taken. Good results have been obtained in many instances where pillars have been extracted by modified longwall systems of working in which a more regular line of retreat, very often a straight line, is maintained. The good effect of stone packs when used in such workings must not, of coarse, be overlooked. It will be generally agreed that the avoidance of areas of concentrated pressure will result in improved working conditions, and the principal objection to maintaining a straight line of retreat with this end in view is a practical one, namely, that there would be a tendency to limit the output to a lower level than can otherwise be obtained, owing to the employment of fewer coal-getters and difficulties caused by ridding through fallen roadways which would tend to retard work across the whole face of the district. These difficulties could be overcome if a regular goaf line was maintained by working a series of pillars with the extraction of each pillar one lift in advance of the adjoining pillar. By this means the old workings will be met with by each pillar in succession, any number of pillars can be worked simultaneously in a district, and the only practical objection is that the full output from a district is only obtained after some delay. Coal Left in Whole Pillars. The proportion of coal left in pillars varies from 50 per cent. in the shallower seams to about 80 per cent. in the deeper seams. Depth is not the only factor to be considered, however, because while the depth determines the magnitude of the load to be supported by the pillars, the thickness and strength of the coal and the first beds of the roof and floor are important factors, as they determine the maximum load which a pillar of a given area will carry. Observations of the pre-formed fractures generally known as "holing breakers," which are found above the coal pillars and are parallel with the old bords and walls, have shown that they occur at distances of from 1 to 19 feet from the sides of the old roadways. These breakers have the appearance of small faults generally hading towards the roadway, and the breaker nearest to the middle of the pillar generally has a dip of a few inches into the pillar. The breakers are not always present, and at considerable depths they frequently do not occur where the roof consists of sandstone, sandy shale or, in some cases, of very strong shale. It is apparent, that the distance from the pillar edge at which the breakers are found will have an important bearing on the degree of support afforded by the pillars and so upon the optimum size of pillar to be formed, because the effective area of a pillar is the area within the breakers. It is probable that the time factor will have a bearing on the occurrence of those fractures, as they will tend to extend further into the pillars with the passage of time. Strength of Pillars During Extraction. A common method of extraction is to split the pillars into two, and in some cases four, by means of narrow roadways driven through the middle of the pillars ; the smaller pillars are then removed by lifts. The advantages gained by this method are that more men can be employed and the pillars are more quickly extracted than when lifts are driven along the edges of the pillars. It has been noted that, in some seams, pillars could be satisfactorily worked in this way, while in other seams pillars of equal size could not be so worked. This is apparently due to differences in the strength of the coal and the containing strata, relative to the depth, in the two cases. The splitting of one or two pillars adjoining the goaf edge, where the pillars are initially ample in strength for the loads they have to carry, is not likely to have any harmful effect, but it is a common fault that the driving of places splitting the pillars is carried on to too great an extent, adjoining pillars being split as far as four or five pillars distant from the goaf edge. Owing to the yielding of these small pillars the pressure is transferred backwards from the goaf edge on to the larger pillars, and the increased pressure may cause deterioration of conditions on the roadways rather remote from the goaf, over which roads a large proportion of the coal must be hauled. It is clear that the avoidance of narrow splits driven through the pillars must result in conservation of the support afforded by the pillars and will tend to keep the pressure area nearer to the goaf, so avoiding excessive pressure on the roadways more remote from the face. Stone Packs in Goaf. It has been suggested that better roof conditions would result if uniform distribution of pressure were secured by maintaining straight lines of retreat, but in some cases, besides this, it may be necessary to effect an actual reduction of pressure on the pillars. This may be done by building stone packs in the goaf. These packs are advantageous under many conditions, particularly where pillars have originally been formed too small in size for the roof load they have to carry, or where the original pillars have been reduced in size (robbed) by subsequent skirtings. In cases where the pillars are extracted by longwall gates advancing from the pillared area into the goaf, packs are built at the gate-sides as the gates are advanced, and where they are extracted by retreating longwall faces waste packs may be equally useful. Direction of Face Line. Observations in several seams have shown that roof conditions deteriorate in bord-lifts if the fast-end side of the face of the lift is kept in advance. It is seldom that the direction of the walls is exactly that of the cleat, so that the bords do not cut the cleat exactly at right angles. The result of this is that, as the face of the bord-lifts is generally driven on the line of the cleat, where lifts are turned away to the right and left from a wall the loose-end side of one and the fast side of the other are kept in advance. The effect of driving the face of a lift with the fast side leading is more or less comparable to driving a very narrow working into the solid coal. This will result in concentration of stress at the fast side of the face and consequently greater risk of roof damage there. Roof Support in Pillar Extraction. It is usual to support the roofs of broken lifts across the whole width of each lift, 4 or 5 yards, by two rows of planks, and, in addition, hardwood chocks are frequently set in line down the middle of the lift. In three seams the supports between the chocks and the goaf side of the lift were experimentally withdrawn to within 4 yards of the face as the lift was driven. These seams were all at depths of more than 1,000 feet and the roofs consisted of shale. In all these cases great improvement in the roof conditions was apparent when the loose-end side timber was withdrawn. In two other seams, however, at similar depths where the roofs were of shale and sandstone, respectively, withdrawal of the supports near the loose end was followed by "weighting" of the roof and its collapse. The principal difference between the conditions where success and failure attended the experiment was that in the former case pre-formed breakers (holing breakers) existed in the roofs of the lifts, while in the latter case no such breakers existed. Further experiments were directed to determining the effects of the withdrawal of this timber and the conditions necessary for it to lead to improvement in roof conditions. The results were not conclusive at the time when the experiments were discontinued, but it appears that where the roof-bed is strong and unbroken the withdrawal of these supports may have an adverse effect. Summary. The gradual development of cleavage-planes in a shale roof above the solid coal, where the width of a narrow working is increased by driving a longwall face, is an indication that the roof pressure on the coal in front of the face increases as the face advances from the solid coal, or from pre-formed pillars, until it reaches a normal load due to longwall working in that seam. The development of this induced cleavage, together with observations of roof conditions behind the face, indicates conditions similar to those previously shown to be developed above narrow workings. Roof pressures are very similar in broken workings to those in longwalls, but in the former no induced cleavage has been found in the shale roofs. This is explained by the reduced constraint in an area of pillars, as compared with an area of solid coal, which causes the pressure on the pillars to be spread over a larger area and, therefore, to be of less unit intensity. Observations in workings in an upper seam have disclosed effects which can be explained by subsidence caused by longwall or broken workings in a seam below. Present methods of broken working often result in areas of concentrated pressure near the goaf edge. Extraction of pillars on a straight line of retreat will result in an even distribution of pressure across the pillars adjoining the goaf, and will reduce the extent of roof damage. Stone packs built in the goaf will result in a reduction of pressure and may be advantageous in some circumstances. The size of coal pillars formed in whole working generally increases with depth, but the strength and thickness of the seam and the immediate roof- and floor-beds are important factors for consideration when deciding on the optimum size of pillars in a given case. The extraction of pillars by means of narrow roadways driven through them is good practice only where the strength of the pillars is more than ample for the loads they have to carry, because such roadways reduce the strength of a pillar in a proportion much greater than that of the coal so extracted. The strength of a pillar during extraction is best conserved by means of lifts driven along the pillar edges. It has been observed that roof damage is less when the loose-end side of the face of a lift is kept in advance than it is when the fast side is leading. Where pre-formed breakers occur in the roofs above coal pillars the extent of roof damage can often be reduced by withdrawing all timber from between the centre chocks and the goaf to within 4 yards of the face as the lift is advanced. Some experiments have suggested that where no pre-formed breakers occur the withdrawal of these supports may have an adverse effect.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||